Noncommutativity and Discrete Physics

Louis H. Kauffman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0167-2789%2898%2900049-9

1997-09-07

Abstract:The purpose of this paper is to present an introduction to a point of view for discrete foundations of physics. In taking a discrete stance, we find that the initial expression of physical theory must occur in a context of noncommutative algebra and noncommutative vector analysis. In this way the formalism of quantum mechanics occurs first, but not necessarily with the usual interpretations. The basis for this work is a non-commutative discrete calculus and the observation that it takes one tick of the discrete clock to measure momentum.

Quantum Algebra

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore the basic theory of discrete physics and presents a view of discrete physics based on non - commutative algebra and non - commutative vector analysis. By introducing a new form of calculus - Discrete Ordered Calculus (DOC), the author studies the expression of physical theories in a non - commutative framework. The main objectives of the paper include:

1. **Construction of non - commutative discrete calculus**: The author defines position and velocity measurements under discrete time steps and proposes a non - commutative differential operator \(D\), which takes into account the influence of the observation order. Specifically, the relationship between position \(X\) and velocity \(v\) is defined as:
\[
v(t)=X_{t + 1}-X_t
\]
Further, a non - commutative derivative is defined:
\[
dX = X' - X
\]
where \(X'\) represents the value of \(X\) in the next time step. To deal with non - commutativity, a special time - shift operator \(J\) is introduced, such that:
\[
DX=J(X' - X)=[X, J]
\]

2. **Basic equations of non - commutative dynamics**: The author shows how to derive dynamic equations similar to those in classical physics in a non - commutative framework. For example, for the commutation relation between position \(X_i\) and velocity \(\dot{X}_j\):
\[
[X_i,\dot{X}_j]=g_{ij}
\]
where \(g_{ij}\) is a function and can be expressed as a metric field. Through these commutation relations, the author derives a non - commutative form similar to electromagnetic field theory.

3. **Relationship between non - commutative and classical mechanics**: The author discusses the relationship between Poisson brackets and commutation brackets in a non - commutative framework. In particular, by introducing the discrete - time derivative \(D\), the author shows how to re - interpret the Hamilton equations in a non - commutative framework. This indicates that classical Hamilton mechanics can be naturally derived from commutation relations in a non - commutative framework.

4. **Quantum groups and discrete time**: The author explores the relationship between quantum groups and discrete time. In particular, in the quantum group \(U_q(SU(2))\), the time - evolution operator \(J\) can be represented by a conjugation action. This provides a new perspective for understanding the meaning of time in a non - commutative framework.

5. **Networks and discrete space - time**: Finally, the author discusses how to represent discrete space - time with network structures. By assigning specific "colors" to the nodes and edges of the network, the amplitudes of the network can be calculated, and these amplitudes correspond to path integrals in physical systems and quantum - mechanical amplitudes. This provides a new method for understanding the topological properties of low - dimensional spaces.

In summary, this paper attempts to construct a completely new theoretical framework of discrete physics by introducing non - commutative algebra and discrete ordered calculus, thereby providing a new perspective for understanding the relationship between quantum mechanics and classical mechanics.