P. Ávila,E. Okon,D. Sudarsky,M. Wiedemann
Abstract:A recently proposed gedankenexperiment involving the (gravitational or electromagnetic) interaction between two objects--one placed in a state of quantum superposition of two locations--seems to allow for faster-than-light communication. However, it has been argued that, if the mediating fields are endowed with quantum properties, then the possibility for superluminal signaling is fully avoided. Moreover, in the gravitational case, this conclusion has been used to argue for the view that the gravitational field must be quantized. In this work, we clarify and complement some aspects of the discussion. In particular, by focusing on the way in which entanglement spreads across the components of the system, we offer some insights into the fundamental quantum features behind the impossibility of superluminal signaling and we provide a more general proof of such an impossibility in this and related protocols.
Quantum Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,History and Philosophy of Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the spatial distribution of quantum superposition states can be used for superluminal signal transmission. Specifically, the paper explores a thought experiment (gedankenexperiment). In this experiment, a particle is placed in a quantum superposition state at two positions, and another particle determines whether an interference pattern can be observed according to whether it interacts (electromagnetically or gravitationally) with the previous particle. If this process can be achieved, it seems that superluminal communication can be achieved through this mechanism. However, the paper points out that if the quantum properties of the mediating fields (such as the electromagnetic field or the gravitational field), especially the quantum fluctuations of these fields, are taken into account, then the possibility of superluminal signal transmission will be completely avoided. In addition, in the case of gravity, this conclusion is used to support the view that the gravitational field must be quantized.
### Main contributions of the paper
1. **Clarification and supplementary discussion**:
- The authors clarify certain aspects in previous research and provide more extensive proofs, showing that superluminal signal transmission is impossible after considering the properties of quantum fields.
- By analyzing how entanglement spreads among different parts of the system, the authors provide some basic quantum characteristics to explain why superluminal signal transmission cannot be achieved.
2. **Analysis of the multi - particle case**:
- The authors consider a situation where Bob controls multiple particles instead of one. They point out that even in this case, by reasonably arranging the positions of the particles, superluminal signal transmission still cannot be achieved. This further supports the crucial role of the quantum properties of quantum fields in preventing superluminal signal transmission.
3. **Criticism of existing theories**:
- The authors criticize some assumptions in previous research, especially regarding the question of whether the gravitational field must be quantized. They point out that these assumptions are logically circular and cannot be used as valid arguments to support the quantization of the gravitational field.
### Formula analysis
- **Radiation conditions**:
\[
D_A < T_A \quad (\text{electromagnetic case})
\]
\[
Q_A < T_A^2 \quad (\text{gravitational case})
\]
where \( D_A \) and \( Q_A \) represent the effective dipole moment and the effective quadrupole moment of Alice's particle respectively.
- **Displacement conditions**:
\[
\frac{D_A}{D^3 T_B^2} > 1 \quad (\text{electromagnetic case})
\]
\[
\frac{Q_A}{D^4 T_B^2} > 1 \quad (\text{gravitational case})
\]
- **Inner product relations**:
\[
|\langle B_1 | B_2 \rangle| \geq |\langle \Psi_1 | \Psi_2 \rangle_{\Sigma_1}|
\]
This inequality shows that Bob's measurement results will not be more strongly decohered than Alice's particle, thus avoiding the possibility of superluminal signal transmission.
### Conclusion
By analyzing in detail the properties of quantum fields, especially the role of quantum fluctuations, the paper proves that superluminal signal transmission is impossible. At the same time, the authors conduct an in - depth exploration of the multi - particle case, further verifying this conclusion. These analyses not only clarify previous theories but also provide a new perspective for understanding the relationship between quantum mechanics and relativity.