Review of Gas-Chromatographic Measurement Methodologies for Atmospheric Halogenated Greenhouse Gases

Noh Soo Han,Jeong Sik Lim
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10408347.2024.2302576
2024-01-21
Critical Reviews in Analytical Chemistry
Abstract:Gas chromatography (GC) is crucial for measuring atmospheric halogenated greenhouse gases (hGHGs), usually coupled with electron capture detector (ECD, with higher sensitivity) or mass spectrometry (MS, with higher selectivity). This review compares GC-ECD and GC-MS for analyzing atmospheric hGHGs in terms of analytical methodology, performance, and instrumentation. For hGHGs such as SF 6 , chlorofluorocarbons, and N 2 O, ECD can be employed in the single column, forecut-backflush (FCBF), and preconcentration methods. The order of appearance of SF 6 and N 2 O is an important consideration for selecting the separation column to avoid chromatographic interference from the long-tailed N 2 O and O 2 on SF 6 . Single column and FCBF GC-ECD methods suffer from nonlinear responsivity, but the preconcentration method can compensate for nonlinearity. The last method also offers a low drift, which eliminates the need for multipoint calibration and enables perfect linearity at atmospheric SF 6 levels. GC-MS demonstrates strong separability and identification capabilities, and over 60 hGHGs can be qualitatively analyzed by leveraging the separation power of MS and established MS databases. However, GC-MS requires a preconcentrator operating at −165 °C utilizing specialized adsorbents. Two notable preconcentrator-GC-MS systems, Medusa-GC-MS and detachable trap preconcentrator (DTP) GC-MS, differ in trap design, temperature scheme, and separation column type. Medusa-GC-MS employs a three-phased temperature operation before MS. DTP-GC-MS separates the preconcentration cycle into highly and less volatile compounds, using a different temperature scheme from that of Medusa-GC-MS. The preconcentrator-GC-MS system is widely employed for measuring perfluorocarbons, hydrofluorocarbons, and other hGHGs. This method necessitates multiple adsorption traps to discriminate the most abundant air components.
chemistry, analytical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is: how to effectively measure halogenated greenhouse gases (hGHGs) in the atmosphere. Specifically, the paper compares the analytical methods, performance, and instrument configurations of gas chromatography-electron capture detector (GC-ECD) and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) in analyzing halogenated greenhouse gases in the atmosphere (such as SF6, CFCs, and N2O). The main focus points include: 1. **Single Column Method**: Suitable for the measurement of SF6 and CFCs, but has issues with non-linear response and tailing peak interference. 2. **Front-Cut Back-Flush Method (FCBF)**: Reduces interference by front-cutting the oxygen peak, improving measurement accuracy. 3. **Preconcentration Method**: Enhances the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) through low-temperature preconcentration techniques, achieving better linearity and lower limits of detection (LOD). 4. **GC-MS System**: Offers strong separation and identification capabilities but requires complex preconcentration devices to improve sensitivity. The paper discusses the advantages and disadvantages of these methods in detail and provides specific experimental conditions and results to help researchers choose the measurement method that best suits their needs.