Abdominal drainage after elective colorectal surgery: propensity score-matched retrospective analysis of an Italian cohort
Stefano Guadagni,Marco Catarci,Francesco Masedu,Mohammad Ehsanul Karim,Marco Clementi,Giacomo Ruffo,Massimo Giuseppe Viola,Felice Borghi,Gianandrea Baldazzi,Marco Scatizzi,Felice Pirozzi,Paolo Delrio,Gianluca Garulli,Pierluigi Marini,Roberto Campagnacci,Raffaele De Luca,Ferdinando Ficari,Giuseppe Sica,Stefano Scabini,Andrea Liverani,Marco Caricato,Alberto Patriti,Stefano Mancini,Gian Luca Baiocchi,Roberto Santoro,Walter Siquini,Gianluca Guercioni,Massimo Basti,Corrado Pedrazzani,Mauro Totis,Alessandro Carrara,Andrea Lucchi,Maurizio Pavanello,Andrea Muratore,Stefano D’Ugo,Alberto Di Leo,Giusto Pignata,Ugo Elmore,Gabriele Anania,Massimo Carlini,Francesco Corcione,Nereo Vettoretto,Graziano Longo,Mario Sorrentino,Antonio Giuliani,Giovanni Ferrari,Lucio Taglietti,Augusto Verzelli,Mariantonietta Di Cosmo,Davide Cavaliere,Marco Milone,Stefano Rausei,Giovanni Ciaccio,Giovanni Tebala,Giuseppe Brisinda,Stefano Berti,Paolo Millo,Luigi Boni,Mario Guerrieri,Roberto Persiani,Dario Parini,Antonino Spinelli,Michele Genna,Vincenzo Bottino,Andrea Coratti,Dario Scala,Umberto Rivolta,Micaela Piccoli,Carlo Talarico,Franco Roviello,Alessandro Anastasi,Giuseppe Maria Ettorre,Mauro Montuori,Pierpaolo Mariani,Nicolò de Manzini,Annibale Donini,Mariano Fortunato Armellino,Carlo Feo,Silvio Guerriero,Andrea Costanzi,Federico Marchesi,Moreno Cicetti,Paolo Ciano,Michele Benedetti,Leonardo Antonio Montemurro,Maria Sole Mattei,Elena Belloni,Daniela Apa,Matteo Di Carlo,Elisa Bertocchi,Gaia Masini,Amedeo Altamura,Francesco Rubichi,Desirée Cianflocca,Marco Migliore,Diletta Cassini,Lorenzo Pandolfini,Alessandro Falsetto,Antonio Sciuto,Ugo Pace,Andrea Fares Bucci,Francesco Monari,Grazia Maria Attinà,Angela Maurizi,Michele Simone,Francesco Giudici,Fabio Cianchi,Bruno Sensi,Alessandra Aprile,Domenico Soriero,Andrea Scarinci,Gabriella Teresa Capolupo,Valerio Sisti,Marcella Lodovica Ricci,Andrea Sagnotta,Sarah Molfino,Pietro Amodio,Alessandro Cardinali,Simone Cicconi,Irene Marziali,Diletta Frazzini,Cristian Conti,Nicolò Tamini,Marco Braga,Michele Motter,Giuseppe Tirone,Giacomo Martorelli,Alban Cacurri,Carlo Di Marco,Patrizia Marsanic,Nicoletta Sveva Pipitone Federico,Marcello Spampinato,Lorenzo Crepaz,Jacopo Andreuccetti,Ilaria Canfora,Giulia Maggi,Matteo Chiozza,Domenico Spoletini,Rosa Marcellinaro,Umberto Bracale,Roberto Peltrini,Maria Michela Di Nuzzo,Emanuele Botteri,Simone Santoni,Massimo Stefanoni,Giovanni Del Vecchio,Carmelo Magistro,Silvia Ruggiero,Arianna Birindelli,Andrea Budassi,Daniele Zigiotto,Leonardo Solaini,Giorgio Ercolani,Giovanni Domenico De Palma,Silvia Tenconi,Paolo Locurto,Antonio Di Cintio,Maria Michela Chiarello,Maria Cariati,Andrea Gennai,Manuela Grivon,Elisa Cassinotti,Monica Ortenzi,Alberto Biondi,Maurizio De Luca,Francesco Carrano,Francesca Fior,Antonio Ferronetti,Giuseppe Giuliani,Graziella Marino,Camillo Leonardo Bertoglio,Francesca Pecchini,Vincenzo Greco,Roberto Piagnerelli,Giuseppe Canonico,Marco Colasanti,Enrico Pinotti,Roberta Carminati,Edoardo Osenda,Luigina Graziosi,Ciro De Martino,Giovanna Ioia,Fioralba Pindozzi,Lorenzo Organetti,Michela Monteleone,Giorgio Dalmonte,Gabriele La Gioia,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/bjsopen/zrad107
2024-01-03
BJS Open
Abstract:Abstract Background In Italy, surgeons continue to drain the abdominal cavity in more than 50 per cent of patients after colorectal resection. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of abdominal drain placement on early adverse events in patients undergoing elective colorectal surgery. Methods A database was retrospectively analysed through a 1:1 propensity score-matching model including 21 covariates. The primary endpoint was the postoperative duration of stay, and the secondary endpoints were surgical site infections, infectious morbidity rate defined as surgical site infections plus pulmonary infections plus urinary infections, anastomotic leakage, overall morbidity rate, major morbidity rate, reoperation and mortality rates. The results of multiple logistic regression analyses were presented as odds ratios (OR) and 95 per cent c.i. Results A total of 6157 patients were analysed to produce two well-balanced groups of 1802 patients: group (A), no abdominal drain(s) and group (B), abdominal drain(s). Group A versus group B showed a significantly lower risk of postoperative duration of stay >6 days (OR 0.60; 95 per cent c.i. 0.51–0.70; P < 0.001). A mean postoperative duration of stay difference of 0.86 days was detected between groups. No difference was recorded between the two groups for all the other endpoints. Conclusion This study confirms that placement of abdominal drain(s) after elective colorectal surgery is associated with a non-clinically significant longer (0.86 days) postoperative duration of stay but has no impact on any other secondary outcomes, confirming that abdominal drains should not be used routinely in colorectal surgery.
surgery