Probabilistic flood hazard mapping considering multiple levee breaches

A. Maranzoni,M. D’Oria,M. Mazzoleni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2021WR030874

IF: 5.4

2022-03-13

Water Resources Research

Abstract:Water Resources Research, Accepted Article.

environmental sciences,water resources,limnology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Probabilistic mapping of life loss due to dam-break flooding

Andrea Maranzoni,Marco D’Oria,Carmine Rizzo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-023-06285-3

IF: 3.158

2023-11-30

Natural Hazards

Abstract:Assessment of flood damage caused by dam failures is typically performed deterministically on the basis of a single preselected scenario, neglecting uncertainties in dam-break parameters, exposure information, and vulnerability model. This paper proposes a probabilistic flood damage model for the estimation of life loss due to dam-break flooding with the aim of overcoming this limitation and performing a more comprehensive and informative evaluation of flood risk. The significant novelty lies in the fact that the model combines uncertainties associated with all three components of risk: hazard, exposure, and vulnerability. Uncertainty in flood hazard is introduced by considering a set of dam-break scenarios, each characterized by different breach widths and reservoir levels. Each scenario is linked to a probability, which is assumed conditional on the dam-break event. Uncertainty in exposure is accounted for using dasymetric maps of the population at risk for two socio-economic states (representing business and non-business hours of a typical week), along with associated likelihood. Vulnerability to flooding is described through a well-established empirical hazard-loss function relating the fatality rate of the population at risk to the flood hazard, the flood severity understanding, and the warning time; a confidence band provides quantitative information about the associated uncertainty. The probabilistic damage model was applied to the case study of the hypothetical collapse of Mignano concrete gravity dam (northern Italy). The main outcome is represented by probabilistic flood damage maps, which show the spatial distribution of selected percentiles of a loss-of-life risk index coupled with the corresponding uncertainty bounds.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,water resources,meteorology & atmospheric sciences
A framework for modelling the probability of flooding under levee breaching

Thomas Wallace,Kaley Crawford‐Flett,Matthew Wilson,Tom Logan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jfr3.12988

2024-04-15

Journal of Flood Risk Management

Abstract:Levees aim to provide protection during floods, however, these structures can breach, causing significant damage. Flood maps that include levee breaching are often limited to deterministic methods. Where probabilistic breaching is done, it often requires computationally expensive Monte Carlo simulations and an understanding of the geotechnical levee properties that are often limited. In this paper, we combine existing fragility curves and empirical breaching equations with a framework for automating levee breaching in catchments with limited geotechnical information. This method can be adapted and applied to existing 2D flood models to determine the probability of inundation, given that a breach occurs. This ultimately allows for greater emergency responses and land use planning to reduce the flood risk faced by our communities. The method was applied to four case study catchments. The results showed that including levee breaching in one catchment led to an average increase in the inundated area by 48.2% and a tripling in the potentially exposed area. However, breaching in some locations reduced the inundation extent by 12%, illustrating the potential for fuse plug levees and floodways as a flood mitigation strategy. This strategy has seen successful usage internationally. Further investigation is recommended to consider whether these mitigation strategies should be enacted.

environmental sciences,water resources
Developing Water Level Maps in the Joint Probability Zone Influenced by Extreme Tide and Rainfall Events

Michael Leonard,Seth Westra,Feifei Zheng,Mark Babister,Ivan Varga

2015-01-01

Abstract:Flood risk in estuarine regions can be difficult to estimate due to the relationship between extreme ocean levels and catchment generated streamflow. One method for estimating flood risk from two extremes is the design variable method, but this method is typically applied at an individual location along the river reach, so that, it is unclear how feasibly the method can be implemented with output from two dimensional hydraulic models. Adapting the design variable method to a spatial setting presents interesting challenges in terms of computational demand, how to incorporate regions outside the main channel and whether or not the method can be applied independently across grid cell locations. To test these issues, a case study is presented for the Nambucca catchment in the Mid North Coast region, NSW. At this location 144 water level maps were used, based on TUFLOW model output, corresponding to combinations of 12 storm tide return-levels and 12 rainfall event return-levels, from 63%AEP to 0.05%AEP. The design variable method was modified to accommodate partially wet grid cells and applied repeatedly and independently to each grid cell location. The two-dimensional design variable method is computationally intensive but yielded good results for this case study, showing considerable potential for wider application.
Efficient joint probability analysis of flood risk

