Specifying Data Objects with Initial Algebras

Chris Preston

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0909.3596

2009-09-19

Logic in Computer Science

Abstract:This study presents a systematic approach to specifying data objects with the help of initial algebras. The primary aim is to describe the set-up to be found in modern functional programming languages such as Haskell and ML, although it can also be applied to more general situations.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Initial Algebras Unchained -- A Novel Initial Algebra Construction Formalized in Agda

Thorsten Wißmann,Stefan Milius

2024-05-21

Abstract:The initial algebra for an endofunctor F provides a recursion and induction scheme for data structures whose constructors are described by F. The initial-algebra construction by Adámek (1974) starts with the initial object (e.g. the empty set) and successively applies the functor until a fixed point is reached, an idea inspired by Kleene's fixed point theorem. Depending on the functor of interest, this may require transfinitely many steps indexed by ordinal numbers until termination.

Logic in Computer Science
Types and Semantics for Extensible Data Types (Extended Version)

Cas van der Rest,Casper Bach Poulsen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2309.14985

2023-09-26

Abstract:Developing and maintaining software commonly requires (1) adding new data type constructors to existing applications, but also (2) adding new functions that work on existing data. Most programming languages have native support for defining data types and functions in a way that supports either (1) or (2), but not both. This lack of native support makes it difficult to use and extend libraries. A theoretically well-studied solution is to define data types and functions using initial algebra semantics. While it is possible to encode this solution in existing programming languages, such encodings add syntactic and interpretive overhead, and commonly fail to take advantage of the map and fold fusion laws of initial algebras which compilers could exploit to generate more efficient code. A solution to these is to provide native support for initial algebra semantics. In this paper, we develop such a solution and present a type discipline and core calculus for a language with native support for initial algebra semantics.

Programming Languages
Initiality for Typed Syntax and Semantics

Benedikt Ahrens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1206.4547

2012-06-20

Logic in Computer Science

Abstract:We give an algebraic characterization of the syntax and semantics of a class of simply-typed languages, such as the language PCF: we characterize simply-typed binding syntax equipped with reduction rules via a universal property, namely as the initial object of some category. For this purpose, we employ techniques developed in two previous works: in [2], we model syntactic translations between languages over different sets of types as initial morphisms in a category of models. In [1], we characterize untyped syntax with reduction rules as initial object in a category of models. In the present work, we show that those techniques are modular enough to be combined: we thus characterize simply-typed syntax with reduction rules as initial object in a category. The universal property yields an operator which allows to specify translations - that are semantically faithful by construction - between languages over possibly different sets of types. We specify a language by a 2-signature, that is, a signature on two levels: the syntactic level specifies the types and terms of the language, and associates a type to each term. The semantic level specifies, through inequations, reduction rules on the terms of the language. To any given 2-signature we associate a category of models. We prove that this category has an initial object, which integrates the types and terms freely generated by the 2-signature, and the reduction relation on those terms generated by the given inequations. We call this object the (programming) language generated by the 2-signature. [1] Ahrens, B.: Modules over relative monads for syntax and semantics (2011), arXiv:1107.5252, to be published in Math. Struct. in Comp. Science [2] Ahrens, B.: Extended Initiality for Typed Abstract Syntax. Logical Methods in Computer Science 8(2), 1-35 (2012)
Algebras of Information. A New and Extended Axiomatic Foundation

Juerg Kohlas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1701.02658

2017-01-11

Abstract:The basic idea behind information algebras is that information comes in pieces, each referring to a certain question, that these pieces can be combined or aggregated and that the part relating to a given question can be extracted. This algebraic structure can be given different forms. Questions were originally represented by subsets of variables. Pieces of information were then represented by valuations associated with the domains of variables. This leads to an algebraic structure called valuation algebras. The basic axiomatics of this algebraic structure was in essence proposed by Shenoy and Shafer. Here a much more general view of systems of questions is proposed and pieces of information are related to the elements of this system of questions. This leads to a new and extended system of axioms for information algebras. Classical valuation algebras are essentially a special case of this new system. A full discussion of the algebraic theory of this new information algebras is given, including local computation, duality between labeled and domain-free versions of the algebras, order of information, finiteness of information and approximation, compact and continuous information algebras. Finally a rather complete discussion of uncertain information, based on random maps into information algebras is presented. This is shown to represent a generalisation of classical Dempster-Shafer theory.

