Performance evaluation of a novel multi-pinhole collimator on triple-NaI-detector SPECT/CT for dedicated myocardial imaging

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40658-023-00541-y

2023-03-26

EJNMMI Physics

Abstract:In this study we evaluated the imaging capabilities of a novel Multi-pinhole collimator (MPH-Cardiac) specially designed for nuclear cardiology imaging on a Triple-NaI-detector based SPECT/CT system.

radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Performance Evaluation of a Novel Multi-Pinhole SPECT System

Nianming Jiang,Hui Liu,Mengle Xue,Cheng Li,Lilei Gao,Fan Liu,Jing Wu,Yaqiang Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2023.168976

2024-01-01

Abstract:In this work, the performance of a novel multi-pinhole SPECT (MPH SPECT) system based on Insight NM/CT Pro (Beijing Novel Medical Equipment Ltd) was evaluated. The sensitivity, spatial resolution, and quantitative accuracy of the MPH system were evaluated in conjunction with the methods in NEMA NU 1-2018. In addition, the performance of MPH in myocardial perfusion imaging was validated by phantom study and clinical study. The average sensitivity of MPH SPECT at the center, half, and edges of field of view (FOV) were 510 count s(-1) MBq(-1) (cps/MBq), 490 +/- 85 cps/MBq and 540 +/- 170 cps/MBq, respectively; the spatial resolution is about 6.5 +/- 0.7 mm, 6.4 +/- 0.8 mm, and 5.4 +/- 0.4 mm for X, Y, and Z axes, respectively; the quantitative accuracy is superior to the conventional SPECT with low-energy high-resolution collimator (LEHR SPECT). The images of the phantom study and clinical study demonstrated the MPH SPECT can take only 5 minutes to obtain myocardial images with high image quality.
Design and evaluation of an adaptive multipinhole collimator for high-performance clinical and preclinical imaging

Chinhong Si,Greta S P Mok,Ling Chen,Benjamin M W Tsui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/MNM.0000000000000429

Abstract:Objective: Pinhole single-photon emission computed tomography provides superior trade-off between resolution and detection efficiency as compared with conventional parallel-hole collimators for imaging small objects. This study aims to design and evaluate an optimized adaptive multipinhole (MPH) collimator for improved clinical myocardial perfusion single-photon emission computed tomography imaging (MPI) and preclinical small-animal imaging (SAI) of rats based on a clinical scanner. Methods: The target resolution and field of view was set to be 1/20 cm for MPI and 0.15/5 cm for SAI, respectively. We determined the design parameters by maximizing the detection efficiency based on system constraints. Point source simulations using Geant4 Application for Emission Tomography were performed for different collimator-to-center of field of view distances to assess the detection efficiency and resolution trade-off. The XCAT phantom with Tc-99m sestamibi distribution and the four-dimensional mouse whole-body phantom with Tc-99m methylene diphosphonate distribution were used to generate noise-free and noisy projections using a three-dimensional analytical MPH projector. Projections were reconstructed using a three-dimensional MPH ordered-subset expectation maximization algorithm. Noise and bias were assessed on the reconstructed images for different collimators. Results: The design parameters are (i) 14 pinholes with 3.42 mm aperture size, 14.5 cm collimator-to-detector distance for MPI; (ii) six pinholes with an aperture size of 0.94 mm, 21.2 cm collimator-to-detector distance for SAI. For MPI, the projected full width at half maximum values were 10.68 and 8.19 mm for low energy high resolution (LEHR) and MPH, respectively, whereas MPH had double detection efficiency. For SAI, the projected full width at half maximum values for LEHR and MPH were 4.93 and 1.20 mm, respectively, whereas the detection efficiency of MPH showed 17.5% improvement as compared with LEHR. The noise-bias trade-off improved for MPH as compared with LEHR for both MPI and SAI. The proposed collimator will have adjustable collimator-to-detector distances - that is, 14.5 cm for MPI and 21.2 cm for SAI. Conclusion: The new collimator yields substantial improvement in image quality as compared with current MPI using LEHR with extra capability for SAI, bridging the clinical and preclinical imaging based on the same platform.
A Novel Technology of Multi-pinhole SPECT for Human Myocardial Perfusion Imaging

Chen Zhang,Haipeng Wang,Ming Xu,Tianpeng Xu,Yansong Hou,Nianming Jiang,Yaqiang Liu,Mai Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/nss/mic42101.2019.9059699

2019-01-01

Abstract:A novel technology of multi-pinhole (MPH) SPECT for human myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) by increasing angular sampling. In this study, the efficiency of MPH SPECT is 0.06%, four-fold higher than Dual-detector LEHR SPECT (typically 0.015%), we acquired projection data of patient MPI for rest and exercise with 12-pinhole collimator and Siemens Symbia T16. There are two cases for MPH SPECT scan in V mode: one view from -170°of main turning device, two views from -170°and -135°. Acquisition time of MPH SPECT was 5 minutes for single and dual angles, and the acquisition of Siemens was 15 minutes. MPH calibration is essential to generate system transfer matrix, which will be employed to iterative reconstruction. Projection data were reconstructed with a Pixel-based Ordered Subset-expectation Maximization (POSEM) reconstruction algorithm. Reconstructed results showed that dual-angle imaging results have better uniformity than single-angle imaging, and MPH SPECT has higher spatial resolution than Siemens Symbia T16 with reduced acquisition time. The short acquisition time of MPH can increase SPECT throughput and reduces the possibility of artifacts due to patient movement. More clinical trial for MPH dual angular sampling performance evaluation will be carried out.
Performance Evaluation of Stationary Dedicated Cardiac SPECT with Multi-Pinhole Collimators: Comparison with Conventional SPECT and CZT SPECT

