The BMJ ’s NHS commission: an emphatic recommitment to the founding principles

Liam Smeeth,Parveen Kumar,Victor Adebowale,Kamran Abbasi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q187

2024-01-30

BMJ

Abstract:The first report of the BMJ Commission on the Future of the NHS calls for the declaration of a national health and care emergency and an urgent reset for the NHS

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Reaffirming our commitment to the NHS is needed now more than ever

Victor Adebowale,Parveen Kumar,Liam Smeeth

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2688

2024-11-30

BMJ

Abstract:There have been at least two independent commissions on the NHS—The Times and The BMJ—in the past year. Recently Ara Darzi's report on the current state of the NHS was published. Although the findings of these commissions and Darzi's report were not a surprise, it is devastating to read of a system so stretched that in some places it is beyond breaking point. While the diagnosis is straightforward, the solutions are sadly not.The BMJ's Commission on the Future of the NHS was established from the perspective that a high-quality health service free for all at the point of care is too precious to be allowed to fail.1 Our aim was to identify the key challenges, but crucially to make recommendations targeted at ensuring that the vision of the NHS is realised.The acute response: Where do we begin?The BMJ commission recommended a relaunch of a new NHS as a whole country...

medicine, general & internal
Next government must be bold to tackle worst NHS crisis ever, says BMJ commission

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q284

2024-02-03

BMJ

Abstract:The NHS is facing the most severe crisis in its history, and bold leadership is needed from the next government to rebuild the service and put health at the centre of all policy, a group of experts has urged.The first report of the BMJ Commission on the Future of the NHS (bmj.com/nhs-commission), which launched this week, identified years of constrained funding, workforce shortages, and high demand from an ageing population as some of the key pressure points on the health service.1 The next government should declare a national health and care emergency and urge all parts of society to play their part in helping improve the health, care, and wellbeing of the population, it argued.The commission brings together leading experts from medicine and healthcare to identify key challenges and priorities and make recommendations aimed at ensuring that the vision of the NHS is realised. It is co-chaired by Victor Adebowale,...

medicine, general & internal
Any NHS reform has to avoid a repeat of 2012

Tom Moberly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2041

2024-09-20

BMJ

Abstract:The BMA and the UK government have finally agreed about something—two things, in fact: a new pay deal and the need for major reform of the NHS.After 44 days of strike action over the past two years, resident doctors (as junior doctors will now be known) have voted to accept the government's latest pay offer, with two thirds of those who voted backing the deal (doi:10.1136/bmj.q2038).1The BMA and the government also agreed that Ara Darzi's report on the state of the health service in England underlines the fact that far reaching change is needed (doi:10.1136/bmj.q2001 doi:10.1136/bmj.q2032 doi:10.1136/bmj.q2009).234 "Without radical action, the NHS won't survive," said the BMA's council chair, Philip Banfield, in response to the review, while the prime minister, Keir Starmer, said that the health service must "reform or die."One of many failings that Darzi highlights is the wellbeing of health service staff. "Every day, more than a million...

medicine, general & internal
The BMJ Commission on the Future of Academic Medicine

Kamran Abbasi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1294

2024-06-14

BMJ

Abstract:Academic medicine is broken. Worldwide, it has been for decades. Perverse incentives, entrenched power imbalances, deteriorating career pathways, restricted funding, and health service pressures are breaking it further. The complex challenges are global, with regional and national subtleties. Scan the landscape of commercialised life sciences, wasteful research and development, and exploitative scientific publishing—taking in a colossal waste of public money—and you quickly realise that this one system failure sits at the centre of the Venn diagram. Academic medicine is not an irrelevant silo.Science should form the basis of clinical practice and patient care. It should be central to medical education and training. It should advance diversity and inclusion. It should be the guiding light for government policy. The fact that it isn't, and is drifting further from the centre in each sphere, is a damning indictment of what society now values. The case for urgent solutions to this global crisis...