Information Theory
A Weakly Initial Algebra for Higher-Order Abstract Syntax in Cedille

Aaron Stump

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4204/EPTCS.307.6

2019-10-24

Abstract:Cedille is a relatively recent tool based on a Curry-style pure type theory, without a primitive datatype system. Using novel techniques based on dependent intersection types, inductive datatypes with their induction principles are derived. One benefit of this approach is that it allows exploration of new or advanced forms of inductive datatypes. This paper reports work in progress on one such form, namely higher-order abstract syntax (HOAS). We consider the nature of HOAS in the setting of pure type theory, comparing with the traditional concept of environment models for lambda calculus. We see an alternative, based on what we term Kripke function-spaces, for which we can derive a weakly initial algebra in Cedille. Several examples are given using the encoding.

Logic in Computer Science,Programming Languages
On Algebraic Specifications Of Abstract Data Types

B Khoussainov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-45220-1_25

2003-01-01

Abstract:In this paper we address long standing open problems of Bergstra and Tucker about specifications of abstract data types by means of equations and conditional equations. By an abstract data type we mean the isomorphism type of an algebra. An algebra is algebraically specified if the algebra can be defined uniquely, in a certain precise sense, in terms of a finite number of conditional equations by allowing functions that are not in the original language of the algebra. We provide full solutions to Bergtsra and Tucker problems, explain basic ideas, methods, and the logical dependencies between blocks of proofs used in our solutions.
Semantics of Constructions (II) — the Initial Algebraic Approach

Fu Yuxi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf02950418

2001-01-01

Abstract:Inductive types can be formulated by incorporating the idea of initial T -algebra. The interpretation of an inductive type of this kind boils down to finding out the initial T -algebra defined by the inductive type. In this paper the issue in the semantic domain of omega sets is examined. Based on the semantic results, a new class of inductive types, that of local inductive types, is proposed.
Scaled Boolean algebras

Michael Hardy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0196-8858(02)00011-8

IF: 1.271

2002-08-01

Advances in Applied Mathematics

Abstract:Scaled Boolean algebras are a category of mathematical objects that arose from attempts to understand why the conventional rules of probability should hold when probabilities are construed, not as frequencies or proportions or the like, but rather as degrees of belief in uncertain propositions. This paper separates the study of these objects from that not entirely mathematical problem that motivated them. That motivating problem is explicated in the first section, and the application of scaled Boolean algebras to it is explained in the last section. The intermediate sections deal only with the mathematics. It is hoped that this isolation of the mathematics from the motivating problem makes the mathematics clearer.

mathematics, applied
Whither Programs as Specifications

David A. Naumann,Minh Ngo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1906.03557

2019-06-09

Logic in Computer Science

Abstract:Unifying theories distil common features of programming languages and design methods by means of algebraic operators and their laws. Several practical concerns --- e.g., improvement of a program, conformance of code with design, correctness with respect to specified requirements --- are subsumed by the beautiful notion that programs and designs are special forms of specification and their relationships are instances of logical implication between specifications. Mathematical development of this idea has been fruitful but limited to an impoverished notion of specification: trace properties. Some mathematically precise properties of programs, dubbed hyperproperties, refer to traces collectively. For example, confidentiality involves knowledge of possible traces. This article reports on both obvious and surprising results about lifting algebras of programming to hyperproperties, especially in connection with loops, and suggests directions for further research. The technical results are: a compositional semantics, at the hyper level, of imperative programs with loops, and proof that this semantics coincides with the direct image of a standard semantics, for subset closed hyperproperties.
Class Algebra for Ontology Reasoning

