The Role of Physical Stores in the Digital Age: Quasi-Experimental Evidence from Product Level Analysis

Jason Chan,Yaqiong Wang,Kaiquan Xu,Xi Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3762286

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:With increasing ecommerce penetration, it is believed that consumers are spending more of their shopping time online and away from physical stores. This brings to question the role of physical stores in an increasingly digitized landscape and whether they remain relevant to existing retailers. The measurement of the impact of physical stores has been characterized by the difficulty of attributing the increase in online sales to customers seeing and experiencing products showcased in physical stores, as this information is not typically observed and captured. Should physical stores remain valuable in the digital age, which products stand to enhance its complementarity to online sales? In this study, we attempt to shed light on these questions using a quasi-experiment, taking place through a nationwide retailer that expanded its physical presence during the study period. This work distinguishes from past studies in that it studies consumer behavior in the underexplored, yet important Chinese market in a mature e-commerce era. Through a “triple-differences” framework conducted at the product-level, we provide a more direct evidence on the effect of the physical channel on sales outcomes in the online channel, thereby complementing past work that showed the benefits of offline stores. Accounting for endogeneity concerns, the main effect of store openings on online sales continue to hold under various checks. We find that online sales for products showcased in physical stores increase for both high and low involvement products, suggesting that two mechanisms are at work in driving the online sales of showcased products. The conspicuous feature of stores helps consumers converge their purchase for high involvement products by providing them with additional sources of product information that is otherwise not available online. Furthermore, the experiential aspect of stores help to increase product sales by generating greater top-of-the-mind awareness of lowinvolvement products. Implications for theory and practice are discussed.