Sensibility Analysis of Traditional Span Frame

Lawrence Kauffmann,Jean-Luc Coureau,Alain Cointe,Philippe Galimard
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15583058.2024.2402306
2024-10-04
International Journal of Architectural Heritage
Abstract:Traditional timber frames may have a complex mechanical behavior regarding to today engineer skills and design standards. For an identical rebuilding as required for the Notre-Dame de Paris Cathedral, accurate modeling must be performed to assess modern reliability. Identical rebuilt means same green oak material, same geometry and timber connections. In the context of the rebuilt of the Notre-Dame carpentry, a part of the timber frame based on the original schemes of the nave extracted from historical graphic document was reproduced. A full-scale replica was erected in order to perform mechanical tests. Through an in-situ monitoring, this structure represents a case study in order to provide data relative to the kinetics of displacements. This investigation allows to evaluate the global behavior of the structure. Based on the finite element method (F.E.M), a dedicated model is used to analyze the sensitivity of the material properties, the beam geometry and the wood-to-wood connections in order to design the testing carried out on the wooden structure. From these full-scale tests, we determine the real stiffness of the carpentry. Then, a retro-analysis was proposed to evaluate the axial stiffness of connections according to the corresponding finite element model, by fitting data to reproduce the real displacements. The study reveals that this property is substantial to describe the global behavior. Furthermore, we carried out in the laboratory an experimental campaign consisting in characterizing traditional joints. The goal was to estimate their stiffness and their specific failure modes by using image correlation. Concomitantly, numerical simulations were developed in order to investigate the dependence of the stiffness according to moisture content variation of oak species. The global research supplies useful tools and results, which may be able to improve the understanding of the mechanical performance of traditional structures and provide valuable information for design purposes.
construction & building technology,engineering, civil
What problem does this paper attempt to address?