Abstract:Background. Prognosis of kidney transplant outcomes, while clinically important, represents a challenging problem. Existing prediction models use the predictors that are available in the post-transplant period. However, the real value of a model is to predict outcomes prior to the transplantation, yet there is little experience in predicting graft survival using pretransplant variables. Furthermore, the prediction models developed using national registry data in previous studies have not been validated in the local clinical environment. This study is one of the first to apply a model derived from aggregate national dataset to a local dataset for validation. Methods. Five classification tree models predicting I, 3, 5, 7, and 10 years posttransplant graft survival have been derived from the United States Renal Data System (USRDS) data in our previous studies. The models included only those predictors that are available prior to kidney transplantation. In this study, the local clinical data were used to validate the models. The local data sources included the Enterprise Data Warehouse (EDW), the Solid Organ Transplant Program, and the Dialysis Program at the University of Utah Health Science Center (UUHSC). A comparative analysis was conducted regarding the data characteristics of the transplant recipients between the national (USRDS) and local (UUHSC) datasets. The performance of the prediction models were evaluated using both the national and local data. Results. In the USRDS dataset, the numbers of the patients with a long enough follow-up to reach the graft outcomes ("fail'" or "survive") at 1, 3, 5, 7, and 10 years posttransplant were 92,844, 73,672, 58,005, 46,791, and 35,279, respectively. In the UllHSC dataset, the numbers of the patients who had known graft outcomes at 1,3,5,7, and 10 years post-transplant were 854, 635, 462, 325, and 213, respectively. We found that the graft survival rates among the transplant recipients from the UUHSC dataset are significantly higher than those from the USRDS dataset (94% vs. 86%; 87% vs. 72%; 77% vs. 54%; 61 % vs. 36%; and 33% vs. 8% at 1, 3, 5, 7, and 10 years post-transplant, respectively, all p<O.OO I). The majority of the recipients (>93%) and the donors (> 95%) were white at the UUHSC. In addition, the UUHSC dataset showed a significantly higher proportion of living donors than the USRDS dataset at 1 year (42% vs. 24%, p<O.OO 1), 3 years (42% vs. 24%, p<O.OOI), 5 years (41% vs. 22%, p<O.OOl), 7 years (40% vs. 20%, p<O.OO 1), and 10 years (39% vs. 1 8%, p<O .00 1 ). Discrimination of the prediction models was measured by the area under the ROC curve (AUC). The AUC values of the models predicting 1, 3, 5, 7, and 10 year graft survival on the USRDS data were 0.59, 0.63, 0.76, 0.91, and 0.97, respectively. In contrast, the AUC values of the models predicting 1,3,5, 7, and 10 year graft survival on the UUHSC data were 0.54, 0.58, 0.58,0.61. and 0.70, respectively. Conclusion. The prediction models performed better on the national data than on the local data. This is almost certainly due to the differences in the data characteristics between the two datasets. Researchers routinely extrapolate the results from national studies to local circumstances, but this study is one of the first to show the potential dangers of doing so with real world data. Adopting wholesale a prediction model developed on a large national dataset for local purposes should be done with caution.

A System for the Combined Carbon Capture and Utilization to Produce Renewable Methanol from Biogas

Carbon Utilization Through Power to Gas and Oxyfuel Combustion Hybridization with Recycled CO2: Design and Preliminary Results

Design and Development of Integrated Direct Air Capture and Methanation Processes

Integrated CO 2 capture and conversion into methanol units: Assessing techno-economic and environmental aspects compared to CO 2 into SNG alternative

Toward Carbon‐Negative Methanol Production from Biogas: Intensified Membrane Reactor

Optimization of the Ex Situ Biomethanation of Hydrogen and Carbon Dioxide in a Novel Meandering Plug Flow Reactor: Start-Up Phase and Flexible Operation

Conceptual Process Design and Technoeconomic Analysis of an e-Methanol Plant with Direct Air-Captured CO 2 and Electrolytic H 2

Simultaneous Biogas Upgrading and Valuable Chemical Production Using Homoacetogens in a Membrane Biofilm Reactor

Integrated Capture and Conversion of CO2 to Methanol in a Post‐Combustion Capture Solvent: Heterogeneous Catalysts for Selective CN Bond Cleavage

Sustainable Biomethanol and Biomethane Production via Anaerobic Digestion, Oxy-Fuel Gas Turbine and Amine Scrubbing CO2 Capture

Integrated Capture and Conversion of CO2 to Methane using a Water-lean, Post-Combustion CO2 Capture Solvent.

A novel system integrating water electrolysis and supercritical CO 2 cycle for biomass to methanol

Methanol production by CO2 hydrogenation: Analysis and simulation of reactor performance

Utilizing carbon dioxide from refinery for methanol and electricity co-production: System design and economic assessment

Bio-methane and bio-methanol co-production from biogas: A profitability analysis to explore new sustainable chemical processes

Power-to-Gas: Process analysis and control strategies for dynamic catalytic methanation system

VALIDATING PREDICTION MODELS OF KIDNEY TRANSPLANT OUTCOME USING LOCAL DATA by

A Search Strategy to Optimize the Affine Variant Properties of S-Boxes

Waste CO 2 capture and utilization for methanol production via a novel membrane contactor reactor process: Techno-economic analysis (TEA), and comparison with other existing and emerging technologies

A novel structure of natural gas, electricity, and methanol production using a combined reforming cycle: Integration of biogas upgrading, liquefied natural gas re-gasification, power plant, and methanol synthesis unit

Flue-to-fuel: Bio-integrated carbon capture and utilization of dilute carbon dioxide gas streams to renewable methane