A continuum of perfect storms: the winter forecast for urgent care in the NHS remains bleak

Tim Cooksley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q11

2024-01-04

BMJ

Abstract:The NHS remains under immense pressure.1 Each part of the system is experiencing demand beyond its capacity, which is continually increasing the problem. This is most vividly illustrated in urgent and emergency care settings. Media images in the next few weeks will portray long queues of ambulances outside emergency departments and patients experiencing prolonged periods of degrading corridor care. Publications will feature stories of patients who have experienced significant harm and trauma due to delayed ambulance responses.Each winter in the past decade has become slightly worse,2 and that trend, which has not been reversed, has resulted in a dire situation that may not yet have reached its nadir. A continuum of often predictable perfect storms has caused a struggling system to reach collapse. Last winter this was exacerbated by a further wave of covid-19, high levels of influenza, and an outbreak of group A streptococcus infection with challenging cold weather....

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily discusses the severe challenges faced by the National Health Service (NHS) in the UK regarding emergency care during the winter season and explores methods to address these issues. Specifically:

1. **Current Situation**: The NHS is currently under immense pressure, with demands on various parts of the system exceeding its capacity, leading to worsening problems. Particularly in emergency and urgent care, long queues for ambulances and prolonged waiting times for patients in corridors are frequent occurrences.

2. **Cause Analysis**: The core of this crisis lies in the lack of sufficient workforce and resources to meet the needs of an increasingly aging population with multiple chronic illnesses. Additionally, high absenteeism rates, burnout, and low morale are also widespread issues.

3. **Impact Assessment**: These problems have led to an increase in excess mortality rates, with more and more patients waiting over 12 hours in emergency departments, further exacerbating the burden on the healthcare system.

4. **Exploration of Solutions**:
- Addressing these issues is not easy and requires long-term planning and implementation. It will take at least 10 years to return to a state of providing high-quality acute medical services.
- The political sphere needs to accept this reality and recognize that short-term "victories" alone cannot solve the problem; a comprehensive long-term strategy is necessary.
- While artificial intelligence may become part of the solution, these technologies will be of limited use if the issues of workforce shortages and resource scarcity are not addressed.
- Healthcare institutions and the government need to provide the necessary resources and reduce unnecessary bureaucratic procedures so that clinical leaders can drive and implement changes.

In summary, the paper aims to reveal the systemic issues faced by the NHS and calls for comprehensive measures to tackle the potential challenges in future winter seasons.