Review on High-Temperature-Resistant Viscoelastic Surfactant Fracturing Fluids: State-of-the-Art and Perspectives

Jinming Liu,Pingli Liu,Juan Du,Qiang Wang,Xiang Chen,Liqiang Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.energyfuels.3c00488

IF: 4.6541

2023-06-27

Energy & Fuels

Abstract:A viscoelastic surfactant (VES) fluid is an important part of a water-based fracturing fluid. As oil and gas exploration expands into deep, high-temperature, low-permeability reservoirs, the conventional VES fracturing fluid has shown great limitations. The high-temperature-resistance mechanisms of the high-temperature-resistant VES fracturing fluids in publicly available literature were analyzed from five aspects: single-chain surfactant system, oligomeric surfactant system, counterion effect, blended surfactant system, and nano-enhanced VES system. The friction-reduction performance, sand-carrying performance, gel-breaking performance, and core-damage performance of these systems were summarized. The results show that oligomeric surfactants with a monounsaturated hydrophobic long chain (>C21) are most likely to be used for VES fracturing fluids in high-temperature reservoirs, but the loading of the surfactants is still relatively high (3–5 wt %). By reducing the repulsion among polar headgroups to effectively decrease the area of head groups, or/and penetrating into the nonpolar cores based on hydrophobic interaction to increase the average hydrophobic volume of hydrophobic tails, counterions affect the performance of VESs. The aromatic counterion salts are preferred choices for improving the temperature resistance, friction reduction, and suspended sand performance of VES fluids. The blended surfactant/synthetic polymer systems based on noncovalent interaction improve the temperature resistance of VES fluids and reduce the loading of the surfactants to a certain extent. Based on the “pseudo-cross-linking” of nanomaterials and wormlike micelles, a very small amount of nanomaterials can improve the temperature resistance of VES fluids and reduce the loading of the surfactants. The most essential and effective method to improve the temperature resistance of VES fluids for fracturing is the molecular structure design based on the packing parameter theory. However, the synthesis process or route still needs further optimization to reduce production costs. In addition, given the excellent performance of VES fluids enhanced by nanomaterials, further research should be conducted on the influence mechanism of nanomaterial type and geometric features on the performance of VESs, as well as the potential harmfulness of nanomaterials, to promote the field-scale application of nano-enhanced VES fluids.

energy & fuels,engineering, chemical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem this paper attempts to address is improving the performance of viscoelastic surfactant (VES) fracturing fluids used at high temperatures, particularly in deep wells, high-temperature, and low-permeability reservoirs. Traditional VES fracturing fluids have significant limitations in terms of stability and cost control in high-temperature environments, which restricts their large-scale application. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Improving high-temperature stability**: Traditional VES fracturing fluids tend to degrade at high temperatures (>120°C), affecting their performance. Therefore, new VES systems need to be developed to enhance their stability under high-temperature conditions.

2. **Reducing costs**: Currently, the cost of VES fracturing fluids is relatively high, with surfactant concentrations typically ranging from 3-5wt%, much higher than other fracturing fluid thickeners. This makes the cost of VES fracturing fluids 5 to 30 times higher than traditional guar-based fracturing fluids. Therefore, reducing the amount of surfactant and overall cost is a key focus of the research.

3. **Improving performance**: In addition to high-temperature stability and cost issues, it is also necessary to improve the friction reduction performance, proppant carrying performance, gel breaking performance, and formation damage degree of VES fracturing fluids.

The paper analyzes different types of VES systems (such as single-chain surfactant systems, oligomeric surfactant systems, counterion effects, mixed surfactant systems, and nano-enhanced VES systems), summarizes the performance of these systems, and proposes mechanisms and strategies to improve high-temperature stability. Ultimately, the paper aims to provide potential solutions for further research and practical application of VES fracturing fluids.