Children Infer Intentions by Assessing Epistemic Attitudes in Interpersonal Interactions

Nina Ni Ye,Xiao Pan Ding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15248372.2024.2430193

2024-11-28

Journal of Cognition and Development

Abstract:Children rely on the information gained in their observations of others to make inferences about intentions. Such observations often involve an informant who makes a claim, a receiver's epistemic attitude toward the informant, and the outcome of that interpersonal interaction. The present research aimed to examine whether young children can infer an informant's intentions when making trust judgments by considering the epistemic attitudes of receivers. Three- to 6-year-old children in Singapore observed informants suggesting object locations (Study 1, N = 43) and labels (Study 2, N = 73) to receivers, who accepted or rejected these suggestions, resulting in a positive or negative outcome. In Study 1, older children, but not younger ones, trusted honest informants more than deceptive ones in the object location task, but this distinction was not observed in the object naming task. Study 2 replicated these findings, showing that older children could differentiate between honest and deceptive informants in tasks similar in domain to the observed information. Older children demonstrated selective trust in both tasks, indicating their ability to generalize selective trust decisions across domains. These findings indicate that preschool children pay particular attention to interpersonal interactions when making trustworthiness judgments. More broadly, they speak to children's flexible and theory-like mentalistic reasoning of what it means to be trustworthy rather than resorting to simple heuristics and assuming straightforward associations between outcome and traits.

psychology, experimental, developmental