Haipeng Wang,Feng Guo,Xinqiang Wang,Zongyao Zhang,Daoyu Wang,Yingying Xu,Yaqiang Liu,Si Chen

2018-01-01

Journal of Nuclear Medicine

Abstract:513 Objectives: The conventional low-energy high-resolution (LEHR) parallel-hole SPECT for nuclear cardiac imaging suffered from low sensitivity and spatial resolution. We designed and implemented a high sensitivity dedicated cardiac multi-pinhole collimator, which is capability for dynamic studies, based on the clinical variable-angle dual-head SPECT ImageE NET 632. The purpose of our study is to evaluate the performance of this multi-pinhole cardiac SPECT system (MP-SPECT). Methods Two SPECT detector heads were placed in 76 degree setup. Conventional parallel-hole collimators were replaced with the multi-pinhole collimators. Each collimator had twelve 4.5 mm tungsten pinholes and all the pinholes focused on the heart region without projection overlap. Five separate and parallel line sources phantom, injected by 2 mCi 99mTc, was scanned for 5 min and reconstructed with 80 MLEM iterations. The average FWHM in transversal image for each line was calculated and used to evaluate the spatial resolution. The volume sensitivity per axial centimeter (VSAC) was measured according to NEMA NU1-2012 with a scaled phantom. A heart phantom with two myocardium defects (2 cm and 1.5 cm in length), injected by 2 mCi 99mTc, was scanned for 5 min and reconstructed with 80 iterations. Two patients with suspicious of coronary heart disease were carried out MP-SPECT (5min) and reconstructed with 80 MLEM iterations. As compared, the patients also underwent MPS imaging on LEHR-SPECT BrightView XCT (15min), D-SPECT (5min) and Discovery NM 530c (5min) according to standard 1-day stress protocol. The reconstruction images were compared. Results The reconstruction spatial resolution (average FWHM of line sources) is 6.0 mm, better than LEHR SPECT (~14 mm). The measured VSAC is 92 s-1/(kBq[asterisk]cm2), about four times higher than LEHR SPECT typically 20 s-1/(kBq[asterisk]cm2 ). Reconstruction image of heart phantom was shown in Figure 1. The shape of myocardium was well reconstructed and both the two defects could be identified clearly. The results of patients study were shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3. Visually, the spatial resolution of MP-SPECT was better than LEHR-SPECT (Figure 2) and comparable to CZE SPECT (Figure 2). Conclusions The proposed MP-SPECT system has higher sensitivity and better spatial resolution than conventional LEHR-SPECT. The myocardial perfusion scans can be carried out without rotation and within 5 min. The heart phantom study show good defect identification and the patients study show that the image quality of MP-SPECT is better than LEHR-SPECT and comparable to commercial dedicated cardiac CZT SPECT.
Development Of Stationary Dedicated Cardiac Spect With Multi-Pinhole Collimators On A Clinical Scanner

Hui Liu,Jing Wu,Si Chen,Shi Wang,Yaqiang Liu,Tianyu Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/NSSMIC.2015.7582154

2015-01-01

Abstract:The existing SPECT system for nuclear cardiac imaging suffered from low sensitivity or high cost. In this study we implemented a novel design of the stationary dedicated cardiac SPECT combined with multi-pinhole collimators based on the clinical dual-head scanner with low cost. Previous simulation study has demonstrated the feasibility of the design.Accurate geometry calibration was implemented for image reconstruction. The projection of a 2-mm-diameter sphere source, which was mounted on patient bed and moved through three certain gridding scanning orbits, was acquired for calibration. The geometrical parameters were estimated by fitting the experimental projection centroids to the geometrical model. The reconstruction adopted MLEM algorithm with GPU parallelization based on CUDA. Considering the impact of large pinhole size on image reconstruction, two analytical pinhole models (sampling pinhole model and dual-section Gaussian model) were proposed to derive the system matrix on the fly during reconstruction. The sphere source projection of one view was reconstructed with the two analytical pinhole models and delta model. The reconstruction results of different views' projection were compared. Furthermore, the myocardium phantom study in comparison with parallel-hole SPECT has been performed to evaluate the system.With geometrical calibration, the reasonable reconstruction images were achieved with 10.6 x 12.9 x 9.6 mm(3) spatial resolution (FWHM). Analytical pinhole models improved the spatial resolution to 6.8 x 8.0 x 7.2 mm(3) and suppressed the deformation while dual-section Gaussian model were slightly better than sampling pinhole model. There was no significant difference between the reconstruction images with one view's and three views' projection, which indicated the stationary imaging property of the SPECT system. Myocardium phantom study demonstrated the superior performance and better defect identification of our proposed SPECT than parallel-hole SPECT.In conclusion, our initial results showed the reasonable images could be achieved on the proposed stationary multi-pinhole dedicated cardiac SPECT. In the future work, more phantom and in vivo experiments would be implemented to evaluate the dedicated cardiac SPECT system.
The clinical utilities of multi-pinhole single photon emission computed tomography