feifei zheng,michael leonard,seth westra

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2166/hydro.2015.052

IF: 3.058

2015-01-01

Journal of Hydroinformatics

Abstract:Flood attributes such as the water level may depend on multiple forcing variables that arise from common meteorological conditions. To correctly estimate flood risk in these situations, it is necessary to account for the joint probability distribution of all the relevant forcing variables. An example of a joint probability approach is the design variable method, which focuses on the extremes of the forcing variables, and approximates the hydraulic response to forcing variables with a water level table. In practice, however, application of the design variable method is limited, even for the bivariate case, partly because of the high computational cost of the hydrologic/hydraulic simulations. We develop methods to minimise the computational cost and assess the appropriate extent and resolution of the water level table in a bivariate context. Flood risk is then evaluated as a bivariate integral, which we implement as an equivalent line integral. The line integral is two orders of magnitude quicker and therefore beneficial to settings that require multiple evaluations of the flood risk (e.g., optimisation studies or uncertainty analyses). The proposed method is illustrated using a coastal case study in which floods are caused by extreme rainfall and storm tide. An open-source R package has been developed to facilitate the uptake of joint probability methods among researchers and practitioners.
Probabilistic hydro-geomorphological hazard assessment based on UAV-derived high-resolution topographic data: The case of Basento river (Southern Italy)

Marco La Salandra,Rodolfo Roseto,Daniela Mele,Pierfrancesco Dellino,Domenico Capolongo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.156736

2022-10-10

Abstract:The combined use of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) and Structure from Motion (SfM) photogrammetry allows the collection and processing of high-resolution data on demand, which is key for the constant and detailed monitoring of the fluvial environment. In addition, through the ever-increasing development of new techniques of mapping and data processing (i.e., UAVs swarm, BVLOS flight missions, high-performance photogrammetry workflow), it is now possible to detect large areas at high-resolution, providing support for spatiotemporal insights into hydro-geomorphological processes and hazard assessment, in order to ensure an effective management and to prevent catastrophic phenomena (i.e., floods). The main goal of this paper is to use UAV-based high-resolution topographic data to constrain the probabilistic hazard assessment of extended reaches of Basento river (Basilicata, Italy). To demonstrate the influence of geomorphology and riverbed sediment on hazard assessment, a sensitivity analysis was carried out on the resolution of the UAV-derived DEMs; on the riverbed roughness coefficient resulting from photo-sieving analysis and on the morphological change detection over short-time ranges (2019-2021). We found that lower resolution DEMs lead to an increase of flooding probability (in several river cross-sections an increase even higher than 99 % resulted), and that a greater roughness coefficient involves an increase in the probability of flooding (with a maximum increase of about 9 %). Moreover, the multitemporal high-resolution outputs resulting from SfM allowed the identification of morphological changes, in short-times, caused by an anthropic modification of the river bank, which significantly affected the flooding hazard.
Development of Probabilistic Dam Breach Model Using Bayesian Inference

