Abstract:Some years ago Greer (1993) and Verschaffel, De Corte and Lasure (1994) provided evidence that after several years of traditional mathematics instruction children have developed a tendency to reduce mathematical modeling to selecting the correct formal-arithmetic operation with the numbers given in the problem, without seriously taking into account their common-sense knowledge and realistic considerations about the problem context. This evidence was obtained by means of a series of especially designed word problems with problematic modeling assumptions from a realistic point of view, administered in the context of a mathematical lesson. After having summarized these two initial studies, we briefly review a series of replication studies executed in different countries showing the omnipresence of this tendency among pupils. Then two related but different lines of follow-up studies are presented. While the first line of research investigated the effects of different forms of scaffolds added to the testing setting aimed at enhancing the mindfulness of students’ approach when solving these problematic items, the second one looked at the effectiveness of attempts to increase the authenticity of the testing setting. After having discussed these empirical studies, the results are interpreted against the background of schooling in general, and the mathematics classroom in particular. The notion of ‘the game of word problems’ is introduced to refer to the ‘hidden’ rules and assumptions that need to be known and respected in order to make the game of word problems function efficiently. In this respect a study is reported which reveals that the strong tendency toward non-realistic mathematical modeling is found among (student-)teachers too. Afterwards two studies aimed at changing students’ perceptions of word problem solving by taking a radical modeling perspective, are reported. The chapter ends with some theoretical, methodological and instructional implications of the work reviewed.

Model method drawing acts as a double-edged sword for solving inconsistent word problems

The Use of a Bar Model Drawing to Teach Word Problem Solving to Students With Mathematics Difficulties

Uncovering the interplay between drawings, mental representations, and arithmetic problem-solving strategies in children and adults

Model Drawing Strategy for Fraction Word Problem Solving of Fourth-Grade Students With Learning Disabilities

Problem-appropriate diagram instruction for improving mathematical word problem solving

The Demands of Simple and Complex Arithmetic Word Problems on Language and Cognitive Resources

To use or no to use diagrams: The effect of drawing a diagram in solving introductory physics problems

What do mathematics lessons look like? Analyses of primary students' drawings

Solving Math Word Problems by Combining Language Models With Symbolic Solvers

The role of strategy-based motivation in mathematical problem solving: The case of learner-generated drawings

Do emotions and prior performance facilitate the use of the learner-generated drawing strategy? Effects of enjoyment, anxiety, and intramathematical performance on the use of the drawing strategy and modelling performance

Learner-generated drawing as a strategy for learning from content area text

Drawing-to-Learn: Does Meta-Analysis Show Differences Between Technology-Based Drawing and Paper-and-Pencil Drawing?

Everyday Knowledge and Mathematical Modeling of School Word Problems

The Effects of Presenting Multidigit Mathematics Problems in a Realistic Context on Sixth Graders' Problem Solving

Every word problem has a solution—The social rationality of mathematical modeling in schools

Do students benefit from drawing productive diagrams themselves while solving introductory physics problems? The case of two electrostatic problems

Learning by Drawing in STEM: A Meta-Analysis

Mapping to Declarative Knowledge for Word Problem Solving