Optimized Cost Per Click in Online Advertising: A Theoretical Analysis

Kaichen Zhang,Zixuan Yuan,Hui Xiong

2024-05-23

Abstract:In recent years, Optimized Cost Per Click (OCPC) and Optimized Cost Per Mille (OCPM) have emerged as the most widely adopted pricing models in the online advertising industry. However, the existing literature has yet to identify the specific conditions under which these models outperform traditional pricing models like Cost Per Click (CPC) and Cost Per Action (CPA). To fill the gap, this paper builds an economic model that compares OCPC with CPC and CPA theoretically, which incorporates out-site scenarios and outside options as two key factors. Our analysis reveals that OCPC can effectively replace CPA by tackling the problem of advertisers strategically manipulating conversion reporting in out-site scenarios where conversions occur outside the advertising platform. Furthermore, OCPC exhibits the potential to surpass CPC in platform payoffs by providing higher advertiser payoffs and consequently attracting more advertisers. However, if advertisers have less competitive outside options and consistently stay in the focal platform, the platform may achieve higher payoffs using CPC. Our findings deliver valuable insights for online advertising platforms in selecting optimal pricing models, and provide recommendations for further enhancing their payoffs. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to analyze OCPC from an economic perspective. Moreover, our analysis can be applied to the OCPM model as well.

Computer Science and Game Theory,Theoretical Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is, in the online advertising industry, under which specific conditions the two pricing models, namely Optimized Cost - per - Click (OCPC) and Optimized Cost - per - Mille (OCPM), are superior to traditional pricing models such as Cost - per - Click (CPC) and Cost - per - Action (CPA). Although these new - type pricing models have been widely adopted, the existing literature has not clearly pointed out under what circumstances they can surpass the traditional models. To fill this gap, this paper constructs an economic model to theoretically compare OCPC with CPC and CPA, taking into account two key factors: external scenarios and external options.

### Specific Problem Description:

1. **OCPC vs CPA**:
- The paper explores how OCPC can effectively replace CPA by dealing with the problem of advertisers manipulating conversion reports in external scenarios. Specifically, when conversions occur outside the advertising platform, advertisers may strategically manipulate conversion reports, thus affecting the platform's revenue. And OCPC performs better in this case because it encourages advertisers to maintain accurate conversion rates.

2. **OCPC vs CPC**:
- The paper also analyzes the potential of OCPC in terms of platform revenue. OCPC may outperform CPC by providing higher revenues for advertisers and attracting more advertisers to the platform. However, if advertisers have fewer external options and continue to stay on the current platform, the platform may obtain higher revenues by using CPC.

3. **The Influence of External Options**:
- This research introduces the important factor of advertisers' external options. Advertisers will consider their external options, that is, whether there are other more attractive advertising platforms, when deciding whether to participate in the auction. This affects the effectiveness of different pricing models.

4. **The Influence of Conversion Rate Prediction Algorithms**:
- The platform now uses machine learning to predict the conversion rate of each user and advertisement, and it is difficult for advertisers to complete this task independently. However, the accuracy of prediction depends on unbiased training samples, which may be affected when conversions occur outside the platform. Therefore, the paper distinguishes between in - site and out - site scenarios and analyzes their impact on pricing models.

### Research Contributions:

- **Analyzing OCPC from an Economic Perspective for the First Time**: Provides the theoretical basis for online advertising pricing models.
- **Identifying Key Factors**: OCPC is superior to CPA in a wider range of external scenarios; OCPC is superior to CPC by attracting more advertisers with external options.
- **Providing Model - Selection Suggestions for Platforms**: Select the optimal pricing model according to the revenue balance between the platform and advertisers.

In conclusion, this paper aims to reveal the advantages of OCPC and OCPM under specific conditions through theoretical analysis and provide valuable insights and suggestions for online advertising platforms to select the best pricing model.