medicine, general & internal
Declaring a health and care emergency

Tom Moberly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q256

2024-02-01

BMJ

Abstract:Do you think the NHS as we know it has a long term future? Will it remain possible, in decades to come, to continue using collective contributions to fund high quality care for all, regardless of ability to pay?Many politicians and commentators in the UK would argue not (https://iea.org.uk/motion-should-the-nhs-be-privatisedhttps://www.cityam.com/fears-of-privatising-nhs-stop-from-saving-health-servicehttps://news.sky.com/story/sajid-javid-ex-health-secretary-issues-warning-over-nhs-as-he-admits-odds-stacked-against-tories-at-next-election-12768611https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/10/02/insurance-based-system-way-save-nhs).1234 After all, the challenges facing the health service grow every week, as The BMJ continues to show. The NHS faces an ongoing workforce crisis, and consultants in England have rejected the government's pay offer, with a mandate to continue their industrial action until June (doi:10.1136/bmj.q222).5 The BMA's Junior Doctors Committee for England is to reballot its members for another six months of industrial action (doi:10.1136/bmj.q200).6Demand on the service also continues to rise, with the need for surgical abortions increasing, at the same time as many of the UK's abortion surgeons are nearing retirement (doi:10.1136/bmj.p2982).7 The incidence of sexually transmitted infections such...

medicine, general & internal
The NHS founding principles are still appropriate today and provide a strong foundation for the future

Nigel Crisp,J S Bamrah,Jessica Morley,Charlotte Augst,Kiran Patel,JS Bamrah

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj-2023-078903

2024-01-30

BMJ

Abstract:The vision of a comprehensive health service is as relevant today as in the 1940s, but new and different societal challenges require a rethink on how to deliver the NHS as it faces a national health and care emergency

medicine, general & internal
Why The BMJ will no longer report on unsubstantiated press releases

Kamran Abbasi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.o1878

2022-07-28

The BMJ

Abstract:When do you say enough is enough? Doctors and other UK public sector workers have concluded that time is now, in a pay dispute that will turn a long hot summer into an autumn and winter of discontent (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1859, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1868, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1872, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1873).1234 Workforce pressures and staff burnout are at unprecedented levels (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1866, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1796).56 NHS restructuring is understandably met with "change fatigue" (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1765).7 The effect on staff manifests in worse outcomes and frustrating experiences for patients, the self evident logic of which seems to escape the people in power. "If you want a picture of the future," wrote George Orwell in 1984, "imagine a boot stamping on a human face—for ever."It seems Orwell was imagining health services in 2022. The positive focus on health at the start of the covid pandemic is now replaced by policy makers telling us that covid is over when it isn't (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1779, doi:10.1136/bmj-2021-069558).89 Or that it...
Value doctors or see NHS crisis worsen, BMA warns in manifesto for next government

Zosia Kmietowicz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1233

2024-06-05

BMJ

Abstract:The next government has no hope of improving the nation's health or providing high quality healthcare if it doesn't look after and retain doctors, the BMA has said in its general election manifesto.1 The result will be an ever deepening NHS crisis.Health must be the first priority of the incoming government, says the association, and it must commit to five key areas:Value the vital role doctors play across all health services and restore their payProtect doctors from any further erosion of their professional role, including by halting their substitution by other healthcare professionals until safety concerns are tackled, and bolster employment rights, including the right to strikeTrain and provide jobs for the next generation of doctors needed to meet demandFund the services needed for the future of the health serviceSafeguard the public's health and wellbeing, prioritising preventative care.BMA chair of council Philip Banfield said, "We have an understaffed, under-resourced, and...

medicine, general & internal
BMA Meeting: Doctors Call for Professional Regulation of Managers to Hold Them to Account