S. J. Peter,A. Siviglia,J. Nagel,S. Marelli,R. M. Boes,D. Vetsch,B. Sudret

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2017wr021176

IF: 5.4

2018-07-01

Water Resources Research

Abstract:Dam breach models are commonly used to predict outflow hydrographs of potentially failing dams and are key ingredients for evaluating flood risk. In this paper a new dam breach modeling framework is introduced that shall improve the reliability of hydrograph predictions of homogeneous earthen embankment dams. Striving for a small number of parameters, the simplified physics‐based model describes the processes of failing embankment dams by breach enlargement, driven by progressive surface erosion. Therein the erosion rate of dam material is modeled by empirical sediment transport formulations. Embedding the model into a Bayesian multilevel framework allows for quantitative analysis of different categories of uncertainties. To this end, data available in literature of observed peak discharge and final breach width of historical dam failures were used to perform model inversion by applying Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation. Prior knowledge is mainly based on noninformative distribution functions. The resulting posterior distribution shows that the main source of uncertainty is a correlated subset of parameters, consisting of the residual error term and the epistemic term quantifying the breach erosion rate. The prediction intervals of peak discharge and final breach width are congruent with values known from literature. To finally predict the outflow hydrograph for real case applications, an alternative residual model was formulated that assumes perfect data and a perfect model. The fully probabilistic fashion of hydrograph prediction has the potential to improve the adequate risk management of downstream flooding. Dam breach hydrographs are predicted within a probabilistic framework A simplified physics‐based dam breach model is developed Bayesian inference analysis is applied to quantify hierarchical uncertainties

environmental sciences,water resources,limnology
Geomorphic risk maps for river migration using probabilistic modeling – a framework

Brayden Noh,Omar Wani,Kieran B. J. Dunne,Michael P. Lamb

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/esurf-12-691-2024

2024-05-09

Earth Surface Dynamics

Abstract:Lateral migration of meandering rivers poses erosional risks to human settlements, roads, and infrastructure in alluvial floodplains. While there is a large body of scientific literature on the dominant mechanisms driving river migration, it is still not possible to accurately predict river meander evolution over multiple years. This is in part because we do not fully understand the relative contribution of each mechanism and because deterministic mathematical models are not equipped to account for stochasticity in the system. Besides, uncertainty due to model structure deficits and unknown parameter values remains. For a more reliable assessment of risks, we therefore need probabilistic forecasts. Here, we present a workflow to generate geomorphic risk maps for river migration using probabilistic modeling. We start with a simple geometric model for river migration, where nominal migration rates increase with local and upstream curvature. We then account for model structure deficits using smooth random functions. Probabilistic forecasts for river channel position over time are generated by Monte Carlo runs using a distribution of model parameter values inferred from satellite data. We provide a recipe for parameter inference within the Bayesian framework. We demonstrate that such risk maps are relatively more informative in avoiding false negatives, which can be both detrimental and costly, in the context of assessing erosional hazards due to river migration. Our results show that with longer prediction time horizons, the spatial uncertainty of erosional hazard within the entire channel belt increases – with more geographical area falling within 25 % < probability < 75 %. However, forecasts also become more confident about erosion for regions immediately in the vicinity of the river, especially on its cut-bank side. Probabilistic modeling thus allows us to quantify our degree of confidence – which is spatially and temporally variable – in river migration forecasts. We also note that to increase the reliability of these risk maps, we need to describe the first-order dynamics in our model to a reasonable degree of accuracy, and simple geometric models do not always possess such accuracy.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,geography, physical
Integration of seasonal frequency domain electromagnetic surveys and geological data for assessing the integrity of earthen levee systems. The case study of the Panaro River (Northern Italy)

N. Bertone,E. Forte,G. Titti,R. Zambrini,P. Macini,A. Mocnik,S. Parodi,F. Pellegrini,M. Possamai,C. Staboli,M. Valente,L. Borgatti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2024.107749