Ilker Ozsahin,Ling Chen,Arda Könik,Michael A King,Freek J Beekman,Greta S P Mok

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21037/qims-19-1036

Abstract:Single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) is an important imaging modality for various applications in nuclear medicine. The use of multi-pinhole (MPH) collimators can provide superior resolution-sensitivity trade-off when imaging small field-of-view compared to conventional parallel-hole and fan-beam collimators. Besides the very successful application in small animal imaging, there has been a resurgence of the use of MPH collimators for clinical cardiac and brain studies, as well as other small field-of-view applications. This article reviews the basic principles of MPH collimators and introduces currently available and proposed clinical MPH SPECT systems.
Feasibility Studies of a High Sensitivity, Stationary Dedicated Cardiac SPECT with Multi-Pinhole Collimators on a Clinical Dual-Head Scanner

Hui Liu,Shi Wang,Tianyu Ma,Jing Wu,Si Chen,Qingyang Wei,Tiantian Dai,Yaqiang Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/nssmic.2014.7430982

2014-01-01

Abstract:In this study we proposed a novel design of the stationary multi-pinhole dedicated cardiac SPECT based on clinical dual-head scanner with high sensitivity and low cost for nuclear medicine myocardial perfusion imaging. The efficacy of proposed collimator design was confirmed by analytically calculating the sensitivity map of field of view (FOV) and the average resolution map weighted by each pinhole's sensitivity. We measured the spatial resolution and sensitivity of the proposed SPECT and low energy high resolution (LEHR) parallel-hole SPECT at central point with the same distance from the collimator with Monte Carlo simulation. A multi-pinhole MLEM reconstruction algorithm was developed with detector response and analytical pinhole projection model. The analytical projection of point source with delta model and pinhole projection model was compared with simulated projection by Gate. We simulated and reconstructed projections of two point with different location with no rotation, one step rotation and two step rotation and one uniform ellipsoid phantom, which covered the heart region. Analytically, the sensitivity was increased to 0.04% and average resolution was about 10 mm inside most of heart regions. The reconstruction spatial resolution of central point was 38% poorer than LEHR SPECT, while the sensitivity was increased by 10-fold, which was consistent with the analytical results. The comparison between the several pinholes' projection calculated with delta model, pinhole analytical model and simulation showed the pinhole analytical model agreed with the simulation in shape, especially when in oblique incidence. The reconstruction results of point source without rotation showed slight deformation on certain point source location. In contrast, with rotation, the deformation was suppressed and resolution was similar. However there was no significant difference in one step and two step rotation. The ellipsoid phantom reconstruction showed the imaging quality of the proposed SPECT although with the expected artifact outside FOV. In conclusion, our initial results demonstrated the feasibility of high sensitivity imaging with proposed stationary multi-pinhole dedicated cardiac SPECT.
Design and evaluation of two multi-pinhole collimators for brain SPECT

Ling Chen,Benjamin M W Tsui,Greta S P Mok

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12149-017-1195-y

Abstract:Objective: SPECT is a powerful tool for diagnosing or staging brain diseases such as Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD) but is limited by its inferior resolution and sensitivity. At the same time, pinhole SPECT provides superior resolution and detection efficiency trade-off as compared to the conventional parallel-hole collimator for imaging small field-of-view (FOV), which fits for the case of brain imaging. In this study, we propose to develop and evaluate two multi-pinhole (MPH) collimator designs to improve the imaging of cerebral blood flow and striatum. Methods: We set the target resolutions to be 12 and 8 mm, respectively, and the FOV at 200 mm which is large enough to cover the whole brain. The constraints for system optimization include maximum and minimum detector-to-center-of-FOV (CFOV) distances of 344 and 294 mm, respectively, and minimal radius-of-rotation (ROR) of 135 mm to accommodate patients' shoulder. According to the targeted FOV, resolutions, and constraints, we determined the pinhole number, ROR, focal length, aperture acceptance angle, and aperture diameter which maximized the system sensitivity. We then assessed the imaging performance of the proposed MPH and standard low-energy high-resolution (LEHR) collimators using analytical simulations of a digital NCAT brain phantom with 99mTc-HMPAO/99mTc-TRODAT-1 distributions; Monte Carlo simulations of a hot-rod phantom; and a Defrise phantom using GATE v6.1. Projections were generated over 360° and reconstructed using the 3D MPH/LEHR OS-EM methods with up to 720 updates. The normalized mean square error (NMSE) was calculated over the cerebral and striatal regions extracted from the reconstructed images for 99mTc-HMPAO and 99mTc-TRODAT-1 simulations, respectively, and average normalized standard deviation (NSD) based on 20 noise realizations was assessed on selected uniform 3D regions as the noise index. Visual assessment and image profiles were applied to the results of Monte Carlo simulations. Results: The optimized design parameters of the MPH collimators were 9 pinholes with 4.7 and 2.8 mm pinhole diameter, 73° acceptance angle, 127 mm focal length, 167 mm ROR for 12 mm and 8 mm target resolution, respectively. According to the optimization results, the detection efficiencies of the proposed collimators were 270 and 40% more as compared to LEHR. The Monte Carlo simulations showed that 7.9 and 6.4 mm rods can be discriminated for the MPH collimators with target resolutions of 12 and 8 mm, respectively. The eight 12 mm-thick discs of the Defrise phantom can also be resolved clearly in the axial plane as demonstrated by the image profiles generated with the MPH collimators. Conclusion: The two collimator designs provide superior image quality as compared to the conventional LEHR, and shows potential to improve current brain SPECT imaging based on a conventional SPECT scanner.
Primary, scatter, and penetration characterizations of parallel-hole and pinhole collimators for I-123 SPECT