Nigel Hawkes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f4138

2013-01-01

BMJ

Abstract:Managers in the NHS should be subject to a regime of professional regulation so that they can be held accountable for their actions and omissions, the BMA’s annual meeting voted today. In spite of doubts expressed by Mark Porter, chairman of council of the BMA, the annual representative meeting carried by a large majority a motion favouring such regulation, proposed by Peter Holden, a Derbyshire GP and member of council. Holden argued that the introduction of managers into the NHS—“most, if not all, without any instinctive, institutional corporate code of professional ethics and behaviour backed up by a formal professional disciplinary and registration regime”—had created a toxic working environment. “Not even in Communist China did they have managers overruling doctors in the operation of …
Doctors are under attack from all sides, BMA chair tells annual meeting

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1402

2024-06-25

BMJ

Abstract:The medical profession is under attack financially, professionally, and morally, and must continue to fight to preserve itself, the BMA's chair of council has said.In a speech to the association's annual representative meeting in Belfast, Philip Banfield took aim at the government over industrial action, funding cuts, and the state of general practice. He also highlighted doctors' fears of speaking out about patient safety and announced a judicial review claim against the General Medical Council over the way it plans to regulate physician and anaesthesia associates, which the BMA says will lead to a dangerous blurring of lines for patients.Discussing the fractured relations between doctors and ministers, Banfield expressed his frustration that while consultants and specialist, associate specialist, and specialty (SAS) doctors in England have been able to secure pay deals, the dispute with junior doctors has now lasted 20 months without resolution. He said that calling an election does...

medicine, general & internal
The NHS doesn't need reimagining: we ȷust need to stop burning money

Cain R Hunt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q524

2024-03-06

BMJ

Abstract:Crisp and colleagues rightly argue that the NHS founding principles remain relevant but then fall into the trap of thinking that improving service models, technology, and education will fix the NHS.1Government figures show that it cost £1.51bn to set up clinical commissioning groups with nothing to show for that now they have been abolished.2 Instead of another wasteful reorganisation, we need to stop the system incentivising parts of the NHS to fight against each other.General practitioners are struggling with funding cuts (1.9% inflation uplift3 next year when inflation is running at 5.1%4). They can afford fewer doctors and nurses, so send more patients to emergency departments and specialist clinics This hurts the NHS because hospitals are more expensive.Hospital clinics are overwhelmed, so they make increasingly strict referral criteria. These often seem to reduce workload by making all referrals harder, not just inappropriate ones.5 Hospitals are paid more for tests referred...

medicine, general & internal
Hospitals Need Encouragement to Become Part of Integrated Care, Report Says

N. Hawkes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f2445

2013-01-01

BMJ

Abstract:Healthcare needs to change radically in the next five years, a group of healthcare executives and clinicians brought together by KPMG has agreed. But many in the sector still behaved as though change was the responsibility of others, their own organisations needing only minor nips and tucks, they said. Calling for “an act of courage and committed leadership,” KPMG’s report of discussions held in Rome in October last year says that it is time for major and transformational reform, not just cosmetic adjustment. The report,1 whose findings were to be presented this week at the International Forum on Quality and Safety in Healthcare in London by Mark Britnell, chairman of global health at KPMG, identifies converging pressures on healthcare systems throughout the world. Firstly, there is a shift from volume to value, as ways are sought …
The British NHS at 75: Past, Contemporary, and Future Challenges

Ben Williams

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/27551938241280175

Abstract:This article assesses how and why the National Health Service (NHS) has remained at the forefront of British politics and society for 75 years amid significant economic pressures, organizational strain, shifting ideological trends, ongoing reforms, and an unprecedented public health emergency. The postwar "years of consensus" evolved into alleged decline and ostensible neglect during the 1980s, while New Labour sought to rejuvenate this core public service after 1997, featuring investment and often controversial reforms that challenged the party's social democratic values. Amid the New Labour era, NHS powers filtered down to devolved administrations, while from 2008 retrenchment and austerity ensued, fueled by global recession. Austerity eventually subsided, yet from early 2020 the NHS swiftly faced the extreme conditions of the globalized Covid-19 pandemic. The service continues to face challenges regarding its longer-term viability, and this article analyzes this scenario, within the context of the NHS's 75-year historical legacy, its contemporary status, comparative international trends, and likely future evolution.
Rammya Mathew: We need braver politics for better health

