Abstract:Background: Wire cerclages play a fundamental role in fracture fixation. With an increasing variety of designs being commercially available the question arises which cerclage should be used. This study investigates the biomechanical properties of metallic and non-metallic cerclages and their different application-types. Furthermore, potential influence of muscular interposition between bone and cerclage constructs was tested. Methods: Samples of the following four different cerclage types were tested on 3D printed models of human humeri as well as on human cadaveric humeri with and without muscular interposition: Titanium Cable Cerclage (CC), Steel Wire Cerclage (SWC), Suture Tape (ST), Suture Tape Cerclage (STC) with both single- (sSTC) and double-loop application (dSTC). A preinstalled self-locking mechanism secured by the provided tensioner in the STCs being the main difference to the STs. Cyclic loading was performed to 1 kN and then linearly to a maximum load of 3 kN. Statistical analysis was performed using either one-way ANOVA and post-hoc Tukey or Kruskal-Wallis and post-hoc Dunn test depending on normalization of data (p < 0.05). Results: Whilst all cerclage options could withstand high loads during failure testing, only within the CC and dSTC group, all samples reached the maximal testing load of 3000 N without any failure. The SWC reached 2977.5 ± 63.6 N, the ST 1970.8 ± 145.9 N, and the sSTC 1617.0 ± 341.6 N on average. Neither muscular interposition nor bone quality showed to have a negative influence on the biomechanical properties of the cerclage constructs, presenting no significant differences. Conclusion: All tested cerclage constructs produce reliable stability but differ in their resulting compression forces, in a simplified fracture model. Therefore, non-metallic cerclage alternatives can provide similar stability with less compression and stiffness to metallic cable constructs, but they may offer several advantages and could possibly provide future benefits. Especially, by offering more elasticity without losing overall stability, may offer a biologic benefit. Installing any cerclage constructs should be performed carefully, especially if poor bone quality is present, as the tightening process leads to high forces on the construct.

Mechanical Analysis of a Novel Sternal Closure System in Static Tensile Loading

Biomechanical Evaluation of Cranial Flap Fixation Techniques: Comparative Experimental Study of Suture, Stainless Steel Wire, and Rivetlike Titanium Clamp

Experimental study of cranial flap fixation techniques on biomechanical evaluation

Clinical Evaluation of Titanium-Alloy Bands for Sternal Closure after Median Sternotomy: Single-Center Experience

Biomechanical Evaluation of Cranial Flap Fixation Techniques

Cerclage performance analysis - a biomechanical comparison of different techniques and materials

Rigid fixation of the sternum: a comparative biomechanical study

Is suture-based cerclage biomechanically superior to traditional metallic cerclage for fixation of periprosthetic femoral fractures: A matched pair cadaveric study

Effectiveness of rigid plate fixation for sternal closure in patients with a high risk of deep sternal wound infection

Bioengineering Approaches and Novel Biomaterials to Enhance Sternal Wound Healing after Cardiac Surgery: A Crosstalk between Innovation and Surgical Practice

Development and preclinical testing of a new tension-band device for the spine: the Loop system

The Correlation between Mechanobiology and Fracture Healing; Osteosynthesis, Biomaterial Optimization and TRIZ Design Principles to Develop Ameliorative Implants for Reconstruction of Median Osteochondrotomy of the Sternum

Biomechanical Performance of 4-Leg Sustained Dynamic Compression Staples in First Tarsometatarsal Arthrodesis

Comparative study of locking neutralization plate construct versus tension band wiring with a cannulated screw for patella fractures: experimental and finite element analysis

The TightRope study: a cadaveric, biomechanical comparison of generations of suspensory fixation with internal brace for Rockwood grade V acromioclavicular joint injuries

Biomechanical evaluation of double-stranded knot configurations in high-strength sutures and tapes

Feasibility Testing of a Novel Suture and Scaffold Dressing Device as an Alternative to Gauze Pad Compression for Wound Dressings

Increased Construct Stiffness With Meniscal Repair Sutures and Devices Increases the Risk of Cheese-Wiring During Biomechanical Load-to-Failure Testing

Canceling Notch Improves the Mechanical Safety of Clavicle Locking Plate: A 3D Finite Element Study.

Unstable Vancouver B1 periprosthetic femoral fracture fixation: A biomechanical comparison between a novel C-shaped memory alloy implant and cerclage wiring

[Biomechanical Performance of Different Wires and Cable Fixation Devices in Posterior Instrumentation for Atlantoaxial Instability].