Arda Könik,Benjamin Auer,Jan De Beenhouwer,Kesava Kalluri,Navid Zeraatkar,Lars R Furenlid,Michael A King

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6560/ab58fe

IF: 3.5

2019-12-13

Physics in Medicine and Biology

Abstract:Multi-pinhole (MPH) collimators are known to provide better trade-off between sensitivity and resolution for preclinical, as well as for smaller regions in clinical SPECT imaging compared to conventional collimators. In addition to this geometric advantage, MPH plates typically offer better stopping power for penetration than the conventional collimators, which is especially relevant for I-123 imaging. The I-123 emits a series of high-energy (>300 keV, ~2.5% abundance) gamma photons in addition to the primary emission (159 keV, 83% abundance). Despite their low abundance, high-energy photons penetrate through a low-energy parallel-hole (LEHR) collimator much more readily than the 159 keV photons, resulting in large downscatter in the photopeak window. In this work, we investigate the primary, scatter, and penetration characteristics of a single pinhole collimator that is commonly used for I-123 thyroid imaging and our two MPH collimators designed for I-123 DaTscan imaging for Parkinson's Disease, in comparison to three different parallel-hole collimators through a series of experiments and Monte Carlo simulations. The simulations of a point source and a digital human phantom with DaTscan activity distribution showed that our MPH collimators provide superior count performance in terms of high primary counts, low penetration, and low scatter counts compared to the parallel-hole and single pinhole collimators. For example, total scatter, multiple scatter, and collimator penetration events for the LEHR were 2.5, 7.6 and 14 times more than that of MPH within the 15% photopeak window. The total scatter fraction for LEHR was 56% where the largest contribution came from the high-energy scatter from the back compartments (31%). For the same energy window, the total scatter for MPH was 21% with only 1% scatter from the back compartments. We therefore anticipate that using MPH collimators, higher quality reconstructions can be obtained in a substantially shorter acquisition time for I-123 DaTscan and thyroid imaging.

engineering, biomedical,radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
Dedicated Cardiac Spect Imaging with Multi-Pinhole Collimators on A Clinical Scanner

Hui Liu,Tianyu Ma,Jing Wu,Si Chen,Shi Wang,Zhaoxia Wu,Yan Xia,Yaqiang Liu

2016-01-01

Abstract:1951 Objectives Cardiac imaging with parallel-hole SPECT has suffered from low resolution and sensitivity. This work aimed to develop dedicated cardiac imaging functionality on a clinical scanner with high resolution and sensitivity. Methods Our dedicated cardiac SPECT imaging was based on a clinical dual-head SPECT scanner. Two NaI(Tl) SPECT detector heads were placed in 90 degree setup. Conventional parallel-hole collimators were replaced with well-designed multi-pinhole collimators. All the pinholes focused on the heart region without projection overlap. Collimator parameters were optimized with an exhaustive searching method to maximize sensitivity at fixed resolution. The pinhole numbers were 16 and 20 respectively for top detector and side detector heads. The optimized pinhole diameter was 4.1 mm and 3.4 mm respectively. SPECT projection data were acquired in stationary imaging mode. Accurate geometry calibration was performed by scanning a point source at 108 positions with known relative distance. Maximum likelihood expectation maximization (MLEM) iterative algorithm with a pre-stored system matrix was developed for SPECT image reconstruction. The image voxel size was 4.0 x 4.0 x 4.0 mm3. To improve image quality, the system matrix was calculated using a finer voxel grid (0.5 x 0.5 x 0.5 mm3 step). Pinhole geometric model was calculated through ray-tracing. Three experiments were conducted to evaluate imaging performance. 1) A 4.6 mCi 99mTc point source was scanned across the field of view (FOV) to calculate average sensitivity. 2) Two point sources at 1 cm distance was imaged to evaluate system spatial resolution. 3) A heart phantom with myocardium defect (2 cm in length), injected by 10 mCi 99mTc, was scanned for 5 s, 15 s and 5 min and were reconstructed with 200 iterations. For comparison, the same phantom was also scanned for 30 min by mounting low-energy high-resolution (LEHR) parallel-hole collimator on SPECT heads. Sixty projections were acquired and data were reconstructed with ordered subset expectation maximization (OSEM) iterative algorithm using 6 subsets and 4 iterations. Results The average sensitivity across the ~14 cm FOV was 0.03%, higher than dual-head LEHR SPECT (typically 0.015%). Two point sources with 1 cm distance were distinguishable in reconstructed image. Full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the point source was 6.4 x 7.5 x 7.0 mm3, which also showed the spatial resolution was much better than LEHR SPECT system (~8 mm). The total counts of 5 s, 15 s and 5 min scan were about 3e5, 1e6 and 2e7 respectively. Reasonable myocardium phantom images without prominent artifact could be acquired with 5 min scan. Compared with the LEHR SPECT image, dedicated cardiac SPECT showed superior spatial resolution and defect identification capability. In low count studies, the 15 s scan and 5 s scan images showed increased noise and reduced boundary visualization, but were still better than LEHR SPECT image in terms of defect identification. Conclusions Our dedicated cardiac SPECT imaging method was demonstrated to be feasible for cardiac imaging with high resolution and sensitivity compared with conventional parallel-hole SPECT. We will evaluate the system performance with anthropomorphic phantom and patient studies in future. Research Support: This study was supported by China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2015M581113).
Comparing different geometries and reconstruction algorithms for multiple pinhole cardiac SPECT using NCAT