IF: 6.902

2024-10-02

Engineering Geology

Abstract:Floods rank among the most widespread and destructive natural hazards worldwide. The progressive degradation, impairment, and breach of earthen riverine levees can occur in both natural and anthropogenic environments, stemming from various scenarios or sequences of events. These may include hydraulic failure due to overtopping because of inadequate height, and structural failure occurring even prior to overtopping, due to insufficient geotechnical and hydraulic characteristics combined with external and internal erosion.Following the catastrophic flood of December 2020, caused by the collapse of a section of the levee system of the Panaro River (a tributary of the Po River, Northern Italy), local Authorities initiated a comprehensive investigation into the causes of the breach. Numerous factors, including geological, geomorphological, and ecological features, were found to have contributed to the progressive decrease of the levee integrity prior to and during the flood. This prompted a broader multidisciplinary study of the Panaro River levee system.The study expanded its focus to include the collapsed section (rebuilt in 2020), as well as an additional 30 km stretch of both the right and left levees north of Modena, totaling 60 km. Detailed geological and geophysical data were integrated into the analysis, with particular emphasis on evaluating the characteristics and integrity features of the levee system.This analysis was carried out using Frequency Domain Electromagnetic Methods (FDEM) on the top of the levees, previously calibrated using Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT), geological mapping, core logs, and Cone Penetration Tests (CPTs). The FDEM surveys were repeated in different environmental conditions, specifically in the dry 2021 summer season and in the wet 2023 spring season, during heavy rainfalls that caused disastrous floods in several areas of the Emilia-Romagna Region. Out of the 60 km surveyed in the study area, the comparison of the two datasets highlights an interval of about 4 km where the internal portion of the levees is characterized by relatively coarse-grained materials and higher permeability making it more prone to internal erosion phenomena. This paper describes and integrates the results of these investigations, drawing attention to the strengths and limitations of the FDEM method when applied to extensive surveys on earthen riverine levee systems. The proposed methodology contributes as well to maintenance and retrofitting efforts to reduce flood risk in the context of the present climate change scenarios.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,engineering, geological
A tracer‐aided 2D numerical framework to define fluvial and pluvial hazard mapping

Pasquale Perrini,Vito Iacobellis,Andrea Gioia,Luis Cea

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jfr3.13039

2024-10-18

Journal of Flood Risk Management

Abstract:Flood hazard is a dynamic nonstationary phenomenon, which can be categorized based on the origin of the inundation. Inland flood hazard arises primarily from pluvial and fluvial inundations, typically modeled separately with respect to the pertaining spatial domains of the assessment, namely the urban areas and the riverine floodplains. When modeling is based on the catchment‐scale hydrological‐hydrodynamic approach, the inundations such as those resulting from pluvial and fluvial processes are usually not discerned, even though disparities in normative flood risk management exist in different countries. This paper establishes a tracer‐aided criterion to discretize between pluvial and fluvial flooding at a catchment scale, relying on the advection process of a conservative tracer. Applied to a small urban catchment for multiple probabilistic rainfall scenarios, our physically based methodology shows that the incorporation of a transport equation within a shallow water model can be used to define the inundation sources. We highlight the advantages of the proposed approach compared to commonly employed modeling techniques for mapping fluvial inundations, while emphasizing the significance of mapping and regulating pluvial hazards in urban areas. The study shows the potential role of an abstraction of the tracers' transport toward identifying the hazard sources in a catchment‐scale 2D numerical framework.

environmental sciences,water resources
Quantitative flood hazard assessment methods: A review

Andrea Maranzoni,Marco D'Oria,Carmine Rizzo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jfr3.12855

2022-10-21

Journal of Flood Risk Management

Abstract:Flood hazard assessment is a fundamental step in flood risk mapping. Quantitative assessment requires hydrodynamic modelling of the flooding process in order to calculate the spatial distribution of suitable flood hazard indicators representative of flooding intensity and frequency, hence its potential to result in harm. Flood hazard indicators are usually defined by combining relevant flooding parameters, mainly flood depth and flow velocity, but also flooding arrival time, flooding duration, sediment or contamination load, and so forth. A flood hazard classification is commonly introduced to assign a hazard level to areas potentially subject to flooding. This article presents a systematic review of quantitative methods proposed in the scientific literature or prescribed by government authorities to assess the hazard associated with natural or anthropic flooding. Flood hazard classification methods are listed and compared by specifying their underlying approach (heuristic, conceptual, empirical), the exposed element which they were designed for (people, buildings, vehicles, etc.), and their fields of application (river overflow, dam‐break, levee breach, debris flow). Perspectives and future challenges in quantitative flood hazard analysis are also discussed. This review aims to help modellers and practitioners to select the most suitable flood hazard assessment method for the case study of interest.

