Investigating the Relative Performance of Bricks-and-Mortar, Clicks-and-Mortar, and Pure-Click Firms in Taiwan

Irene Y. L. Chen,Yi-Shun Wang,Bo-Ruei Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su13063516

IF: 3.9

2021-03-22

Sustainability

Abstract:The study compares the relative performance among bricks-and-mortar, clicks-and-mortar, and pure-click firms. The research model was tested in the Taiwan service industry using a Taiwan Economic Journal dataset of 1448 firms. Using regression analysis, the study provides empirical evidence that clicks-and-mortar firms outperform pure-click firms in terms of efficiency, but not better in profitability and even worse in efficiency than bricks-and-mortar firms. Pure-click firms need to improve their accounts receivable turnover ratio and total assets turnover. While the findings are not in full congruence with past studies, we provide theoretical explanations. Based on the findings, a strategic guide on going clicks and mortar is provided to practitioners.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper examines the relative performance of different types of companies, focusing mainly on the comparison between brick-and-mortar (physical stores) and click-and-mortar (online and physical stores combined) companies versus pure online companies in the Taiwanese service industry. The study utilizes a dataset from a Taiwanese economic journal, which includes information from 1448 companies, and evaluates financial ratios such as efficiency and profitability through regression analysis.

The study finds that click-and-mortar companies perform better in terms of efficiency compared to pure online companies. However, their profitability is not stronger than that of brick-and-mortar companies, and they even lag behind in terms of efficiency. Pure online companies need to improve their accounts receivable turnover ratio and total asset turnover ratio. Although these findings are not entirely consistent with previous research, the paper provides theoretical explanations and strategic guidelines for practitioners who wish to transition to a click-and-mortar model.

The paper also reviews relevant literature, discussing the advantages and disadvantages of physical stores, pure online stores, and click-and-mortar stores, as well as the impact of channel integration. The theory of network externalities is used to explain how different network scales influence consumers' perception of product value. The study presents two hypotheses: first, click-and-mortar companies are more profitable than pure online or physical stores; second, click-and-mortar companies are more efficient than other types of companies.

However, the research results indicate that click-and-mortar companies do not surpass physical stores in terms of profitability and even fall behind in terms of efficiency. This provides a new perspective for future research and offers strategic advice for practitioners who wish to transition from physical or pure online stores to a click-and-mortar model.