Abstract:Empirical studies on selective teaching and informing indicate that children may vary what they teach depending on whom they are teaching, taking into account how helpful the information is for a given audience. The current meta‐analysis quantifies the effect of selective informing and teaching in 2–7‐year‐olds by examining the relationship between the helpfulness of the information and the frequency of information transmission. Through a systematic search that yielded 1483 results, 28 studies (104 effect sizes, N = 2716) met the inclusion criteria. Using robust variance estimation, we found a medium average effect, Hedges' g = 0.578, 95% CI (0.331, 0.825), suggesting that children selectively share information based on its perceived helpfulness to the listener. Moderator analyses revealed that age and communicative context were significant factors. Children were more informative in their communication when asked to teach compared to other nonpedagogical prompts. This finding supports and extends natural pedagogy theory—young children not only interpret pedagogical information differently than information acquired through other means, but they are more selective in their informing when teaching. Additionally, we observed a key developmental progression at age 4. Four‐ to 7‐year‐olds, but not 2–3‐year‐olds, selectively shared information that was most helpful for a given learner. This coincides with the development of false‐belief understanding, which undergoes significant development at around age 4. Taken together, the present synthesis suggests that young children actively engage in selective social learning from both sides, that of beneficiaries and benefactors of valuable information.

Young children can infer information preferences from goals and recommend appropriate sources to others.

Children adapt their information search to goal and statistical structure of a problem

Children's Selective Teaching and Informing: A Meta‐Analysis

Able and willing: Infants selectively seek help from competent and benevolent others

Children’s selective information sharing based on the recipient’s role

Young Children Use Statistical Sampling to Infer the Preferences of Other People

Preschoolers' information search strategies: Inefficient but adaptive

Says who? Children consider informants' sources when deciding whom to believe.

Young Children's Help-Seeking as Active Information Gathering

Robust, Source-Independent Biases in Children's Use of Socially and Individually Acquired Information

Adult age differences in noninstrumental information-seeking strategies.

Know thy audience: Children teach basic or complex facts depending on the learner's maturity

Relationships that Foster Intrinsic Motivation for Information Seeking

Children Infer Intentions by Assessing Epistemic Attitudes in Interpersonal Interactions

Infants and toddlers leverage their understanding of action goals to evaluate agents who help others

Knowledge and source type influence children's skepticism of misinformation

Age‐related changes in information‐seeking behavior about morally relevant events

Trusting information from friends: Adults expect it but preschoolers do not.

How does Google get its information?: Children's judgements about Google search

Children With More Uncertainty in Their Intuitive Theories Seek Domain-Relevant Information

Children'S Buying Behaviour In China A Study Of Their Information Sources