environmental sciences,water resources
Toward a New Flood Assessment Paradigm: From Exceedance Probabilities to the Expected Maximum Floods and Damages

E. Todini,P. Reggiani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2023wr034477

IF: 5.4

2024-01-10

Water Resources Research

Abstract:To assess flood risks, we seek to estimate the probability distribution of the worst possible single‐event over a contiguous period of N years rather than the cumulative losses expected over a planning horizon. For this we use the probability distribution FN of extreme flood events over a multi‐year period, which is different from using the conventional single‐valued exceedance probability of 1/N years. FN can be used to estimate the hazard and then proceed to the estimation of risk, which we define as the "largest expected damage" over the set period. It also allows for a more coherent determination of design values, which descend from fully acknowledging the aleatoric uncertainty of the underlying natural river flow process. The epistemic uncertainty is removed by marginalizing the aleatoric‐epistemic uncertainty joint distribution over the parameter space. The advantage of the proposed Bayesian approach, which can be summarized in 12 steps, is demonstrated for the 2021 River Ahr flood in Germany, which caused casualties and huge material damage. Adopting the multi‐year maxima extreme value distribution can potentially lead to the reclassification of vulnerability levels for flood‐prone areas and reconsideration of current policy‐making and flood risk communication.

environmental sciences,water resources,limnology
Two-dimensional Levee Breaching Model Considering Flow and Sediment Interaction

WU Wei-ming

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-4874.2010.02.003

2010-01-01

Abstract:A two dimensionnal dam/levee breaching model was developed to simulate overtopping flows, breach development, and the related sediment transport processes. The depth-averaged 2-D flow and non-equilibrium total-load sediment transport equations were solved using an explicit finite volume method on a rectangular grid. The model considered interactions among transient flow, strong sediment transport and rapid bed distortion by including bed change and variable flow density in the continuity and momentum equations of flow. The HLL approximate Riemann solver was used to handle the mixed-regime flows near the breach, and different repose angles for the sediments below and above the water surface were adopted to handle the non-cohesive embankment slope avalanching. The model was checked against the laboratory experiment carried out by HR Wallingford, UK, and the results show that the developed model predicts well the breach dimension, flow hydrograph, and flow characteristics. The sensitivity analysis shows the nonlinear features of the model.
A Probabilistic Modelling System for Assessing Flood Risks

Heiko Apel,Annegret H. Thieken,Bruno Merz,Günter Blöschl

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-005-8603-7

IF: 3.158

2006-05-01

Natural Hazards

Abstract:In order to be economically viable, flood disaster mitigation should be based on a comprehensive assessment of the flood risk. This requires the estimation of the flood hazard (i.e. runoff and associated probability) and the consequences of flooding (i.e. property damage, damage to persons, etc.). Within the “German Research Network Natural Disasters” project, the working group on “Flood Risk Analysis” investigated the complete flood disaster chain from the triggering event down to its various consequences. The working group developed complex, spatially distributed models representing the relevant meteorological, hydrological, hydraulic, geo-technical, and socio-economic processes. In order to assess flood risk these complex deterministic models were complemented by a simple probabilistic model. The latter model consists of modules each representing one process of the flood disaster chain. Each module is a simple parameterisation of the corresponding more complex model. This ensures that the two approaches (simple probabilistic and complex deterministic) are compatible at all steps of the flood disaster chain. The simple stochastic approach allows a large number of simulation runs in a Monte Carlo framework thus providing the basis for a probabilistic risk assessment. Using the proposed model, the flood risk including an estimation of the flood damage was quantified for an example area at the river Rhine. Additionally, the important influence of upstream levee breaches on the flood risk at the lower reaches was assessed. The proposed model concept is useful for the integrated assessment of flood risks in flood prone areas, for cost-benefit assessment and risk-based design of flood protection measures and as a decision support tool for flood management.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,water resources,meteorology & atmospheric sciences
Effect of uncertainties in breach location and breach mechanisms on risk‐related classification of off‐stream reservoirs