Joyoni Dey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/nssmic.2011.6153770

2011-10-01

Abstract:Cardiac SPECT is primarily used for myocardial perfusion imaging for an estimated 9–10 million patients in the US (and approximately double the number worldwide). However SPECT in general suffers from low sensitivity because of the necessity for collimation. Recently, new designs have emerged with 5–8 times the sensitivity of the standard gamma cameras currently used in the clinic for estimating myocardial perfusion. Examples are DSPECT and GE Discovery systems. Pin-hole collimation is used in the new Discovery series from GE. The advantage of this particular pin-hole design is that there are no moving parts, thus reducing manufacturing and servicing costs. Funk et al used a multi-pinhole system attached to a NaI crystal detector for SPECT Cardiac application. This author had proposed curved detector fitted to each pin- hole, to obtain improved performance $(\sim 2.25$ times sensitivity or 30% better resolution) over that of a flat-detector system for SPECT gamma-cameras. In this work the author implemented voxel-based and detector-based reconstruction algorithms for a multi-pinhole system with flat or curved detectors. Three different geometric configurations with 32, 27, and 21 pinholes were tested and different algorithms compared. The system with 21 pinholes offered similar image quality as the 32 or 27 and was preferred for the reduced number of pinholes. Quantitative analyis was done with the NCAT and a cubic block. The voxel-based reconstruction was preferred from convergence, image quality and speed.
A Multi-Function Compact Small-Animal Imaging System Incorporating Multipinhole Standard and Helical SPECT and Parallel-Hole SPECT

Jianguo Qian,Eric L. Bradley,Stan Majewski,Vladimir Popov,Margaret S. Saha,Mark F. Smith,Andrew G. Weisenberger,Robert E. Welsh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/nssmic.2006.354403

2006-01-01

Abstract:A small-animal imaging system suitable for SPECT imaging and multipinhole standard/helical SPECT has been designed and constructed. Copper-beryllium parallel-hole collimators suitable for imaging the ~35 keV photons from the decay of125I have been built and installed to achieve better spatial resolution and to reduce imaging time on our dual-detector array. To further address the limitations in the resolution of parallel-hole SPECT and the sensitivity and limited field of view of single-pinhole SPECT, we have incorporated multipinhole circular/helical SPECT in addition to expanding parallel-hole SPECT capabilities. The pinhole SPECT system is based on a 110 mm circular detector equipped with pixellated NaI(Tl) scintillator (1×1×5mm3/pixel). The helical trajectory is accomplished by two stepping motors controlling the rotation of the detector-support gantry and displacement of the animal bed along the axis of rotation of the gantry. Results obtained in SPECT studies of various phantoms show an enlarged field of view, enhanced resolution and improved sensitivity over our earlier results. In particular, improved reconstructed resolution is obtained with the helical pinhole SPECT. Pinhole collimators with one, three and five 1 mm diameter pinholes have been used in these tests. Spatial resolution of 1.26 mm, 1.43 mm and 1.55 mm have been obtained respectively with those collimators.
Spectral Multiplexing Multi-Pinhole Collimator Design forHigh Sensitivity Small Animal SPECT