Rammya Mathew

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1388

2024-06-26

BMJ

Abstract:In the run-up to every election, the NHS is front and centre of political manifestos. This time is no different, with party leaders over-promising on what they can deliver, lacking detail on how they'll achieve it.The public wants to see improved access to healthcare and reduced waiting times for elective care. But I worry that the emphasis on reducing NHS waiting times leaves us firefighting, putting more resources into a system that simply can't keep up with the growing demand for health and social care. It could leave us failing to acknowledge the bigger picture, in terms of what keeps us well and what reduces our need for healthcare in the first place.Earlier this year I listened to Chris Whitty, chief medical officer for England, talk about his proposed strategy for a healthier society.1 Contrary to political plans over the years, this wasn't about building more hospitals or GP surgeries2...

medicine, general & internal
Regarding general practice: an appeal to the new UK Government

Peter D Toon,Rupal Shah,Kim Stillman,Rosamund Bryar,Gene Feder,Paquita de Zulueta,Andrew Papanikitas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp24x739245

2024-09-01

British Journal of General Practice

Abstract:Dear Sir Keir and Mr Streeting, We were very pleased to hear that the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care has commissioned an immediate and independent investigation of the NHS with a particular focus on assessing patient access to health care, the quality of health care being provided, and the overall performance of the health system. Addressing the chronic underfunding of the NHS in recent years is crucial, but in order to make the best use of additional money we must also review the way in which the NHS is managed. No doubt COVID-19 placed an enormous strain on the NHS. However, much of the current low morale, high levels of burnout, and consequent difficulties in recruitment and retention in primary care are the result of a neoliberal market paradigm that promotes a 'factory model' of health care. This industrial model of care is predicated on increasing control, micro-management, and targets as the solutions to failure to meet demand. As ...

medicine, general & internal,primary health care
Only radical reform will save general practice: we need to rethink GP partnerships

Tom Riddington

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q306

2024-02-07

BMJ

Abstract:As a GP I apologise daily for the delays patients face, and the challenges they must overcome to do something as simple as see the doctor of their choice in a timely manner.General practice today is a wild west free market. Doctors are disincentivised to settle into partnerships or provide the continuity patients find valuable. Ours is the world of zero hours contracts, locum side hustles, and out-of-hours moonlighting.1 We opt for less traditional careers to avoid the chaos of an NHS in freefall.When the system is the problem, the system needs to change.The NHS's birth hammered a wedge between GPs and hospitals. Small business owners had little desire to surrender their profitable surgeries. A compromise was reached: GP partners remained contractors, not NHS employees.This half-in, half-out relationship with the NHS needs fixing. General practice could finally be nationalised. Wes Streeting made no secret of his desire to "tear up"...

medicine, general & internal
GP contract: Practices at risk of closure unless 1.9% offer is improved, warns BMA

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q287

2024-02-03

BMJ

Abstract:Many general practices will be at risk of closing down or face "awful choices" over staff redundancies and the services they provide unless the government improves its contractual offer to the profession, the BMA's General Practitioners Committee for England has warned.The committee said the offer of a 1.9% uplift to core general medical services (GMS) funding provided nowhere near what is needed to prevent practices from reducing services or closing down altogether. The 2024-25 offer will do little to bring hope, stability, or safety to the profession and will worsen patients' access even further, it added.At a meeting on Thursday 1 February the committee unanimously instructed its leadership team to continue talks with the government and NHS England over the next few weeks to deal with its concerns. The committee intends to put the final contract offer to a referendum vote of members on 1 March.Details of the offer come...