Nathalia Silva‐Cancino,Leonardo Alfonso

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jfr3.13044

2024-11-08

Journal of Flood Risk Management

Abstract:Off‐stream reservoirs are artificial water storage structures that increase the flood risk of an area. In some places, related risk reduction plans are based on a risk classification of these structures, which follows local water resource management regulations. These classification methods typically follow deterministic qualitative guidelines that do not account for uncertainties. This study introduces a fourth‐step probabilistic approach that accounts for uncertainties related to simultaneous breach formation and breaking point location of off‐stream reservoirs, and proposes an alternative visualisation for their classification. The methodology is applied to a set of Spanish off‐stream reservoirs that are classified according to the Spanish normative. Results show that different breaking points and breach formations generate diverse classifications that can affect risk reduction plans. Additionally, we demonstrate that the proposed visualisation can be used for various purposes, including the case of the evolution of the categorisation in time, due to land use changes, which could be used by decision‐makers to understand which off‐stream reservoir requires a category update. These findings introduce a novel approach to managing uncertainties, which is crucial for developing resilient flood management strategies and contributes to the innovation discourse in flood risk management.

environmental sciences,water resources
Multi‐Level Monte Carlo Models for Flood Inundation Uncertainty Quantification

G. Aitken,L. Beevers,M. A. Christie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2022WR032599

IF: 5.4

2022-10-19

Water Resources Research

Abstract:Flood events are the most commonly occurring natural disaster, with over 5 million properties at risk in the UK alone. Changes in the global climate are expected to increase the frequency and magnitude of flood events. Flood hazard assessments, using climate projections as input, guide policy decisions and engineering projects to reduce the impact of large return period events. Probabilistic flood modelling is required to take into account uncertainties in climate model projections. However, the dichotomous relationship between probabilistic modelling, computational cost and model resolution limits the applicability of such techniques. This paper examines improvements to traditional Monte Carlo methods using Latin hypercube sampling and Multi‐level Monte Carlo (MLMC) to quantify the uncertainty in flood extent resulting from input hydrograph uncertainty. The results demonstrate that MLMC is a more efficient modelling strategy than current methods (i.e. traditional Monte Carlo) with high resolution outputs produced in less time than previously possible. The novel application of MLMC technique to three Scottish case studies, demonstrating a variety of river characteristics, domain sizes and computational costs, using a high resolution 5m grid resulted in a 99.2% reduction in computational cost compared to traditional Monte Carlo methods and up to 2.3 times speedup over Latin Hypercube Sampling. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

environmental sciences,water resources,limnology
Modeling of levee breach flooding in densely populated urban areas

Dawei Zhang,Danxun Li,Hongwei Fang,Zhicong Chen

2007-01-01

Abstract:A numerical model has been developed, tested, and applied to simulate levee breach flooding in densely populated urban areas. The 2D shallow water equations are spatially diseretized by an unstructured finite volume method. Roe's approximate Riemann solver is used to compute inter-cell fluxes; the characteristic decomposition method is used in dealing with the bed slope source term. The algorithm has a second order accuracy both in space and time, achieved respectively by TVD-Muscl and Hancock methods. The model's accuracy, stability, and reliability are tested with two study cases. The model is then applied to describe possible flooding events due to levee breach in Haerbin city, a metropolitan in north-east China. During the levee breach flooding event, the streets network in the dense urban area becomes the main passage for flood routing. The paper shows that the developed 2D model can be used to predict the hydraulic characteristics of floods in dense urban areas in support of managing flood emergency and planning mitigation measures.
Assessing the effectiveness of "River Morphodynamic Corridors" for flood hazard mapping

