Low Magnitude Continuous and Intermittent Mechanical Vibration Effects on Nanoscale Topography and Mechanical Properties of Bone Fracture Healing
Lei Tan,Shicai Yang,Guozhao Liu,Bin Zhao,Chao Liu,Baohui Hao,Junhao Lin,Dong Zhu,Xizheng Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1166/jbt.2016.1503
2016-01-01
Journal of Biomaterials and Tissue Engineering
Abstract:Purpose: This study aims to develop a bone-healing model to evaluate the effect of mechanical vibration on bone-healing process by investigating bone morphological and biomechanical changes at nanoscale. Material and methods: 21 short-tailed Han sheep were subjected to right metatarsal osteotomy and randomly divided into three groups: control group (CT), continuous vibration (CV) group, and intermittent vibration (IV) group. Low-magnitude (35 Hz, 0.25 g) mechanical vibration was applied to fractured limbs on both CV and IV groups, two weeks after osteotomy. For CV group, all animals were treated daily for 15 minutes for 8 weeks. For IV group, all animals were treated daily for 15 minutes. However, the treatment comprised of 7 days' continuous loading followed by 7 days' rest, and continued for 8 weeks. Upon completion, all animals were euthanized, and metatarsi were harvested. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) and Nanoindentation testing were employed to evaluate the topographical and biomechanical properties of bone tissue at nanometer scale. Results: The size of mineral granules adjacent to fracture lines was ordered from smallest to largest as following: IV < CV < CT, while the surface roughness of these areas was in a reverse order, with CT< CV < IV. There are no significant differences for either elastic modulus (E) or hardness (H), or the E/H ratio (E/H) among three groups for the measured areas. In general, E, H, and E/H were higher in IV group compared with others. Conclusion: In this study, our results demonstrated that mechanical vibration can stimulate osteogenesis after metatarsal osteotomy, with intermittent vibration having the most active healing response. Low-magnitude vibration can enhance the mechanical properties of regenerated callus, with intermittent vibration having the best outcome. However, the insignificance of elastic modulus between vibration groups and control group may be due to inferior mechanical properties of primary callus formed during the time of experiments.