Abstract:Brittle solids typically fail by growth and propagation of a crack from a surface flaw. This process is modelled using linear elastic fracture mechanics, which parameterizes the toughness of a material by the critical stress intensity factor, or the prefactor of the singular stress field. This widely used theory applies for cracks that are planar, but cracks typically are not planar, and instead are geometrically complex, violating core tenets of linear elastic fracture mechanics. Here we characterize the crack tip kinematics of complex crack fronts in three dimensions using optical microscopy of several transparent, brittle materials, including hydrogels of four different chemistries and an elastomer. We find that the critical strain energy required to drive the crack is directly proportional to the geodesic length of the crack, which makes the sample effectively tougher. The connection between crack front geometry and toughness has repercussions for the theoretical modelling of three-dimensional cracks, from engineering testing of materials to ab-initio development of novel materials, and highlights an important gap in the current theory for three-dimensional cracks.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to understand the influence of complex crack front geometries on the toughness of brittle solids**. Specifically, the traditional linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) theory assumes that cracks are planar, but in reality, cracks are often geometrically complex, which violates the core assumption of LEFM. Therefore, existing theories cannot accurately describe the behavior of three - dimensional cracks. This paper experimentally studied the dynamic characteristics of complex crack fronts in several transparent brittle materials (including four hydrogels with different chemical compositions and one elastomer), and found that the critical strain energy of the crack is proportional to the geodesic length of the crack front, thereby enhancing the effective toughness of the material. This finding is of great significance from engineering material testing to the development of new materials, and also reveals the deficiencies of current theories in dealing with three - dimensional crack problems. ### Main findings: 1. **The relationship between crack front geometric complexity and material toughness**: - The geodesic length of the crack front is proportional to the critical strain energy required for crack propagation, which increases the effective toughness of the material. - This relationship shows consistency in multiple materials, indicating its universality. 2. **Uneven advancement of the local crack front**: - Even under globally stable conditions, some parts of the crack front can locally reach a critical state and advance. This phenomenon is similar to crack front pinning in planar systems. 3. **The influence of elastic heterogeneity on crack behavior**: - By embedding rigid nylon particles in the material, the planar symmetry of the crack can be broken, further increasing the complexity of the crack front and thus improving the toughness of the material. ### Research methods: - **Optical microscope imaging**: Use a confocal microscope to record the dynamic characteristics of the crack front, especially the change in crack tip opening displacement (CTOD) during the loading process. - **Three - dimensional reconstruction**: Directly measure the geodesic length of the crack front by performing volume reconstruction on image stacks of different z - slices. - **Energy release rate analysis**: Fit a parabola through CTOD data to calculate the mode I stress intensity factor (\( K_I \)), and then obtain the energy release rate (\( G \)) and the apparent fracture energy (\( \Gamma_{\text{app}} \)). ### Conclusions: - The geometric complexity of the crack front can significantly improve the toughness of the material by increasing the geodesic length. - This finding challenges the existing linear elastic fracture mechanics theory and requires a new theoretical framework to explain and predict the behavior of three - dimensional cracks. - This research provides new ideas and tools for material testing and the design of new materials.

Complexity of crack front geometry enhances toughness of brittle solids

Size effects in the toughening of brittle materials by heterogeneities: a non-linear analysis of front deformations

Towards Fully Automatic Modelling of the Fracture Process in Quasi-Brittle and Ductile Materials: a Unified Crack Growth Criterion

Size selection of crack front defects: Multiple fracture-plane interactions and intrinsic lengthscales

Characterizing Brittle Fracture by Modeling Crack Deflection Angles from the Microstructure

Mind the Helical Crack

Crack Front Segmentation and Facet Coarsening in Mixed-Mode Fracture

Modelling the Failure Behaviour of Brittle or Quasi-Brittle Materials by Analysing the Growth of Micro-Cracks

Pinning cracks by microstructure design in brittle materials

Dynamical Fracture Instabilities Due to Local Hyperelasticity at Crack Tips

Effects of crack tip geometry on dislocation emission and cleavage: A possible path to enhanced ductility

Dynamic toughness in elastic nonlinear viscous solids

Effect of Inhomogeneities on Dynamic Crack Growth in an Elastic Solid

Theoretical and Numerical Prediction of Crack Path in the Material with Anisotropic Fracture Toughness

Hyperelastic effects in brittle materials failure

Crack Roughness of High-Speed Fracture in Brittle Single Crystalline Material

Correlating toughness and roughness in ductile fracture

Rate Effects on Toughness in Elastic Nonlinear Viscous Solids

Effects of Brittleness on Crack Behaviors in Rock-Like Materials

Finite size effects on crack front pinning at heterogeneous planar interfaces: Experimental, finite elements and perturbation approaches

Modelling fracture process zone width and length for quasi-brittle fracture of rock, concrete and ceramics