Andrea Brenna,Giacomo Poletto,Nicola Surian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geomorph.2024.109460

IF: 4.406

2024-10-25

Geomorphology

Abstract:In dynamic rivers the assessment of flood hazard related to geomorphological dynamics assumes crucial importance. Recently, some geomorphological approaches have been developed to assess channel dynamics in response to floods. In this study we explore the River Morphodynamic Corridors which include the current active channel and areas of the alluvial plain that may be (re)activated by channel dynamics during floods. In order to assess the effectiveness of such corridors for mapping flood hazard, we delineated the morphodynamic corridors along a river network of 74 km in the Cordevole River catchment (Italy) and compared the corridors with the channel changes that were triggered by a high-magnitude event (Vaia Storm) that hit the study area in October 2018. We observed that the morphodynamic corridors are capable to define areas where channel dynamics are most likely to occur and have proven satisfactorily effective in predicting channel widenings triggered by a severe flood. The results show that it is crucial to adopt different procedures for corridor delineation based on channel width, i.e., for small streams (width < 30 m) a more precautionary approach should be adopted that considers the entire alluvial plain as an area potentially affected by channel dynamics. The study highlighted an inherent limitation of the approach, since erosion that can affect valley slopes or fluvial terraces (i.e., widening of the alluvial plain) is not taken into account. This application represents the first validation of the River Morphodynamic Corridors approach through comparison with observed flood channel changes. Through this analysis, it can be inferred that, notwithstanding its relatively simple procedure, the approach allows a robust mapping and delineation of flood hazard due to river channel dynamics. The River Morphodynamic Corridors, when applied jointly with hydraulic model for assessing inundation processes, allow an overall assessment of flood hazard, particularly in dynamic river contexts.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,geography, physical
Effects of Dam Failure Mechanisms on Downstream Flood Propagation

Francesco Federico,Chiara Cesali

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-46351-9_13

2020-01-01

Abstract:The careful mapping of areas that might potentially be flooded following a dam failure is necessary to understand, reduce and manage the relevant risks. These ones, in turn, strongly depend upon both the dam failure mechanisms and the characteristics of the areas potentially subjected to inundation (i.e. topography, presence of infrastructures, …). Specifically, referring to the embankment dam on Sciaguana River (Sicily, Italy), 2D unsteady flow simulations of the possible dam break due to (a) overtopping or (b) piping failure have been carried out by running the HEC RAS code. The effects of an assigned breach formation and progression mechanisms on flood propagation have been parametrically analysed. Inundation mapping results obtained through the proposed dam failure model have been compared with the potentially flooding areas predicted by the local government Authorities. Some breach prediction methods available in technical literature have been furthermore applied; the corresponding results have been discussed and compared with the numerical (HEC RAS) simulations. The proposed analyses may contribute to a better and more reliable delimitation of the flood hazard areas as well as the definition of relevant mitigation countermeasures.
Fluvial and pluvial flood hazard mapping: combining basin and municipal scale assessment

Matej Vojtek,Soheyl Moradi,Davide Luciano De Luca,Andrea Petroselli,Jana Vojteková