medicine, general & internal
Public health is in crisis, but it can be fixed

David J Hunter,Peter Littlejohns,Albert Weale

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q760

2024-03-28

BMJ

Abstract:Since 2010 a combination of austerity, Brexit, and the impact of covid-19 has considerably worsened the public's health in England.123 Obesity levels have risen, fuelled by the consumption of unregulated ultra-processed foods, a chronic problem which successive governments have failed to tackle.4 Gains in life expectancy have stalled.5 Health inequalities, both between and within regions, are widening.6 Growing numbers of people are unable to work because of illness.7 The UK now has one of the worst health profiles of any high income country, especially among children,8 and its deteriorating health status is adding to pressures on the NHS. To secure social conditions that support healthy populations, we need the political commitment of governments to act for the common good and their investment in institutions that protect public health.We know that ill health is tied to social determinants, and while governments alone do not shape those determinants, it is their job...

medicine, general & internal
Nhs Chief Tells Politicians to Embrace Hospital Closures to Improve Services for Patients

Nigel Hawkes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f582

2013-01-01

Abstract:Opposing changes to hospital services in England risked perpetuating mediocrity, the NHS’s medical director, Bruce Keogh, has warned. Appealing to politicians to step above their local interests and think of the wider interests of the NHS, the man responsible for quality at the NHS Commissioning Board said that changes might mean local closures or reconfigurations but that the result would be that patients could be directed to specialist centres where their care would be better. “Unless we can get to that place where people look at the greater good, which is sometimes in conflict with local interests, then professional, personal, and political interests will conspire to perpetuate mediocrity and inhibit the pursuit of excellence to the detriment of our NHS and ultimately our patients,” Keogh told the Guardian .1 Reconfigurations in at least 15 places …
Sixty seconds on . . . NHS reforms

Jacqui Wise

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2072

2024-09-21

BMJ

Abstract:I'm getting a feeling of déjà vuThis time it's the Policy Exchange think tank calling for NHS England to be abolished as an independent commissioning body and for its key functions to be delivered by an NHS management board within the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC).1Isn't constant reorganisation part of the problem?Yes, Ara Darzi's recent damning report said the NHS is in a "critical condition," partly as a result of the "disastrous" structural reforms in 2012.2So it's all Andrew Lansley's fault?His 2012 reforms did create NHS England. But the report argues that we now need a "rebalancing," with less central bureaucracy; a limited number of functions "to be overseen and held more tightly by ministers and others more loosely"; and greater autonomy for managers and clinicians throughout the NHS. There should also be a major overhaul to improve operational performance with more effective procedures to dismiss managers who...

medicine, general & internal

The BMJ ’s NHS commission: an emphatic recommitment to the founding principles

Reaffirming our commitment to the NHS is needed now more than ever

Next government must be bold to tackle worst NHS crisis ever, says BMJ commission

Any NHS reform has to avoid a repeat of 2012

The BMJ Commission on the Future of Academic Medicine

Declaring a health and care emergency

The NHS founding principles are still appropriate today and provide a strong foundation for the future

Why The BMJ will no longer report on unsubstantiated press releases

Value doctors or see NHS crisis worsen, BMA warns in manifesto for next government

BMA Meeting: Doctors Call for Professional Regulation of Managers to Hold Them to Account

Doctors are under attack from all sides, BMA chair tells annual meeting

The NHS doesn't need reimagining: we ȷust need to stop burning money

Hospitals Need Encouragement to Become Part of Integrated Care, Report Says

The British NHS at 75: Past, Contemporary, and Future Challenges

Rammya Mathew: We need braver politics for better health

Regarding general practice: an appeal to the new UK Government

Only radical reform will save general practice: we need to rethink GP partnerships

GP contract: Practices at risk of closure unless 1.9% offer is improved, warns BMA

Public health is in crisis, but it can be fixed

Nhs Chief Tells Politicians to Embrace Hospital Closures to Improve Services for Patients

Sixty seconds on . . . NHS reforms