Conceptual tensions between quantum mechanics and general relativity: Are there experimental consequences, e.g., superconducting transducers between electromagnetic and gravitational radiation?

Raymond Y. Chiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.gr-qc/0208024

2002-09-19

Abstract:One of the conceptual tensions between quantum mechanics (QM) and general relativity (GR) arises from the clash between the spatial nonseparability of entangled states in QM, and the complete spatial separability of all physical systems in GR, i.e., between the nonlocality implied by the superposition principle, and the locality implied by the equivalence principle. Experimental consequences of this conceptual tension will be explored for macroscopically coherent quantum fluids, such as superconductors, superfluids, and atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs), subjected to tidal and Lense-Thirring fields arising from gravitational radiation. A Meissner-like effect is predicted, in which the Lense-Thirring field is expelled from the bulk of a quantum fluid. Superconductors are predicted to be macroscopic quantum gravitational antennas and transducers, which can directly convert upon reflection a beam of quadrupolar electromagnetic radiation into gravitational radiation, and vice versa, and thus serve as both sources and receivers of gravitational waves. An estimate of the transducer conversion efficiency on the order of unity comes out of the Ginzburg-Landau theory for an extreme type II, dissipationless superconductor with minimal coupling to weak gravitational and electromagnetic radiation fields, whose frequency is smaller than the BCS gap frequency, thus satisfying the quantum adiabatic theorem. The concept of ``the impedance of free space for gravitational plane waves'' is introduced, and leads to a natural impedance-matching process, in which the two kinds of radiation fields are impedance-matched to each other around a hundred coherence lengths beneath the surface of the superconductor. A simple, Hertz-like experiment has been performed to test these ideas, and preliminary results will be reported.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the conceptual tension between quantum mechanics (QM) and general relativity (GR), which is manifested in the following aspects:

1. **Spatial Inseparability vs. Complete Spatial Separability**: The conflict between the spatial inseparability (non - locality) of entangled states in quantum mechanics and the complete spatial separability (locality) of all physical systems in general relativity. For example, the behavior of macroscopic coherent quantum fluids such as superconductors, superfluids, and Bose - Einstein condensates (BECs) when subjected to tidal fields and Lense - Thirring fields caused by gravitational waves.

2. **Equivalence Principle vs. Uncertainty Principle**: The equivalence principle in general relativity is based on locality, while the uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics abandons the classical concept of "trajectory". This conflict may have experimental manifestations on both micro and macro scales, especially when it comes to macroscopic quantum objects.

3. **Mixed States vs. Pure States**: When one part of a system falls into a black hole and the other part flies to infinity, general relativity considers this a mixed state, while quantum mechanics considers it a pure state. This involves the nature of information.

### Specific Research Content

The paper explores whether these conceptual tensions will lead to experimental consequences and proposes specific experimental suggestions, such as using macroscopic quantum objects (such as superconductors) as quantum converters and antennas to detect gravitational waves. The author predicts some interesting effects, including:

- **Meissner - like Effect**: Similar to the repulsion of magnetic fields by superconductors, superconductors may also repel the Lense - Thirring field of gravitational waves, causing gravitational plane waves to be reflected from the surface of the superconductor.

- **Direct Coupling of Electromagnetic and Gravitational Radiation**: Superconductors can serve as macroscopic - quantity quantum - gravitational antennas and converters, directly converting quadrupole electromagnetic radiation into gravitational radiation and vice versa.

### Experimental Verification

To verify these theoretical predictions, the author proposes a simple experiment similar to the Hertz experiment, and the preliminary results will be reported in subsequent reports.

### Mathematical Formulas

Some of the key formulas mentioned in the paper include:

- The London penetration depth \(\lambda_L\) for atomic BECs is given by:
\[
\lambda_L=(8\pi n a)^{- 1/2}
\]
where \(n\) is the average atomic density of the BEC and \(a\) is the S - wave scattering length.

- The Bohm singlet of Cooper - pair electrons:
\[
|S = 0\rangle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(|\uparrow\rangle_1|\downarrow\rangle_2-|\uparrow\rangle_2|\downarrow\rangle_1\right)
\]

Through these studies, the paper aims to explore the deep - seated conceptual tension between quantum mechanics and general relativity and find possible experimental verification paths.