A combined experimental and computational approach to unravel degradation mechanisms in electrochemical wastewater treatment

Sara Feijoo,Simona Baluchová,Mohammadreza Kamali,Josephus Gerardus Buijnsters,Raf Dewil
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ew00784g
2024-01-20
Environmental Science Water Research & Technology
Abstract:Electrochemical wastewater treatment is a promising technique to remove recalcitrant pollutants from wastewater. However, the complexity of elucidating the underlying degradation mechanisms hinders its optimisation not only from a techno-economic perspective, as it is desirable to maximise removal efficiencies at low energy and chemical requirements, but also in environmental terms, as the generation of toxic by-products is an ongoing challenge. In this work, we propose a novel combined experimental and computational approach to (i) estimate the contribution of radical and non-radical mechanisms as well as their synergistic effects during electrochemical oxidation and (ii) identify the optimal conditions that promote specific degradation pathways. As a case study, the distribution of the degradation mechanisms involved in the removal of benzoic acid (BA) via boron-doped diamond (BDD) anodes was elucidated and analysed as a function of several operating parameters, i.e., the initial sulfate and nitrate content of the wastewater and the current applied. Subsequently, a multivariate optimisation study was conducted, where the influence of the electrode nature was investigated for two commercial BDD electrodes and a customised silver-decorated BDD electrode. Optimal conditions were identified for each degradation mechanism as well as for the overall BA degradation rate constant. BDD selection was found to be the most influential factor favouring any mechanism (i.e., 52-85% contribution), given that properties such as its boron doping and the presence of electrodeposited silver could dramatically affect the reactions taking place. In particular, decorating the BDD surface with silver microparticles significantly enhanced BA degradation via sulfate radicals, whereas direct oxidation, reactive oxygen species and radical synergistic effects were promoted when using a commercial BDD material with higher boron content and on a silicon substrate. Consequently, by simplifying the identification and quantification of underlying mechanisms, our approach facilitates the elucidation of the most suitable degradation route for a given electrochemical wastewater treatment together with its optimal operating conditions.
environmental sciences,engineering, environmental,water resources
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to reveal the degradation mechanism in electrochemical wastewater treatment by combining experimental and computational methods. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Estimate the contributions of radical and non - radical degradation mechanisms and their synergetic effects**: In the electrochemical oxidation process, understanding the contributions of different degradation mechanisms (such as radical and non - radical mechanisms) and their interactions is crucial for optimizing the wastewater treatment process. 2. **Determine the optimal conditions for promoting specific degradation pathways**: By studying different operating parameters (such as the initial content of sulfate and nitrate in wastewater, the applied current, etc.), identify the optimal conditions that can promote specific degradation mechanisms. 3. **Simplify the identification and quantification of degradation mechanisms**: Propose a new method to make the identification and quantification of degradation mechanisms simpler, thereby providing a more practical tool for research and industrial applications. ### Specific problem background Electrochemical wastewater treatment is a promising technology that can effectively remove refractory pollutants in wastewater. However, due to the complexity of the degradation mechanism, optimizing this technology is challenging. In particular, from a technical and economic perspective, it is necessary to maximize the removal efficiency while reducing the use of chemicals and energy; from an environmental perspective, avoiding the generation of toxic by - products is also crucial. ### Research methods To achieve the above - mentioned goals, the author proposes a method that combines experiment and calculation, specifically including: - **Experimental part**: Through electrochemical experiments, study the degradation of benzoic acid (BA) under different conditions and analyze the contributions of different degradation mechanisms. - **Calculation part**: Establish a kinetic model, estimate the steady - state concentrations of radicals (such as hydroxyl radical •OH and sulfate radical SO•−4) through mathematical formulas (such as equations 31 and 32), and further expand the model to consider other possible degradation mechanisms (such as equation 33). ### Main findings - **Contributions of radical and non - radical mechanisms**: The study found that different electrode materials (such as commercial BDD electrodes and silver - modified BDD electrodes) have a significant impact on the degradation mechanism. For example, the silver - modified BDD electrode significantly enhances the effect of degrading benzoic acid through sulfate radicals. - **Optimal operating conditions**: Through multivariate optimization research, the optimal operating conditions for each degradation mechanism and the overall BA degradation rate constant are determined. Among them, the choice of BDD is the most important influencing factor, and its boron doping level and surface characteristics have an important impact on the reaction process. ### Conclusion By combining experimental and computational methods, this study successfully reveals the complex degradation mechanism in electrochemical wastewater treatment and provides a scientific basis for optimizing this process. This method not only helps to improve the efficiency of wastewater treatment, but also can reduce the generation of harmful by - products, and has important practical application value.