Teleportation: Dream or Reality?

L. Vaidman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.57866
1998-10-29
Abstract:Since its discovery in 1993, we witness an intensive theoretical and experimental effort centered on teleportation. Very recently it was claimed in the press that ``quantum teleportation has been achieved in the laboratory'' (T. Sudbery, Nature, 390, p. 551). Here, I briefly review this research focusing on the connection to nonlocal measurements, and question Sudbery's statement. A philosophical inquiry about the paradoxical meaning of teleportation in the framework of the many-worlds interpretation is added.
Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the definition, realization and philosophical significance of quantum teleportation. Specifically: 1. **Clarify the meaning of "teleportation"**: - The author Lev Vaidman discussed the different meanings of the term "teleportation" in science fiction and physics, and pointed out that true quantum teleportation should be able to transmit an unknown quantum state without moving any system carrying this quantum state. 2. **Evaluate whether existing experiments have truly achieved quantum teleportation**: - The paper made a critical evaluation of the so - called "quantum teleportation" experiments in recent laboratories, pointing out that many experiments do not fully meet the standards of quantum teleportation strictly defined in the BBCJPW (Bennett, Brassard, Crépeau, Jozsa, Peres, and Wootters) scheme. For example, NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance) experiments cannot transmit unknown quantum states, and in optical experiments, there is a problem that the classical channel may carry quantum states. 3. **Explore the technical challenges in achieving reliable quantum teleportation**: - The author analyzed in detail the importance of Bell - operator measurement and its technical difficulties. Due to the lack of effective quantum - quantum interaction, current methods are difficult to achieve non - degenerate Bell - operator measurement, thus limiting the success rate of reliable teleportation. It is mentioned in the paper that using atoms and electromagnetic cavities may be a promising direction to achieve 100% success - rate teleportation in the future. 4. **Discuss the philosophical problems of quantum teleportation**: - In the framework of the Many - Worlds Interpretation (MWI), the author explored the paradoxes brought by quantum teleportation. According to MWI, teleportation does not mean the actual movement of the quantum state, but splits the world through local measurement, so that the state of the remote particle in each world differs from the original state by a known transformation. This solves the problem in relativity that information cannot travel faster than the speed of light. In summary, this paper aims to clarify the definition of quantum teleportation, evaluate the rationality of existing experiments, and propose the technical path and philosophical thinking for achieving reliable quantum teleportation.