Wenying Wang,Tao Feng

2021-01-01

Journal of Nuclear Medicine

Abstract:1140 Objectives: Multi-pinhole SPECT is widely used for small animals thanks to its ability to track the real-time distribution of radionuclides in high spatial resolution. A stationary system is usually desirable due to its dynamic imaging capability. However, in a stationary system, the limited number of pinholes may result in artifacts due to inadequate angular sampling. We seek to improve the tradeoff between sensitivity and spatial resolution and angular sampling specific to multi-energy radionuclides, such as Indium-111, by introducing a spectral multiplexing multi-pinhole collimator design.\n Methods: We proposed a novel spectral multiplexing multi-pinhole collimator that consisted of two sets of pinholes. Each set of pinholes have no overlap between the projections of the designed field of view (FOV). The first set of pinholes consists of 7 rows and the second set of pinholes has 6 rows. Each row includes 14 pinholes distributed equi-angularly. The second set of pinholes interleaves between the first set of pinholes and acquires different angular sampling patterns. The second set of pinholes are covered with a certain thickness of tungsten that filters the emitted gamma-photons of different energy at a different ratio. The energy-discriminating measurements can be decomposed into projections of individual pinhole set without multiplexing effect. The spectral sensitivities (including the energy-dependent spectral sensitivities of isotope abundance and 1 cm CsI scintillator detection efficiency) are implemented in the system matrix. Projection data of a digital phantom that consisted of 6 groups of rods of different sizes were simulated. Poisson noise was added presuming 30MBq total radioactivity of Indium-111 with 300 seconds acquisition time. The noisy projection data were reconstructed into 150*150*46 voxels with 0.2 mm cubic voxel size using 160 iterations of the maximum likelihood expectation maximization (MLEM) algorithm. Four different tungsten filter thickness ([0.1, 0.2, 0.35, 0.5] mm) were investigated and compared with the reconstructions of single-set multi-pinhole collimator through quantitative analysis of contrast and noise in the reconstructed volumes.\n Results: The reconstructed images with the proposed spectral multiplexing collimator shows superior contrast recovery, lower noise, and lower aliasing artifacts compared with the single-set design results. Among all investigated filter thickness, the 0.1 mm tungsten filter shows the best performance. At the same contrast level at all resolutions, the spectral multiplexing collimator achieves a 40% noise reduction compared with the single-set design results. The 300 seconds scan using a spectral multiplexing collimator with 0.1 mm tungsten filter can achieve higher or equivalent CNR than a 500 seconds scan using a single-set collimator. This allows for 40% time-saving in acquisition protocol design.\n Conclusions: The proposed spectral multiplexing multi-pinhole collimator can achieve higher contrast to noise ratio or the same contrast to noise ratio with shorter acquisition time. The improved angular sampling is beneficial to improve spatial resolution and reduce aliasing artifacts.
Comparison of a Multi-pinhole Stationary SPECT System and a Parallel-hole High Speed Rotational SPECT system

Yohei Fujishiro,Kazumi Murata,Nobutoku Motomura,Koichi Ogawa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/nss/mic42101.2019.9059796

2019-10-01

Abstract:A multi-detector SPECT system with multi-pinhole collimators has been studied to reconstruct an object with a static data acquisition mode. Because a pinhole collimator can acquire photons that enter a detector at many different angles, and if we attach a multi-pinhole collimator to a gamma camera system that has a multi-detector, we can reconstruct the distribution of activities in an organ without any movement of the detectors. However, one of the issues of this data acquisition mode is its limited angles. The size of an effective area of the gamma camera is limited and many pinholes are required to reconstruct an artifact free image. The number of pinholes also affects the data acquisition efficiency and the spatial resolution of a reconstructed image. On the other hand, a high speed data acquisition with a parallel-hole collimator attached to a multi-detector SPECT system may reconstruct a reasonable quality image with a short time data acquisition. In this case, the number of detected photons is very small, but we can use many projection data acquired with equiangular directions. In this paper, we evaluated the quality of images reconstructed with the data measured with a stationary data acquisition with a multi-pinhole collimator and those measured with a high speed data acquisition with a parallel-hole collimator attached to a triple head gamma camera system. The collimators used in this study were a multi-pinhole collimator composed of 11 pinholes with a diameter of 2 or 3 mm, and a parallel-hole collimator with a hole diameter of 2 mm and thickness 4 cm. Data acquisition times were 3 and 4 min. We corrected the absorption of gamma rays with reference to the X-ray CT images, the scattering of gamma rays with the TEW method, and the statistical noise with the appropriate Butterworth filter. The quality of images acquired with the parallel-hole collimator was better than with the pinhole data acquisition despite the very short data acquisition time.
Advances in pinhole and multi-pinhole collimators for single photon emission computed tomography imaging

Jalil Pirayesh Islamian,AhmadReza Azazrm,Babak Mahmoudian,Esmail Gharapapagh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4103/1450-1147.150505

Abstract:The collimator in single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), is an important part of the imaging chain. One of the most important collimators that used in research, preclinical study, small animal, and organ imaging is the pinhole collimator. Pinhole collimator can improve the tradeoff between sensitivity and resolution in comparison with conventional parallel-hole collimator and facilities diagnosis. However, a major problem with pinhole collimator is a small field of view (FOV). Multi-pinhole collimator has been investigated in order to increase the sensitivity and FOV with a preserved spatial resolution. The geometry of pinhole and multi-pinhole collimators is a critical factor in the image quality and plays a key role in SPECT imaging. The issue of the material and geometry for pinhole and multi-pinhole collimators have been a controversial and much disputed subject within the field of SPECT imaging. On the other hand, recent developments in collimator optimization have heightened the need for appropriate reconstruction algorithms for pinhole SPECT imaging. Therefore, iterative reconstruction algorithms were introduced to minimize the undesirable effect on image quality. Current researches have focused on geometry and configuration of pinhole and multi-pinhole collimation rather than reconstruction algorithm. The lofthole and multi-lofthole collimator are samples of novel designs. The purpose of this paper is to provide a review on recent researches in the pinhole and multi-pinhole collimators for SPECT imaging.
Efficient Monte-Carlo based system modelling for image reconstruction in preclinical pinhole SPECT

