Abstract:"Does generative AI infringe copyright?" is an urgent question. It is also a difficult question, for two reasons. First, "generative AI" is not just one product from one company. It is a catch-all name for a massive ecosystem of loosely related technologies, including conversational text chatbots like ChatGPT, image generators like Midjourney and DALL-E, coding assistants like GitHub Copilot, and systems that compose music and create videos. These systems behave differently and raise different legal issues. The second problem is that copyright law is notoriously complicated, and generative-AI systems manage to touch on a great many corners of it: authorship, similarity, direct and indirect liability, fair use, and licensing, among much else. These issues cannot be analyzed in isolation, because there are connections everywhere. In this Article, we aim to bring order to the chaos. To do so, we introduce the generative-AI supply chain: an interconnected set of stages that transform training data (millions of pictures of cats) into generations (a new, potentially never-seen-before picture of a cat that has never existed). Breaking down generative AI into these constituent stages reveals all of the places at which companies and users make choices that have copyright consequences. It enables us to trace the effects of upstream technical designs on downstream uses, and to assess who in these complicated sociotechnical systems bears responsibility for infringement when it happens. Because we engage so closely with the technology of generative AI, we are able to shed more light on the copyright questions. We do not give definitive answers as to who should and should not be held liable. Instead, we identify the key decisions that courts will need to make as they grapple with these issues, and point out the consequences that would likely flow from different liability regimes.

Creating Innovation Value from Generative Ai: A Property Rights Perspective

The Research On The Ownership Of Copyright Of AI-generated Content

Balancing Innovation and Regulation in the Age of Generative Artificial Intelligence

Good Models Borrow, Great Models Steal: Intellectual Property Rights and Generative AI

The Implication of Generative Artificial Intelligence towards Intellectual Property Rights (Examining the Multifaceted Implications of Generative Artificial Intelligence on Intellectual Property Rights)

Generative AI and US Intellectual Property Law

U Can't Gen This? A Survey of Intellectual Property Protection Methods for Data in Generative AI

Generative Artificial Intelligence and Copyright: Both Sides of the Black Box

Copyright Policy Options for Generative Artificial Intelligence

Legal regulation of generative AI: a multidimensional construction

Governance of Generative Artificial Intelligence for Companies

Managing Copyright Infringement Risks in Generative Artificial Intelligence Data Mining

Generative AI and the Digital Commons

Copyright, text & data mining and the innovation dimension of generative AI

An ethical study of generative AI from the Actor-Network Theory perspective

Assessing the Copyright Infringement Risk of Generative AI Created Works

Intersection of generative artificial intelligence and copyright: an Indian perspective

Generative AI and Copyright: A Dynamic Perspective

Talkin' 'Bout AI Generation: Copyright and the Generative-AI Supply Chain

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE CONTEXT OF COPYRIGHT

Should We Ban Generative AI, Incentivise it or Make it a Medium for Inclusive Creativity?