Extracting secondary data from citizen science images reveals host flower preferences of the Mexican grass‐carrying wasp Isodontia mexicana in its native and introduced ranges

Nadja Pernat,Daniyar Memedemin,Tom August,Cristina Preda,Lien Reyserhove,Jens Schirmel,Quentin Groom
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.11537
IF: 3.167
2024-06-15
Ecology and Evolution
Abstract:This study uses citizen‐scientist photographic records to examine pollinator‐plant interactions of the wasp Isodontia mexicana in its native and introduced range. We use a data sharing method by identifying the plants on iNaturalist images of the wasp using the Pl@ntNet API, a plant species identification application. We validated this method by simultaneously identifying the plants by experts and summarizing other interactions seen in the photographs to support the added value of the image data contributed by the public for ecological research. We investigated the plant‐pollinator interactions of the Mexican grass‐carrying wasp Isodontia mexicana—native to North America and introduced in Europe in the 1960s—through the use of secondary data from citizen science observations. We applied a novel data exchange workflow from two global citizen science platforms, iNaturalist and Pl@ntNet. Images from iNaturalist of the wasp were used to query the Pl@ntNet application to identify possible plant species present in the pictures. Simultaneously, botanists manually identified the plants at family, genus and species levels and additionally documented flower color and biotic interactions. The goals were to calibrate Pl@ntNet's accuracy in relation to this workflow, update the list of plant species that I. mexicana visits as well as its flower color preferences in its native and introduced ranges. In addition, we investigated the types and corresponding frequencies of other biotic interactions incidentally captured on the citizen scientists' images. Although the list of known host plants could be expanded, identifying the flora from images that predominantly show an insect proved difficult for both experts and the Pl@ntNet app. The workflow performs with a 75% probability of correct identification of the plant at the species level from a score of 0.8, and with over 90% chance of correct family and genus identification from a score of 0.5. Although the number of images above these scores may be limited due to the flower parts present on the pictures, our approach can help to get an overview into species interactions and generate more specific research questions. It could be used as a triaging method to select images for further investigation. Additionally, the manual analysis of the images has shown that the information they contain offers great potential for learning more about the ecology of an introduced species in its new range.
ecology,evolutionary biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?