Daniel Buehrer,Chee-Hwa Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1302.0334

2013-02-02

Abstract:Class algebra provides a natural framework for sharing of ISA hierarchies between users that may be unaware of each other's definitions. This permits data from relational databases, object-oriented databases, and tagged XML documents to be unioned into one distributed ontology, sharable by all users without the need for prior negotiation or the development of a "standard" ontology for each field. Moreover, class algebra produces a functional correspondence between a class's class algebraic definition (i.e. its "intent") and the set of all instances which satisfy the expression (i.e. its "extent"). The framework thus provides assistance in quickly locating examples and counterexamples of various definitions. This kind of information is very valuable when developing models of the real world, and serves as an invaluable tool assisting in the proof of theorems concerning these class algebra expressions. Finally, the relative frequencies of objects in the ISA hierarchy can produce a useful Boolean algebra of probabilities. The probabilities can be used by traditional information-theoretic classification methodologies to obtain optimal ways of classifying objects in the database.

Artificial Intelligence
Initial Semantics for Reduction Rules

Benedikt Ahrens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.23638/LMCS-15%281%3A28%292019

2019-03-20

Abstract:We give an algebraic characterization of the syntax and operational semantics of a class of simply-typed languages, such as the language PCF: we characterize simply-typed syntax with variable binding and equipped with reduction rules via a universal property, namely as the initial object of some category of models. For this purpose, we employ techniques developed in two previous works: in the first work we model syntactic translations between languages over different sets of types as initial morphisms in a category of models. In the second work we characterize untyped syntax with reduction rules as initial object in a category of models. In the present work, we combine the techniques used earlier in order to characterize simply-typed syntax with reduction rules as initial object in a category. The universal property yields an operator which allows to specify translations---that are semantically faithful by construction---between languages over possibly different sets of types. As an example, we upgrade a translation from PCF to the untyped lambda calculus, given in previous work, to account for reduction in the source and target. Specifically, we specify a reduction semantics in the source and target language through suitable rules. By equipping the untyped lambda calculus with the structure of a model of PCF, initiality yields a translation from PCF to the lambda calculus, that is faithful with respect to the reduction semantics specified by the rules. This paper is an extended version of an article published in the proceedings of WoLLIC 2012.

Logic,Logic in Computer Science
Algebraic Reasoning over Relational Structures

Jan Jurka,Stefan Milius,Henning Urbat

2024-10-18

Abstract:Many important computational structures involve an intricate interplay between algebraic features (given by operations on the underlying set) and relational features (taking account of notions such as order or distance). This paper investigates algebras over relational structures axiomatized by an infinitary Horn theory, which subsume, for example, partial algebras, various incarnations of ordered algebras, quantitative algebras introduced by Mardare, Panangaden, and Plotkin, and their recent extension to generalized metric spaces and lifted algebraic signatures by Mio, Sarkis, and Vignudelli. To this end, we develop the notion of clustered equation, which is inspired by Mardare et al.'s basic conditional equations in the theory of quantitative algebras, at the level of generality of arbitrary relational structures, and we prove that it is equivalent to an abstract categorical form of equation earlier introduced by Milius and Urbat. Our main results are a family of Birkhoff-type variety theorems (classifying the expressive power of clustered equations) and an exactness theorem (classifying abstract equations by a congruence property).

