Abstract:Spatial patterns in population trends, particularly those at fine geographic scales, can help better understand the factors driving population change in North American birds. The standard trend models for the North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) were designed to estimate changes in relative abundance through time (trend) within broad geographic strata, such as countries, Bird Conservation Regions, U.S. states, and Canadian territories or provinces. Calculating trend estimates at the level of the BBS's individual survey transects ("routes") allows exploration of finer spatial patterns and estimation of the effects of covariates, such as habitat loss or annual weather, on both relative abundance and trend. Here, we describe four related hierarchical Bayesian models that estimate trends for individual BBS routes. All four models estimate route-level trends and relative abundances using a hierarchical structure that shares information among routes, and three of the models share information in a spatially explicit way. The spatial models use either an intrinsic Conditional Autoregressive (iCAR) structure or a distance-based Gaussian Process (GP) to estimate the spatial components. We fit all four models to data for 71 species and then, because of the intensive computations required, fit two of the models (one spatial and one non-spatial) for an additional 216 species. In a leave-future-out cross-validation, the spatial models outperformed the non-spatial models for 284 out of 287 species. The best approach to modeling the spatial components depends on the species being modeled; the Gaussian Process had the highest predictive accuracy for 69% of the species tested here and the iCAR was better for the remaining 31%. We also present two examples of route-level covariate analyses focused on spatial and temporal variation in habitat for Rufous Hummingbird ( Selasphorus rufus ) and Horned Grebe ( Podiceps auritus ). In both examples, the inclusion of covariates improved our understanding of the patterns in the rate of population change for both species. Route-level models for BBS data are useful for visualizing spatial patterns of population change, generating hypotheses on the causes of change, comparing patterns of change among regions and species, and testing hypotheses on causes of change with relevant covariates. The post Patterns and drivers of population trends on individual Breeding Bird Survey routes using spatially explicit models and route-level covariates first appeared on Avian Conservation and Ecology.

Evaluating trade-offs in spatial versus temporal replication when estimating avian community composition and predicting species distributions

Adaptive sampling by citizen scientists improves species distribution model performance: A simulation study

The influence of sampling scheme and interpolation method on the power to detect spatial effects of forest birds in Ontario (Canada)

Spatiotemporal modelling of abundance from multiple data sources in an integrated spatial distribution model

A comparison of monitoring designs to assess wildlife community parameters across spatial scales

Supplemental structured surveys and pre-existing detection models improve fine-scale density and population estimation with opportunistic community science data

The shadow model: how and why small choices in spatially explicit species distribution models affect predictions

Evaluating community-wide temporal sampling in passive acoustic monitoring: A comprehensive study of avian vocal patterns in subtropical montane forests

Patterns and drivers of population trends on individual Breeding Bird Survey routes using spatially explicit models and route-level covariates

Deciphering ecology from statistical artefacts: Competing influence of sample size, prevalence and habitat specialization on species distribution models and how small evaluation datasets can inflate metrics of performance

A hierarchical model combining distance sampling and time removal to estimate detection probability during avian point counts

Mapping multiscale breeding bird species distributions across the United States and evaluating their conservation applications

Dealing with overprediction in species distribution models: How adding distance constraints can improve model accuracy

The effect of sample size and species characteristics on performance of different species distribution modeling methods

A spatial modeling framework for monitoring surveys with different sampling protocols with a case study for bird abundance in mid-Scandinavia

Presence-only species distribution models are sensitive to sample prevalence: Evaluating models using spatial prediction stability and accuracy metrics

Spatial Clustering of Citizen Science Data Improves Downstream Species Distribution Models

Improved state-space models for inference about spatial and temporal variation in abundance from count data

Integrating counts from rigorous surveys and participatory science to better understand spatiotemporal variation in population processes

Modeling American Kestrel Decline Using Spatiotemporal Subsampling to Improve eBird Data Reliability

How sensitive are species distribution models to different background point selection strategies? A test with species at various equilibrium levels