Abstract:Our memories of other people shape how we interact with them. Yet, even when we forget exactly what others said or did, we often remember impressions that capture a general gist of their behavior-whether they were forthright, friendly, or funny. Drawing on fuzzy trace theory, we propose two modes of social impression formation: impressions formed based on ordinal gist ("more competent," "less competent") or categorical gist ("competent," "incompetent"). In turn, we propose that people gravitate toward the simplest representation available and that different modes of memory have distinct consequences for social decisions. Specifically, ordinal impressions lead people to make decisions based on an individual's standing relative to others, whereas categorical impressions lead people to make decisions based on discrete classifications that interpret behavior. In four experiments, participants learned about two groups of individuals who differed in their competence (Studies 1a, 2, and 3) or generosity (Study 1b). When participants encoded impressions as ordinal rankings, they preferred to hire or help a relatively good target from a low-performing group over a relatively bad target from a high-performing group, even though both targets behaved identically and accuracy was incentivized. However, when participants could use categorical boundaries to interpret behavior, this preference was eliminated. In a final experiment, changing the category participants used to encode others' generosity changed their impressions, even when accounting for memory for verbatim details. This work links social impressions to theories of mental representation in memory and judgment, highlighting how distinct representations support divergent patterns of social decision-making. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).

Effects of information on interpersonal attraction: Similarity versus affective value.

Information processing approaches to interpersonal attraction

The Effects of Implicit Egotism on Interpersonal Attractiveness

Effects of Actual (Manipulated) and Perceived Similarity on Liking in Get-acquainted Interactions: The Role of Communication

Self-disclosure and attraction: Effects of intimacy and desirability on beliefs and attitudes

Do accurate personality impressions benefit early relationship development? The bidirectional associations between accuracy and liking.

Depth of processing, belief congruence, and attitude-behavior correspondence

Two modes of social impressions and their effects on choice.

How to Be "groupy" Matters: Groups with Shared Traits and Shared Goals Engender Distinct Patterns of Social Judgments

Attitude theory and the attitude-behavior re l ation

Information as a Moderator of Accuracy in Personality Judgment

Perceived general similarity and relationship satisfaction: The role of attributional confidence

Like yourself, and others will follow: The role of target self-esteem in the association between being seen accurately and being liked in platonic and romantic first impressions.

Attitudes and the prediction of behavior

Consistency and bias in the attribution of attitudes.

Interdependence and Interpersonal Attraction Among Heterogeneous and Homogeneous Individuals: A Theoretical Formulation and a Meta-analysis of the Research

Testing the Effect of Sending an Evaluative Message on Perceiving Others in Computer-Mediated Communication

Is attitude research incompatible with the compatibility principle

Good conduct makes your face attractive: The effect of personality perception on facial attractiveness judgments

EXPLORING THE MECHANISM FOR INTERPERSONAL ATTRACTION:I-SHARING AS AN IMPORTANT FACTOR AND EMOTION AS A MEDIATOR

The Effect of Moral Behavior on Facial Attractiveness