Logic in Computer Science
Projection-algebras and quantum logic

Daniel Lehmann

2024-08-15

Abstract:P-algebras are a non-commutative, non-associative generalization of Boolean algebras that are for quantum logic what Boolean algebras are for classical logic. P-algebras have type <X, 0, ', .> where 0 is a constant, ' is unary and . is binary. Elements of X are called features. A partial order is defined on the set X of features by x <= y iff x.y = x. Features commute, i.e., x.y = y.x iff x.y <= x. Features x and y are said to be orthogonal iff x.y = 0 and orthogonality is a symmetric relation.The operation + is defined as the dual of . and it is commutative on orthogonal features. The closed subspaces of a separable Hilbert space form a P-algebra under orthogonal complementation and projection of a subspace onto another one.P-algebras are complemented orthomodular posets but they are not lattices. Existence of least upper bounds for ascending sequences is equivalent to the existence of least upper bounds for countable sets of pairwise orthogonal elements. Atomic algebras are defined and their main properties are studied. The logic of P-algebras is then completely characterized. The language contains a unary connective corresponding to the operation ' and a binary connective corresponding to the operation ".". It is a substructural logic of sequents where the Exchange rule is extremely limited. It is proved to be sound and complete for P-algebras.

Quantum Physics,Logic in Computer Science,Logic
An Introduction to Different Approaches to Initial Semantics

Thomas Lamiaux,Benedikt Ahrens

2024-01-18

Abstract:Characterizing programming languages with variable binding as initial objects, was first achieved by Fiore, Plotkin, and Turi in their seminal paper published at LICS'99. To do so, in particular to prove initiality theorems, they developed a framework based on monoidal categories, functors with strengths, and $\Sigma$-monoids. An alternative approach using modules over monads was later introduced by Hirschowitz and Maggesi, for endofunctor categories, that is, for particular monoidal categories. This approach has the advantage of providing a more general and abstract definition of signatures and models; however, no general initiality result is known for this notion of signature. Furthermore, Matthes and Uustalu provided a categorical formalism for constructing (initial) monads via Mendler-style recursion, that can also be used for initial semantics. The different approaches have been developed further in several articles. However, in practice, the literature is difficult to access, and links between the different strands of work remain underexplored.

Logic in Computer Science,Programming Languages
Verifying Interaction Between Methods in Classes

Tingting Hu,Shuling Wang,Zongyan Qiu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tase.2015.24

2015-01-01

Abstract:Algebraic specification is well-known in specifying abstract data types. It could also play an important role in verifying the interrelation between methods in classes. In this paper we develop a framework for verifying the conformance of method implementations against an algebraic specification. Different from most existing work that perform testing at the code level for the conformance, our approach verifies the conformance without touching the implementation details. As another contribution, we show that if all the inherited methods of a subclass satisfy behavioral subtyping, then the subclass conforms to the algebraic specification of its superclass, i.e., there is no need to re-verify.
Complete Conceptual Schema Algebras

Hui Ma,Rene Noack,Klaus-Dieter Schewe,Bernhard Thalheim,Qing Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3233/fi-2013-834

2013-01-01

Fundamenta Informaticae

Abstract:A schema algebra comprises operations on database schemata for a given data model. Such algebras are useful in database design as well as in schema integration. In this article we address the necessary theoretical underpinnings by introducing a novel notion of conceptual schema morphism that captures at the same time the conceptual schema and its semantics by means of the set of valid instances. This leads to a category of schemata that is finitely complete and co-complete. This is the basis for a notion of completeness of schema algebras, if it captures all universal constructions in the category of schemata. We exemplify this notion of completeness for a recently introduced particular schema algebra.
Measuring data types

Lukas Mulder,Paige Randall North,Maximilien Péroux

2024-05-23

Abstract:In this article, we combine Sweedler's classic theory of measuring coalgebras -- by which $k$-algebras are enriched in $k$-coalgebras for $k$ a field -- with the theory of W-types -- by which the categorical semantics of inductive data types in functional programming languages are understood. In our main theorem, we find that under some hypotheses, algebras of an endofunctor are enriched in coalgebras of the same endofunctor, and we find polynomial endofunctors provide many interesting examples of this phenomenon. We then generalize the notion of initial algebra of an endofunctor using this enrichment, thus generalizing the notion of W-type. This article is an extended version of