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19475705.2024.2432377

2024-12-01

Geomatics Natural Hazards and Risk

Abstract:In this study, we aimed to assess the fluvial and pluvial flood hazard by a combination of basin and municipal scale assessment using an indicator-based approach, hydrologic-hydraulic modeling, and geographic information systems (GIS). The study area is represented by the Gidra River Basin and 12 municipalities. To calculate a composite flood hazard index (CFHI), we used two components: pluvial flood potential index (PFPI) and fluvial flood hazard index (FFHI). Altogether, five physical-geographical indicators and land use/land cover were used to calculate the PFPI. For determining the FFHI, we calculated three hydraulically modeled indicators for Q 100 : flood extent, average flow depth, and average flow velocity in each municipality. The most endangered municipalities in terms of the FFHI are located in the central and upper part of the basin while in case of the PFPI, the highest values were obtained by the municipalities located in the lower and central part of the basin. The highest values of CFHI were recorded in municipalities of Cífer, Budmerice, and Jablonec, which are in central part of the studied basin. Reliability of the calculated PFPI and FFHI was proven by the occurrence of past floods in the studied municipalities during the years 1996–2024.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,meteorology & atmospheric sciences,water resources
Statistical analysis of the uncertainty related to flood hazard appraisal

Vincenza Notaro,Gabriele Freni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4938959

2015-01-01

AIP Conference Proceedings

Abstract:The estimation of flood hazard frequency statistics for an urban catchment is of great interest in practice. It provides the evaluation of potential flood risk and related damage and supports decision making for flood risk management. Flood risk is usually defined as function of the probability, that a system deficiency can cause flooding (hazard), and the expected damage, due to the flooding magnitude (damage), taking into account both the exposure and the vulnerability of the goods at risk. The expected flood damage can be evaluated by an a priori estimation of potential damage caused by flooding or by interpolating real damage data. With regard to flood hazard appraisal several procedures propose to identify some hazard indicator (HI) such as flood depth or the combination of flood depth and velocity and to assess the flood hazard corresponding to the analyzed area comparing the HI variables with user-defined threshold values or curves (penalty curves or matrixes). However, flooding data are usually unavailable or piecemeal allowing for carrying out a reliable flood hazard analysis, therefore hazard analysis is often performed by means of mathematical simulations aimed at evaluating water levels and flow velocities over catchment surface. As results a great part of the uncertainties intrinsic to flood risk appraisal can be related to the hazard evaluation due to the uncertainty inherent to modeling results and to the subjectivity of the user defined hazard thresholds applied to link flood depth to a hazard level. In the present work, a statistical methodology was proposed for evaluating and reducing the uncertainties connected with hazard level estimation. The methodology has been applied to a real urban watershed as case study.

Probabilistic flood hazard mapping considering multiple levee breaches

Probabilistic mapping of life loss due to dam-break flooding

A framework for modelling the probability of flooding under levee breaching

Developing Water Level Maps in the Joint Probability Zone Influenced by Extreme Tide and Rainfall Events

Efficient joint probability analysis of flood risk

Probabilistic hydro-geomorphological hazard assessment based on UAV-derived high-resolution topographic data: The case of Basento river (Southern Italy)

Development of Probabilistic Dam Breach Model Using Bayesian Inference

Geomorphic risk maps for river migration using probabilistic modeling – a framework

Integration of seasonal frequency domain electromagnetic surveys and geological data for assessing the integrity of earthen levee systems. The case study of the Panaro River (Northern Italy)

A tracer‐aided 2D numerical framework to define fluvial and pluvial hazard mapping

Quantitative flood hazard assessment methods: A review

Toward a New Flood Assessment Paradigm: From Exceedance Probabilities to the Expected Maximum Floods and Damages

Two-dimensional Levee Breaching Model Considering Flow and Sediment Interaction

A Probabilistic Modelling System for Assessing Flood Risks

Effect of uncertainties in breach location and breach mechanisms on risk‐related classification of off‐stream reservoirs

Multi‐Level Monte Carlo Models for Flood Inundation Uncertainty Quantification

Modeling of levee breach flooding in densely populated urban areas

Assessing the effectiveness of "River Morphodynamic Corridors" for flood hazard mapping

Effects of Dam Failure Mechanisms on Downstream Flood Propagation

Fluvial and pluvial flood hazard mapping: combining basin and municipal scale assessment

Statistical analysis of the uncertainty related to flood hazard appraisal