Abstract:Despite major advances in quantitative approaches to natural resource management, there has been resistance to using these tools in the actual practice of managing ecological populations. Given a managed system and a set of assumptions, translated into a model, optimization methods can be used to solve for the most cost effective management actions. However, when the underlying assumptions are not met, such methods can potentially lead to poor decisions. Managers who develop decisions based on past experience and judgment, without the aid of mathematical models, can potentially learn about the system and develop flexible management strategies. However, these strategies are often based on subjective criteria and equally invalid and often unstated assumptions. Given the drawbacks of both methods, it is unclear whether simple quantitative models improve environmental decision making over expert opinion. In this paper, we explore how well students, using their experience and judgment, manage simulated fishery populations in an online computer game and compare their management outcomes to the performance of model-based decisions. We consider harvest decisions generated using four different quantitative models: 1. the model used to produce the simulated population dynamics observed in the game, with all underlying parameter values known [a control], 2. the same model, but with unknown parameter values that must be estimated during the game from observed data, 3. models that are structurally different from those used to simulate the population dynamics and 4. a model that ignores age structure. Humans on average performed much worse than the models in cases 1 - 3. When the models ignored age structure, they generated poorly performing management decisions, but still outperformed students using experience and judgment 66 percent of the time.

Playing games against nature: optimal policies for renewable resource allocation

Optimal harvesting policy for biological resources with uncertain heterogeneity for application in fisheries management

Biological Interactions and Cooperative Management of Multiple Species

Optimal harvesting of stochastic spatial resources

Fisheries Management in Congested Waters: A Game-Theoretic Assessment of the East China Sea

Optimal Interventions in Coupled-Activity Network Games: Application to Sustainable Forestry

Optimal Quota for a Multi-species Fishing Models

Optimal Exploitation of a Resource with Stochastic Population Dynamics and Delayed Renewal

Stochastic perturbations and fisheries management

Effects of increasing risk in common resource exploitation under cost asymmetry

A multi-agent reinforcement learning model of common-pool resource appropriation

Markov decision process routing games

Best Response Sequences and Tradeoffs in Submodular Resource Allocation Games

Human judgment vs. theoretical models for the management of ecological resources

Optimal escapement in stage-structured fisheries with environmental stochasticity

Generalized Nash Equilibrium Models for Asymmetric, Non-cooperative Games on Line Graphs: Application to Water Resource Systems

Resolving the measurement uncertainty paradox in ecological management

Robust Policy Selection and Harvest Risk Quantification for Natural Resources Management under Model Uncertainty

Dynamics and Optimal Harvesting for Fishery Models with Reserved Areas

A Bayesian game of resource exploitation in hinterland regions: modelling scenarios for sustainable development