Abstract:Normally, a full process of public policy implementation includes three parts: policy document flow,implementation action by public agency, and citizens’ participation. Meanwhile, implementation process can be regarded as a combination of policy stream, process stream and resource stream. When policy documents cannot be transformed into real action and government and society cannot interact well with each other, policy targets are poorly accomplished. In this case, policy implementation shows up as a fake implementation, or symbolic implementation. In China, such a symbolic policy implementation is named "empty flow of policy text".Focusing on the implementation process of the policies on the regulating the production and selling of "drainage oil", this article tries to analyze the symbolic policy implementation in China. It argues that three main factors contributing to the symbolic policy implementation in China: first, the conflict between local government as the agent of of the central government and the principles of bureaucracy leads to all kinds of implementation forms and poor implementation; second, the lack of accurate measurements of policy goals at different levels of government and effective policy tools, especially the lack of advanced science and technology leads to the serious formalistic top-down policy implementation; third, the insufficient coordination mechanisms among different policy actors results in weak cooperation and loose policy network in policy implementation. Therefore, the key to eliminating symbolic policy implementation is to define accurately the responsibilities of governments at different levels in policy implementation.

Street-Level Bureaucracy and the Over-Standardization of Policy Implementation: An Analysis of Urban Management through the Destruction of Merchant Couplets

How Street-Level Bureaucrats Collaborate for Policy Entrepreneurship: Insights from Anti-Poverty Policy Implementation in China

The Power of the Street-Level Bureaucrat in Public Service Bureaucracies

The Street-Level Bureaucracy at the Intersection of Formal and Informal Water Provision

Local Government Competition and Centralised Urban Growth Management Policy Implementation: Evidence from China

Implementing targeted poverty alleviation: a policy implementation typology

Do visiting monks give better sermons? “Street‐level bureaucrats from higher‐up” in targeted poverty alleviation in China

Enlisting Citizens: Forging the Effectiveness of Policy Implementation in Local China

Analysis of Bureaucracy Problem in Participatory Irrigation Management Model

Street-Level Leadership: Rethinking the Role of Public Servants in Contemporary Governance

Street‐level bureaucrats as policy entrepreneurs: Action strategies for flexible community governance in China

Intense Monitoring and Bureaucratic Support for an Anti-poverty Campaign in China

A Study of Symbolic Policy Implementation Phenomenon in China

Criticizing and Introspecting on Public School's "Bureaucracy Criticism"

How Intermediate Government Facilitates Top-Down Policy Experimentation: Empirical Insights from Rural Land Marketization in Shanghai

Action Logic and Regulation Measures of Urban Management Misconduct

Small Town Social Management Innovation For Healthy Urbanization: Enlarging Township Administrative Power Practice And Meaning

Research on the Application of Standardization in the Urban Governance of Disused Vehicle

Clients' Help Deservingness, Crowd Situational Stress and Discretionary Decision-making: an Experimental Study of Regulatory Street-level Bureaucrats in China

Career concerns and multitasking local bureaucrats: Evidence of a target-based performance evaluation system in China

Serving many masters: Public accountability in private policy implementation