Minh Phuong Nguyen,Marlies C Goorden,Ruud M Ramakers,Freek J Beekman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6560/ac0682

IF: 3.5

2021-06-16

Physics in Medicine and Biology

Abstract:Abstract The use of multi-pinhole collimation has enabled ultra-high-resolution imaging of SPECT and PET tracers in small animals. Key for obtaining high-quality images is the use of statistical iterative image reconstruction with accurate energy-dependent photon transport modelling through collimator and detector. This can be incorporated in a system matrix that contains the probabilities that a photon emitted from a certain voxel is detected at a specific detector pixel. Here we introduce a fast Monte-Carlo based (FMC-based) matrix generation method for pinhole imaging that is easy to apply to various radionuclides. The method is based on accelerated point source simulations combined with model-based interpolation to straightforwardly change or combine photon energies of the radionuclide of interest. The proposed method was evaluated for a VECTor PET-SPECT system with (i) a HE-UHR-M collimator and (ii) an EXIRAD-3D 3D autoradiography collimator. Both experimental scans with 99m Tc, 111 In, and 123 I, and simulated scans with 67 Ga and 90 Y were performed for evaluation. FMC was compared with two currently used approaches, one based on a set of point source measurements with 99m Tc (dubbed traditional method), and the other based on an energy-dependent ray-tracing simulation (ray-tracing method). The reconstruction results show better image quality when using FMC-based matrices than when applying the traditional or ray-tracing matrices in various cases. FMC-based matrices generalise better than the traditional matrices when imaging radionuclides with energies deviating too much from the energy used in the calibration and are computationally more efficient for very-high-resolution imaging than the ray-tracing matrices. In addition, FMC has the advantage of easily combining energies in a single matrix which is relevant when imaging radionuclides with multiple photopeak energies (e.g. 67 Ga and 111 In) or with a continuous energy spectrum (e.g. 90 Y). To conclude, FMC is an efficient, accurate, and versatile tool for creating system matrices for ultra-high-resolution pinhole SPECT.

engineering, biomedical,radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
High-sensitivity cardiac SPECT system design with collimator-less interspaced mosaic-patterned scintillators

Rui Wang,Debin Zhang,Yifan Hu,Zhenlei Lyu,Tianyu Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2023.1145351

IF: 3.9

2023-06-28

Frontiers in Medicine

Abstract:Purpose Single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) is an important tool for myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI). Mechanical collimators cause the resolution-sensitivity trade-off in the existing cardiac SPECT systems, which hinders fast cardiac scan capability. In this work, we propose a novel collimator-less cardiac SPECT system with interspaced mosaic-patterned scintillators, aiming to significantly improve sensitivity and reduce scan time without trading-off image resolution. Methods We propose to assemble a collimator-less cardiac SPECT with 7 mosaic-patterned detector modules forming a half-ring geometry. The detector module consists of 10 blocks, each of which is assembled with 768 sparsely distributed scintillators with a size of 1.68 mm × 1.68 mm × 20 mm, forming a mosaic pattern in the trans-axial direction. Each scintillator bar contains 5 GAGG(Ce) scintillators and 5 optical-guide elements, forming a mosaic pattern in the axial direction. In the Monte Carlo simulations, the in-plane resolution and axial resolution are evaluated using a hot-rod phantom and 5 disk phantoms, respectively. We simulate a cardiac phantom that is placed in a water-filled cylinder and evaluate the image performance with different data acquisition time. We perform image reconstruction with the expectation–maximization algorithm using system matrices derived from the simulation of a uniform cylindrical source filling the field-of-view (FOV). Besides, a 2-D prototype system is designed to demonstrate the feasibility of the collimator-less imaging concept. Results In the simulation system, the sensitivity is 16.31% ± 8.85% in a 180 mm (Φ) × 100 mm (L) FOV. The 6-mm rods in the hot rod phantom and the 5-mm disks in the disk phantom are clearly separable. Satisfactory MPI image quality is achieved in the cardiac phantom study with an acquisition time of 30 s. In prototype experiments, the point sources with an 8 mm center-to-center distance are clearly separable at different positions across the FOV. Conclusion The study reveals a promising approach to high-sensitivity SPECT imaging without a heavy-metal collimator. In cardiac imaging, this approach opens the way to a very fast cardiac scan with good resolution. Further works are ongoing to build a practical 3-D imaging system based on the existing design.

medicine, general & internal
Multi-pinhole collimator design in different numbers of projections for brain SPECT

