Abstract:Density-dependent population dynamic models strongly influence many of the world's most important harvest policies. Nearly all classic models (e.g. Beverton-Holt and Ricker) recommend that managers maintain a population size of roughly 40-50 percent of carrying capacity to maximize sustainable harvest, no matter the species' population growth rate. Such insights are the foundational logic behind most sustainability targets and biomass reference points for fisheries. However, a simple, less-commonly used model, called the Hockey-Stick model, yields very different recommendations. We show that the optimal population size to maintain in this model, as a proportion of carrying capacity, is one over the population growth rate. This leads to more conservative optimal harvest policies for slow-growing species, compared to other models, if all models use the same growth rate and carrying capacity values. However, parameters typically are not fixed; they are estimated after model-fitting. If the Hockey-Stick model leads to lower estimates of carrying capacity than other models, then the Hockey-Stick policy could yield lower absolute population size targets in practice. Therefore, to better understand the population size targets that may be recommended across real fisheries, we fit the Hockey-Stick, Ricker and Beverton-Holt models to population time series data across 284 fished species from the RAM Stock Assessment database. We found that the Hockey-Stick model usually recommended fisheries maintain population sizes higher than all other models (in 69-81% of the data sets). Furthermore, in 77% of the datasets, the Hockey-Stick model recommended an optimal population target even higher than 60% of carrying capacity (a widely used target, thought to be conservative). However, there was considerable uncertainty in the model fitting. While Beverton-Holt fit several of the data sets best, Hockey-Stick also frequently fit similarly well. In general, the best-fitting model rarely had overwhelming support (a model probability of greater than 95% was achieved in less than five percent of the datasets). A computational experiment, where time series data were simulated from all three models, revealed that Beverton-Holt often fit best even when it was not the true model, suggesting that fisheries data are likely too small and too noisy to resolve uncertainties in the functional forms of density-dependent growth. Therefore, sustainability targets may warrant revisiting, especially for slow-growing species.

Evaluating the consequences: Impact of sex-selective harvesting on fish population and identifying tipping points via life-history parameters

Effects of stochasticity and social norms on complex dynamics of fisheries

Size-selective Harvesting Alters Biological Traits of Marine Medaka (oryzias Melastigma)

How ecological processes shape the outcomes of stock enhancement and harvest regulations in recreational fisheries.

Impact of Harvesting on a Bioeconomic Predator-Prey Fishery Model Subject to Environmental Toxicant

The Effect of Seasonal Harvesting on Stage-Structured Population Models

Understanding the impact of selective fishery and bycatch on stock dynamics

Dynamics and Optimal Harvesting for Fishery Models with Reserved Areas

Utilizing spatial demographic and life history variation to optimize sustainable yield of a temperate sex-changing fish

Assessing trade-offs to inform ecosystem-based fisheries management of forage fish

The Effects of Selective Harvest on Japanese Spanish Mackerel (Scomberomorus niphonius) Phenotypic Evolution

Accounting for salmon body size declines in fishery management can reduce conservation risks

Pelagic and Demersal Fish Population Rebuilding in Response to Fisheries-Induced Evolution in Exploited China Seas

Bioeconomic analysis of harvesting within a predator-prey system: A case study in the Chesapeake Bay fisheries

Recognizing and prevention of probable regime shift in density regulated and Allee type stochastic harvesting model with application to herring conservation

Experimental evidence of size-selective harvest and environmental stochasticity effects on population demography, fluctuations and non-linearity

Revisiting Fishery Sustainability Targets

Interaction between harvesting intervention and birth perturbation in an age-structured model

The Effects of Selective Harvest on Exploited Population and Economic Benefits

Study on Dynamic Behavior of Two Fishery Harvesting Models: Effects of Variable Prey Refuge and Imprecise Biological Parameters

Discrete-Time Model of an Exploited Population with Age and Sex Structures: Instability and the Hydra Effect