Abstract:Background: The English National Health Service has multiple waiting time standards relating to cancer diagnosis and treatment. Targets can have unintended effects, such as prioritisation based on targets instead of clinical need. In this case, a `threshold effect' will appear as a spike in hospitals just meeting the target. Methods: We conducted a retrospective study of publicly available cancer waiting time data, including a 2-week wait for a specialist appointment, a 31-day decision to first treatment and a 62-day referral to treatment standard that attracted a financial penalty. We examined the performance of hospital trusts against these targets by financial year to look for threshold effects, using Cattaneo et al. manipulation density test. Results: Trust performance against cancer waiting targets declined over time, and this trend accelerated since the start of the Covid-19 pandemic. Statistical evidence of a threshold effect for the 2-week and 31-day standard was only present in a few years. However, there was strong statistical evidence of a threshold effect for the 62-day standard across all financial years (p < 0.01). Conclusion: The data suggests that the effect of threshold targets alters hospital behaviour at target levels but does not do so equally for all standards. Evidence of threshold effects for the 62-day standard was particularly strong, possibly due to some combination of a smaller volume of eligible patients, a larger penalty, multiple waypoints where hospitals can intervene, baseline performance against the target and where the target is set (i.e. how much headroom is available). RCTs of the use of threshold targets and of different designs for such targets in the future would be extremely informative.

NHS targets will be missed this winter, trust leaders fear

A continuum of perfect storms: the winter forecast for urgent care in the NHS remains bleak

Hospitals in England See Deficits Grow As Wage Bills Rise and Earning Capacity Falls.

NHS Hospitals Should Imitate Sainsbury's Local and Tesco Metro, Hospital Chief Says.

Longer Waits in Emergency Departments Are Inevitable As Services Reach Capacity, Report Finds

English Nhs Could Be 54bn Pound In Red By 2021 If Budget Or Output Doesn'T Increase

NHS Scotland is treating fewer patients than before the pandemic despite boost to staff and funding

NHS data show A&E patients waiting longer and big rise in GP flu consultations.

Hospital Trusts Will Have to Cut Activity when Integration Fund Comes into Effect, Meeting is Told

Reduced discretionary effort by staff is affecting NHS productivity, report finds

NHS hospital capacity during covid-19: overstretched staff, space, systems, and stuff

Strike escalation and seasonal pressures create perfect storm for the NHS

Labour's pledge to clear NHS waiting list within five years will be tough to achieve, say leaders

Hospitals’ Reported £1bn Deficit Masks True Scale of Financial Woes, Say Analysts

NHS in England Balances Books, but Local Deficits Mean Worse Care in Some Areas, Says Report

Declaring a health and care emergency

Hospitals are urged to increase use of virtual wards to cut admissions

Foundation Trusts Plan to Recruit 2400 Extra Doctors in 2013-14

Effect of cancer waiting time standards in the English National Health Service: a threshold analysis

Why are doctors struggling to find jobs in an NHS so short of clinicians?

General practice workload is unsustainable, real time data show.