Wenbo Huang,Greta S P Mok

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2023.1211726

2023-09-28

Abstract:Purpose: High resolution and sensitivity brain SPECT is promising for the accurate diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD). Multi-pinhole (MPH) collimators with a good performance in imaging small field-of-view (FOV) could be better used for brain SPECT. In this study, we aim to evaluate the impact of varying the number of pinholes and the number of projections on the performance of MPH brain SPECT. Methods: The system design was based on a commercial clinical dual-head SPECT/CT scanner, with target spatial resolutions of 12 mm and 8 mm for AD and PD SPECT, respectively. In total, 1-25 pinholes were modeled for 64, 32, 16, 8, 4, and 2 projections. The 3D NURBS-based HUman Brain (NHUB) phantom was used in the analytical simulation to model 99mTc-HMPAO and 99mTc-TRODAT distributions. The 2D Derenzo hot-rod phantom and star phantom were used in Monte Carlo simulations to evaluate the spatial resolution and angular sampling performance of MPH. The influence of different detector positions was also evaluated for 2, 4, and 6 angular views. The projections were reconstructed using the 3D MPH ML-EM method. Normalized mean square error, coefficient of variation, and image profiles were evaluated. Results: Along with the decrease in the number of projections, more pinholes are required to achieve the optimum performance. For 32 projections, 9- and 7-pinhole collimators provide the best normalized mean square error (NMSE) to the coefficient of variation (COV) trade-off for 99mTc-HMPAO and 99mTc-TRODAT, respectively. Detector positions substantially affect the image quality for MPH SPECT for 2 and 4 angular views. The smallest rod size for the Derenzo hot-rod phantom, which could be resolved, is 7.9 mm for the MPH general purpose collimator (MPGP) with more than 16 projections and 6.4 mm for MPH high-resolution collimator (MPHR) with more than 8 projections. Conclusion: The number of pinholes affects the performance of the MPH collimator, especially when the projection views become fewer. More pinholes are required for fewer projections to provide better angular sampling in MPH for complex activity distributions. Detector positions affect the image quality of MPH SPECT for 2 and 4 angular views, where L-mode acquisition is slightly superior to H-mode. MPH collimators exhibited improved spatial resolution and angular sampling compared with both LEHR and single pinhole collimators.
A small-animal imaging system capable of multipinhole circular/helical SPECT and parallel-hole SPECT

Jianguo Qian,Eric L Bradley,Stan Majewski,Vladimir Popov,Margaret S Saha,Mark F Smith,Andrew G Weisenberger,Robert E Welsh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2008.05.061

2008-08-21

Abstract:We have designed and built a small animal single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) imaging system equipped with parallel-hole and multipinhole collimators and capable of circular or helical SPECT. Copper-beryllium parallel-hole collimators suitable for imaging the ~35 keV photons from the decay of (125)I have been built and installed to achieve useful spatial resolution over a range of object-detector distances and to reduce imaging time on our dual-detector array. To address the resolution limitations in the parallel-hole SPECT and the sensitivity and limited field of view of single-pinhole SPECT, we have incorporated multipinhole circular and helical SPECT in addition to expanding the parallel-hole SPECT capabilities. The pinhole SPECT system is based on a 110 mm diameter circular detector equipped with a pixellated NaI(Tl) scintillator array (1x1x5 mm(3)/pixel). The helical trajectory is accomplished by two stepping motors controlling the rotation of the detector-support gantry and displacement of the animal bed along the axis of rotation of the gantry. Results obtained in SPECT studies of various phantoms show an enlarged field of view, very good resolution and improved sensitivity using multipinhole circular or helical SPECT. Collimators with one, three and five 1 mm diameter pinholes have been implemented and compared in these tests. Our objective is to develop a system on which one may readily select a suitable mode of either parallel-hole SPECT or pinhole circular or helical SPECT for a variety of small animal imaging applications.

Performance evaluation of a novel multi-pinhole collimator on triple-NaI-detector SPECT/CT for dedicated myocardial imaging

Performance Evaluation of a Novel Multi-Pinhole SPECT System

Design and evaluation of an adaptive multipinhole collimator for high-performance clinical and preclinical imaging

A Novel Technology of Multi-pinhole SPECT for Human Myocardial Perfusion Imaging

Performance Evaluation of Stationary Dedicated Cardiac SPECT with Multi-Pinhole Collimators: Comparison with Conventional SPECT and CZT SPECT

Development Of Stationary Dedicated Cardiac Spect With Multi-Pinhole Collimators On A Clinical Scanner

The clinical utilities of multi-pinhole single photon emission computed tomography

Feasibility Studies of a High Sensitivity, Stationary Dedicated Cardiac SPECT with Multi-Pinhole Collimators on a Clinical Dual-Head Scanner

Design and evaluation of two multi-pinhole collimators for brain SPECT

Primary, scatter, and penetration characterizations of parallel-hole and pinhole collimators for I-123 SPECT

Dedicated Cardiac Spect Imaging with Multi-Pinhole Collimators on A Clinical Scanner

Comparing different geometries and reconstruction algorithms for multiple pinhole cardiac SPECT using NCAT

A Multi-Function Compact Small-Animal Imaging System Incorporating Multipinhole Standard and Helical SPECT and Parallel-Hole SPECT

Spectral Multiplexing Multi-Pinhole Collimator Design forHigh Sensitivity Small Animal SPECT

Comparison of a Multi-pinhole Stationary SPECT System and a Parallel-hole High Speed Rotational SPECT system

Advances in pinhole and multi-pinhole collimators for single photon emission computed tomography imaging

Efficient Monte-Carlo based system modelling for image reconstruction in preclinical pinhole SPECT

High-sensitivity cardiac SPECT system design with collimator-less interspaced mosaic-patterned scintillators

Multi-pinhole collimator design in different numbers of projections for brain SPECT

A small-animal imaging system capable of multipinhole circular/helical SPECT and parallel-hole SPECT