How Is Mutual-Help Housing Participatory? A Critical Discourse Analysis of Socio-Spatial Responses to Informality in Chile and Brazil

Alejandro de Castro Mazarro,Markus Kurth,Thuc Han Tran
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14036096.2024.2345890
2024-04-30
Housing Theory and Society
Abstract:Participation is a prerequisite for mutual-help housing projects aimed at the sustainable transformation of informal urban areas. Given the ambiguity in how participation is understood in such projects, a deeper understanding of the discourses and socio-spatial constraints that frame participatory design processes is needed. To unpack the problem-solving narratives implicit in participatory design projects, this paper employs a critical discourse approach to analyse two prominent mutual-help housing projects in Chile and Brazil. The findings reveal that while both cases showcase dwellers' participation as a construction labour force, their discourses on participation follow distinct orientations that are influenced by their policy environments and the problems they target, such as material poverty and social injustice. These findings aim to provide urban designers and practitioners with a conceptual tool to rigorously examine participatory design practices and to better constrain the use of the concept.
environmental studies,urban studies,regional & urban planning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?