Sean M. Carroll
Abstract:I propose a version of quantum mechanics featuring a discrete and finite number of states that is plausibly a model of the real world. The model is based on standard unitary quantum theory of a closed system with a finite-dimensional Hilbert space. Given certain simple conditions on the spectrum of the Hamiltonian, Schrödinger evolution is periodic, and it is straightforward to replace continuous time with a discrete version, with the result that the system only visits a discrete and finite set of state vectors. The biggest challenges to the viability of such a model come from cosmological considerations. The theory may have implications for questions of mathematical realism and finitism.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve
This paper aims to explore a fully discrete and finite-state model of quantum mechanics, which could be a reasonable model of the real world. Specifically, the author proposes a closed system model based on standard unitary quantum theory, where the Hilbert space of the system is finite-dimensional. By assuming that the Hamiltonian spectrum satisfies certain simple conditions, Schrödinger evolution can be periodic, allowing continuous time to be replaced by a discrete version, so that the system only accesses a set of discrete and finite state vectors.
### Main Challenges
1. **Cosmological Considerations**: The biggest challenge of this model comes from cosmology. Since the overall time evolution is periodic, there is a phenomenon of recurrence: anything that has happened once will repeat infinitely in the future and has also happened infinitely in the past. This could lead to the Boltzmann Brain phenomenon, where observers are generated by random fluctuations rather than evolving from a low-entropy initial state through ordinary thermodynamic processes. In this case, the cognitive stability of observers is threatened.
2. **Mathematical Realism and Finitism**: This model may impact issues of mathematical realism and finitism. Traditionally, the mathematical tools used to describe physical systems (such as Peano arithmetic and Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory) involve an infinite number of concepts, even if these concepts do not necessarily correspond directly to physical structures. Whether this model can completely avoid these issues is currently unclear.
### Specific Implementation of the Model
1. **Discretized Time Evolution**: Under appropriate Hamiltonian conditions, time evolution can be discretized so that the system only accesses a set of discrete and finite state vectors. Thus, the continuous nature of the Hilbert space becomes irrelevant, as physical states only occupy discrete grid points within this space.
2. **Periodicity of Energy Eigenstates**: If the energy eigenvalues are commensurable, i.e., their ratios are rational numbers, the evolution of the system will be exactly periodic. In this case, discretized time evolution can be achieved by defining a fundamental time step.
3. **Potential Solutions to Cosmological Problems**:
- **Non-Ergodic Evolution**: Assuming the evolution is non-ergodic can avoid the Boltzmann Brain phenomenon.
- **Emergent Time**: Assuming time itself is emergent, by decomposing the Hilbert space into "clock" and other parts, can avoid eternal recurrence and the Boltzmann Brain phenomenon.
### Conclusion
Despite the cosmological challenges, this model may still represent a fully discrete and finite, realistic physics. This model helps to avoid the physical and philosophical problems brought by continuous quantities but requires further research to address the cosmological issues.