Category Theory,Logic in Computer Science,Algebraic Topology
Finite Algebras with Hom-Sets of Polynomial Size

Libor Barto,Antoine Mottet

2023-07-13

Abstract:We provide an internal characterization of those finite algebras (i.e., algebraic structures) $\mathbf A$ such that the number of homomorphisms from any finite algebra $\mathbf X$ to $\mathbf A$ is bounded from above by a polynomial in the size of $\mathbf X$. Namely, an algebra $\mathbf A$ has this property if, and only if, no subalgebra of $\mathbf A$ has a nontrivial strongly abelian congruence. We also show that the property can be decided in polynomial time for algebras in finite signatures. Moreover, if $\mathbf A$ is such an algebra, the set of all homomorphisms from $\mathbf X$ to $\mathbf A$ can be computed in polynomial time given $\mathbf X$ as input. As an application of our results to the field of computational complexity, we characterize inherently tractable constraint satisfaction problems over fixed finite structures, i.e., those that are tractable and remain tractable after expanding the fixed structure by arbitrary relations or functions.

Rings and Algebras
Π 01-presentations of algebras ∗

Bakhadyr Khoussainov,Theodore Slaman,Pavel Semukhin

2005-01-01

Abstract:Effectiveness issues in algebra and model theory have been investigated intensively in the last thirty years. One wishes to understand the effective content of model-theoretic and algebraic results, and the interplay between notions of computability, algebra, and model theory. A significant body of work has recently been done in the area, and this is attested by recent series of Handbooks and surveys in computable mathematics, computability, and algebra (see, e.g., [1], [4], [3]). An emphasis has been placed on the study of computable models and algebras. These are the structures whose domains are computable sets of natural numbers, and whose atomic diagrams are computable. The study of computable model theory and algebra can naturally be extended to include a wider class of structures. This can be done by postulating that the atomic diagrams or natural fragments of the atomic diagrams are in some complexity class such as Σn or Π 0 n. These classes of algebras include computably enumerable (c.e.) algebras and co-c.e. algebras which we call Σ1-algebras and Π 0 1-algebras, respectively. Roughly, Σ1-algebras are the ones whose positive atomic diagrams are computably enumerable, and Π1-algebras are the ones whose negative atomic diagrams are computably enumerable. These include finitely presented algebras (e.g. finitely presented groups or rings) and groups generated by finitely many computable permutations of ω. There has been some research on Σ1-algebras (see for example [2], [6], [8], [9]) but not much is known about Π1-algebras and their properties. The main goal of this paper is the study of the question as
Building complicated index models and Boolean algebras

Saharon Shelah

2024-01-28

Abstract:We build models using an indiscernible model sub-structures of ${\kappa} \ge {\lambda}$ and related more complicated structures. We use this to build various Boolean algebras.

Logic

Specifying Data Objects with Initial Algebras

Initial Algebras Unchained -- A Novel Initial Algebra Construction Formalized in Agda

Types and Semantics for Extensible Data Types (Extended Version)

Initiality for Typed Syntax and Semantics

Algebras of Information. A New and Extended Axiomatic Foundation

A Weakly Initial Algebra for Higher-Order Abstract Syntax in Cedille

On Algebraic Specifications Of Abstract Data Types

Semantics of Constructions (II) — the Initial Algebraic Approach

Scaled Boolean algebras

Whither Programs as Specifications

Class Algebra for Ontology Reasoning

Initial Semantics for Reduction Rules

Algebraic Reasoning over Relational Structures

Projection-algebras and quantum logic

An Introduction to Different Approaches to Initial Semantics

Verifying Interaction Between Methods in Classes

Complete Conceptual Schema Algebras

Measuring data types

Finite Algebras with Hom-Sets of Polynomial Size

Π 01-presentations of algebras ∗

Building complicated index models and Boolean algebras