A critical evaluation of grid stability and codes, energy storage and smart loads in power systems with wind generation

Dlzar Al kez,Aoife M. Foley,Neil McIlwaine,D. John Morrow,Barry P. Hayes,M. Alparslan Zehir,Laura Mehigan,Behnaz Papari,Chris S. Edrington,Mesut Baran

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2020.117671

IF: 9

2020-08-01

Energy

Abstract:Existing power systems are facing new challenges in maintaining the security of the power system as the penetration of variable renewable energy technologies, such as variable speed wind turbines, increase. System non-synchronous generation replaces conventional generators as penetration of renewable generation increases. This affects system rotational inertia and limits the number of online thermal generators that can provide frequency stability services and system-wide areas voltage stability. This evolution has resulted in some changes to existing grid codes and new ancillary services. Furthermore, it could provide opportunities to address the security of the system utilizing modern smart technologies, e.g. smart loads, heat pumps and electric vehicles. The aim of this paper is to evaluate the impacts of large-scale renewable power generation on power system dynamics from the perspective of the power system operator. It focuses on the grid codes implications and challenges specifically. Synthetic inertia response opportunities from smart loads, electric vehicles and energy storage technologies and dispatching wind farms during frequency excursions are analyzed and thoroughly discussed. The key finding is that rethinking in the development of grid code requirements and market mechanisms are needed if a power system based on 100% power electronic renewable generation is to be achieved. This type of power system would need a range of technologies to provide the types of ancillary (i.e. system) services required, as none of the technologies alone can tackle all the challenges presented.

energy & fuels,thermodynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the impact on the dynamic stability of the power system after a high proportion of renewable energy (especially wind energy) is connected to the grid. With the increase in the penetration rate of renewable energy, traditional synchronous generators are replaced by asynchronous generation units, resulting in a reduction in system inertia, which in turn affects the frequency stability and voltage stability of the system. Specifically:

1. **Reduction in system inertia**: Renewable energy technologies (such as variable - frequency wind turbines) are usually decoupled from the grid through power - electronic converters, which limits their natural ability to respond to frequency changes. Therefore, a high proportion of these technologies will significantly reduce the inertia of the entire system, making the system more likely to have problems such as an increase in frequency deviation (nadir) and rate of change of frequency (RoCoF) when facing power imbalances.

2. **Challenges to frequency stability**: The reduction in system inertia will lead to an increase in the rate of change of frequency, thereby increasing the risk of system - frequency fluctuations. In the case of large - scale wind power integration, if there is insufficient frequency support, it may lead to too - low or too - high frequencies, which in turn will trigger load shedding or system black - start, seriously affecting the safe operation of the power system.

3. **Challenges to voltage stability**: The high - proportion integration of wind power will also affect the voltage stability of the system. Especially after a fault event occurs, the system needs to be able to maintain the voltage level, while the voltage regulation ability of wind power generation units is limited, and additional reactive power compensation devices may be required to support voltage stability.

4. **Changes in grid codes and requirements for ancillary services**: In order to address the above challenges, it is necessary to re - evaluate and adjust grid codes and introduce new ancillary services (such as fast - frequency response, inertia enhancement, etc.) to ensure the stable operation of the power system. The paper explores how to use modern technologies such as smart loads, electric vehicles, and energy - storage technologies to provide these ancillary services, thereby improving the flexibility and stability of the system.

In summary, this paper aims to evaluate the impact of high - proportion renewable energy integration on the dynamic stability of the power system and propose solutions to ensure the safe and reliable operation of future power systems.