Abstract:High penetrations of non-synchronous renewable energy generation can decrease overall grid stability because these units do not provide rotational inertia in the same way as traditional synchronously-connected generators. Many recent studies have investigated 100% renewable energy generation scenarios, but few have explored the trade-offs associated with an electricity grid dominated by non-synchronous generation (i.e. wind and solar). Fast frequency response from grid-forming inverters—along with other technology changes—could help mitigate low system inertia levels, but the impact of this response is unknown. An inertia-constrained unit commitment and dispatch model was used to study the stability of future grid scenarios with high penetrations of non-synchronous renewable energy generation under a variety of technology scenarios. The Texas grid (the Electric Reliability Council of Texas – ERCOT) was used as a test case and instances when the system inertia fell below 100 GW<math>·</math>s (the grid's current minimum level) were recorded. When the modeled critical inertia limit was reduced to 80 GW<math>·</math>s to represent changes in grid operation, no critical inertia hours occurred for renewable energy penetrations up to 93% of annual energy. The critical inertia limit could drop to 60 GW<math>·</math>s if the largest generators in ERCOT (two co-located nuclear plants) were retired, but emissions increased by <math>~</math>25% in these scenarios. If the critical inertia limit was kept the same (100 GW<math>·</math>s), adding 525 MW of fast frequency response from wind, solar, and energy storage could reduce the number of critical inertia hours by up to 95%. These results show that changes to grid operating practices and generator retirements reduced critical inertia hours more than fast frequency response from inverter-connected resources. Each of these mitigation pathways has associated trade-offs, so the transition to a grid dominated by non-synchronous energy generation should be handled with care, but high renewable energy penetrations (i.e. >80%) might be feasible in Texas.

Assessment of frequency stability and required inertial support for power grids with high penetration of renewable energy sources

Assessment and management of frequency stability in low inertia renewable energy rich power grids

Analytic Assessment of the Power System Frequency Security

Probabilistic Assessment on Area-Level Frequency Nadir/Vertex for Operational Planning

Assessing Grid Strength of 100% Inverter-Based Power Systems

Frequency Stability of Renewable Energy Integrated Low-Inertia Power Systems During Grid Faults

Enhancing Frequency Emergency Control with Battery Energy Storage Systems in Low-Inertia Power Grid

Small-signal Stability Analysis of Power Systems under Uncertain Renewable Generation

Simultaneous Assessment of Multiple Aspects of Stability of Power Systems with Renewable Generation

Understanding the impact of non-synchronous wind and solar generation on grid stability and identifying mitigation pathways

A Framework for Frequency Stability Assessment of Future Power Systems: An Australian Case Study

A critical evaluation of grid stability and codes, energy storage and smart loads in power systems with wind generation

Extensive frequency response and inertia analysis under high renewable energy source integration scenarios: application to the European interconnected power system

Impact of renewable energy penetration rate on power system frequency stability

Online estimation of inertia and frequency regulation capability based on small perturbation

Reliability Assessment of Power System Considering the Impact of Renewable Energy Sources Integration Into Grid With Advanced Intelligent Strategies

Inertia and Primary Frequency Response Requirement Assessment for High-Penetration Renewable Power Systems Based on Planning Perspective

Study on Quantitative Evaluation Index of Power System Frequency Response Capability

Frequency Stability Enhancement of Microgrid Using Optimization Techniques-Based Adaptive Virtual Inertia Control

Review on Stability and Power Quality Problem and Mitigation on Renewable Energy Penetration in Grid System

Exploring the gaps in renewable energy integration to grid