Abstract:The attentional template is often described as the mental representation that drives attentional selection and guidance, for instance, in visual search. Recent research suggests that this template is not a veridical representation of the sought-for target, but instead an altered representation that allows more efficient search. The current paper contrasts two such theories. Firstly, the Optimal Tuning account which posits that the attentional template shifts to an exaggerated target value to maximise the signal-to-noise ratio between similar targets and non-targets. Secondly, the Relational account which states that instead of tuning to feature values, attention is directed to the relative value created by the search context, e.g. all redder items or the reddest item. Both theories are empirically supported, but used different paradigms (perceptual decision tasks vs. visual search), and different attentional measures (probe response accuracy vs. gaze capture). The current design incorporates both paradigms and measures. The results reveal that while Optimal Tuning shifts are observed in probe trials they do not drive early attention or eye- movement behaviour in visual search. Instead, early attention follows the Relational Account, selecting all items with the relative target colour (e.g., redder). This suggests that the masked probe trials used in Optimal Tuning do not probe the attentional template that guides attention. In Experiment 3 we find that optimal tuning shifts correspond in magnitude to purely perceptual shifts created by contrast biases in the visual search arrays. This suggests that the shift in probe responses may in fact be a perceptual artefact rather than a strategic adaptation to optimise the signal-to-noise ratio. These results highlight the distinction between early attentional mechanisms and later, target identification mechanisms.Significance statementClassical theories of attention suggest that attention is guided by a feature-specific target template. In recent designs this has been challenged by an apparent non- veridical tuning of the template in situations where the target stimulus is similar to non-targets. The current studies compare two theories that propose different explanations for non-veridical tuning; the Relational and the Optimal Tuning account. We show that the Relational account describes the mechanism that guides early search behaviour, while the Optimal Tuning account describes perceptual decision-making. Optimal Tuning effects may be due to an artefact that has not been described in visual search before (simultaneous contrast).

Categorization templates modulate selective attention.

The time course of category-based attentional template pre-activation depends on the category framework

Category-based Attentional Capture Can Be Influenced by Color- and Shape-Dimensions Independently in the Conjunction Search Task.

Suppression on the basis of template for rejection is reactive: Evidence from human electrophysiology

Understanding the PD and the N2pc: Modeling the Neural Mechanisms Underlying Spatial Attention Shifts

Proactive selective attention across competition contexts

The Role of Attention in Category Representation

Attentional templates for target features versus locations

The allocation of working memory resources determines the efficiency of attentional templates in single- and dual-target search.

Common Neural Mechanisms Control Attention and Working Memory

Proactive selective attention across competition contexts.

Goal-directed attention transforms both working and long-term memory representations in the human parietal cortex

Temporal characteristics of overt attentional behavior during category learning

Category-Based Attention Facilitates Memory Search

Attention enhances category representations across the brain with strengthened residual correlations to ventral temporal cortex

The attentional template in high and low similarity search: Optimal tuning or tuning to relations?

Learning-Induced Changes in Attentional Allocation During Categorization: A Sizable Catalog of Attention Change As Measured by Eye Movements

Dual-format attentional template during preparation in human visual cortex

Testing the contributions of proactive target and distractor templates in visual search performance

Attention Modulates Human Visual Responses to Objects by Tuning Sharpening

The impact of negative attentional set upon target processing in RSVP: an ERP study.