Abstract:We study random-turn resource-allocation games. In the Trail of Lost Pennies, a counter moves on $\mathbb{Z}$. At each turn, Maxine stakes $a \in [0,\infty)$ and Mina $b \in [0,\infty)$. The counter $X$ then moves adjacently, to the right with probability $\tfrac{a}{a+b}$. If $X_i \to -\infty$ in this infinte-turn game, Mina receives one unit, and Maxine zero; if $X_i \to \infty$, then these receipts are zero and $x$. Thus the net receipt to a given player is $-A+B$, where $A$ is the sum of her stakes, and $B$ is her terminal receipt. The game was inspired by unbiased tug-of-war in~[PSSW] from 2009 but in fact closely resembles the original version of tug-of-war, introduced [HarrisVickers87] in the economics literature in 1987. We show that the game has surprising features. For a natural class of strategies, Nash equilibria exist precisely when $x$ lies in $[\lambda,\lambda^{-1}]$, for a certain $\lambda \in (0,1)$. We indicate that $\lambda$ is remarkably close to one, proving that $\lambda \leq 0.999904$ and presenting clear numerical evidence that $\lambda \geq 1 - 10^{-4}$. For each $x \in [\lambda,\lambda^{-1}]$, we find countably many Nash equilibria. Each is roughly characterized by an integral {\em battlefield} index: when the counter is nearby, both players stake intensely, with rapid but asymmetric decay in stakes as it moves away. Our results advance premises [HarrisVickers87,Konrad12] for fund management and the incentive-outcome relation that plausibly hold for many player-funded stake-governed games. Alongside a companion treatment [HP22] of games with allocated budgets, we thus offer a detailed mathematical treatment of an illustrative class of tug-of-war games. We also review the separate developments of tug-of-war in economics and mathematics in the hope that mathematicians direct further attention to tug-of-war in its original resource-allocation guise.

Tipping and strong rarity value in a stochastic fishery game

Rarity Value and Species Extinction: The Anthropogenic Allee Effect

MODELING THE EFFECT OF RARITY VALUE ON THE EXPLOITATION OF A WILDLIFE SPECIES SUBJECTED TO THE ALLEE EFFECT

Fisheries management as a Stackelberg Evolutionary Game: Finding an evolutionarily enlightened strategy

Stochastic perturbations and fisheries management

Opportunistic exploitation: an overlooked pathway to extinction

Effects of increasing risk in common resource exploitation under cost asymmetry

Tipping point realized in cod fishery

A nonautonomous model for the effect of rarity value on the dynamics of a predator–prey system with variable harvesting

Effects of stochasticity and social norms on complex dynamics of fisheries

Optimal Exploration of an Exhaustible Resource with Stochastic Discoveries

Transient Perturbations Reveal Distinct Strategies for Reserve Benefits in Life History-Dependent Ecosystems

Optimal escapement in stage-structured fisheries with environmental stochasticity

Playing games against nature: optimal policies for renewable resource allocation

The tragedy of the commons: a Mean-Field Game approach to the reversal of travelling waves

On Optimal Harvesting Problems in Random Environments

Feasibility of a fishery regulation model. A pulse quota fishing policy with environmental stochasticity

Evaluating the consequences: Impact of sex-selective harvesting on fish population and identifying tipping points via life-history parameters

Optimal harvesting of stochastic spatial resources

On the Trail of Lost Pennies: player-funded tug-of-war on the integers

Fragility of the Commons under Prospect-Theoretic Risk Attitudes