Abstract:The main characteristics of the cooling phase of post-flashover compartment fires are studied using a simplified first-principles heat transfer approach to establish key limitations of more traditional methodologies (e.g., Eurocode). To this purpose, the boundary conditions during cooling are analysed. To illustrate the importance of a first-principles approach, a detailed review of the literature is presented followed by the presentation of a simplified numerical model. The model is constructed to calculate first-order thermal conditions during the cooling phase. The model is not intended to provide a precise calculation method but rather baseline estimates that incorporate all key thermal inputs and outputs. First, the thermal boundary conditions in the heating phase are approximated with a single (gas) temperature and the Eurocode parametric fire curves, to provide a consistent initial condition for the cooling phase and to be able to compare the traditional approach to the first-principles approach. After fuel burnout, the compartment gases become optically thin and temperatures decay to ambient values, while the compartment solid elements slowly cool down. For simplicity, convective cooling of the compartment linings is estimated using a constant convective heat transfer coefficient and all linings surfaces are assumed to have the same temperature (no net radiative heat exchange). All structural elements are assumed to be thermally thick. While these simplifications introduce quantitative errors, they enable an analytical solution for transient heat conduction in a semi-infinite solid that captures all key heat transfer processes. Comparisons between the results obtained using both approaches highlight how, even when considering the same fire energy input, the thermal boundary conditions according to the Eurocode parametric fire curves lead to an increase energy accumulated in the solid after fuel burnout and a delay in the onset of cooling. This is not physically correct, and it may lead to misrepresentation of the impact of post-flashover fires on structural behaviour.

Notre-Dame de Paris as a validation case to improve fire safety modelling in historic buildings

A multi-model structural analysis of the vaults of Notre-Dame de Paris Cathedral after the 2019 fire and a proposal for a hybrid model merging continuum and discrete approaches

2D/3D data fusion for the comparative analysis of the vaults of Notre-Dame de Paris before and after the fire

Revealing the iron skeleton of Notre-Dame de Paris. Methodologies and issues of archaeological and analytical investigations following the blaze

Faceting the post-disaster built heritage reconstruction process within the digital twin framework for Notre-Dame de Paris

Structural study of the Notre-Dame ancient charpente

A digital ecosystem for the multidisciplinary study of Notre-Dame de Paris

FIRE PROTECTION IN RELIGIOUS MONUMENTS: ON THE EXAMPLE OF NOTRE-DAME DE PARIS AND THE CATHEDRAL OF ST. PETER AND ST. PAUL IN NANTES, FRANCE

Sensibility Analysis of Traditional Span Frame

Structural Fire Risk for Heritage Buildings by the Performance-Based Engineering Format

Development of a Fluid–Structure Coupling Validated with a Confined Fire: Application to Painted Caves

Thermal characterisation of the cooling phase of post-flashover compartment fires

Modelling the Response of Timber Beams Under Fire

Modeling the behavior of reinforced concrete walls under fire, considering the impact of the span on firewalls

Compartment fires: Challenges for fire modeling as a tool for a safe design (IAFSS workshop, April 2021)

Recent advances in fire–structure analysis

Model uncertainty in a parametric fire curve approach: A stochastic correction factor for the compartment fire load density

Experimental investigation on the effect of natural fire exposure on the post‐fire behavior of reinforced concrete beams using electric radiant panel

Experimental study of the wind pressure field on the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris

Scientific research on stained-glass windows for Notre-Dame de Paris Cathedral

A coupled hybrid numerical study of tunnel longitudinal ventilation under fire conditions