A comparison of slope stability assessment techniques using different rock mass classification systems and finite element method (FEM): A case study from the Garhwal Himalayas, India
Neeraj Dahiya,Koushik Pandit,Shantanu Sarkar
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12040-022-01988-w
2022-11-27
Journal of Earth System Science
Abstract:The Himalayan belt is highly susceptible to landslides since majority of slopes comprise of highly weathered and deformed rocks with unfavourable orientation of structural discontinuities. Inappropriate planning of road-cutting often weakens the existing hill slopes, often triggering slides due to antecedent rainfall or earthquake occurrence. In the present study, a road stretch (~25 km length) along the National Highway (NH-58) between Shivpuri to Kaudiyala in Garhwal Himalayas of Uttarakhand, India has been studied which includes a mix of stable, partially stable and unstable road-cut slopes. Various rockmass classification techniques such as Geological Strength Index (GSI), Rock Mass Rating (RMR basic ) , Slope Mass Rating (SMR), Continuous Slope Mass Rating (CSMR) and Q-slope have been used for qualitative slope stability assessment. A quantified slope stability analysis by deterministic approach of all these studied road-cut slopes has been carried out using two-dimensional finite element method. Further, a comparative study has been performed between qualitative and quantified outcomes of the stability analysis. Finally, following the slope support guidelines chart based on SMR, stability analyses of two significant road-cut slopes have been carried out to understand their practical implications. It has been concluded that both SMR and CSMR techniques showed similar results for the stability grades of the studied slopes. However, these classification techniques are more effective for rapid assessment of slope stability, whereas the deterministic approach through finite element analysis is more prudent for designing any slope stability measures. Therefore, the presented methodology will be useful for a critical assessment of slope stability vis-à-vis to prepare a guideline for selection of appropriate design of control measures. Research highlights Rock mass classification techniques such as Geological Strength Index (GSI), Rock Mass Rating (RMR basic ) , Slope Mass Rating (SMR), Continuous Slope Mass Rating (CSMR) and Q-slope have been used for qualitative slope stability assessment. A quantified slope stability analysis of all these studied road cut slopes has been carried out using 2-dimensional finite element method. Finally, a comparative study has been performed between qualitative and quantified outcomes of the stability analysis. Further, following the slope support guidelines chart based on SMR (Romana, 1985), stability analysis of two significant road cut slopes has been carried out to exhibit their practical implications.
geosciences, multidisciplinary