Swirl flow stability: thermodynamic analysis and experiments

František Maršík,Zdeněk Trávníček,Bernhard Weigand,Florian Seibold,Zuzana Antošová
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00161-024-01303-6
2024-05-12
Continuum Mechanics and Thermodynamics
Abstract:The current paper presents a theoretical analysis of swirl flow stability, both inside a tube (vortex tube) and in a free annular swirl flow. The starting concept is the study of the evolution of velocity and temperature fluctuations. Methods of non-equilibrium thermodynamics are used to describe the magnitude of fluctuations and their properties. The important role of the total enthalpy follows from a variational analysis. Moreover, the thermodynamic criterion of the stability is formulated using the total enthalpy, and compared with experiments, numerical results and classical Rayleigh theory support its applicability. It was shown that the solid body vortex is at the margin of stability, which is experimentally observed. Analogously, the potential vortex is by the thermodynamic criterion stable; however, by the Rayleigh criteria it is on the onset of stability. The classical Taylor experiment of flow between two rotating cylinders is analysed from the point of view of this criterion. These results are underlined by swirl tube experiments at the Institute of Aerospace Thermodynamics at Stuttgart University and the annular nozzle experiments performed in the Institute of Thermomechanics CAS in Prague. Both independent experiments confirm the transformation of the initial annular vortex into a stable potential-type vortex. The results of this theory can also be used to explain the exceptional stability of tropical cyclones.
thermodynamics,mechanics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main topic of this paper is the stability of swirl flow, particularly in situations involving swirling pipes and free annular vortex flow. The authors utilize non-equilibrium thermodynamics to analyze the evolution of velocity and temperature fluctuations, and propose a thermodynamic stability criterion based on total enthalpy. They find that solid vortices are located at the edge of stability, which has been observed in experiments. On the other hand, potential vortices are stable according to thermodynamic standards, but are at the stability threshold under the Rayleigh criteria. The paper also validates this theory through experiments and numerical simulations, including swirl pipe experiments at the University of Stuttgart Institute of Aerospace Thermodynamics and annular nozzle experiments at the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic Thermodynamics Institute. These experimental results support the theoretical predictions. Furthermore, the study suggests that this theory can also be used to explain the abnormal stability of tropical cyclones. In summary, the main objective of the paper is to analyze and understand the stability of fluid flow containing vortices using thermodynamic methods, particularly through experimental and numerical simulation results under various conditions.