Abstract:There is an ongoing debate in the scientific community regarding the nature and role of the mental representations involved in solving arithmetic word problems. In this study, we took a closer look at the interplay between mental representations, drawing production, and strategy choice. We used dual-strategy isomorphic word problems sharing the same mathematical structure, but differing in the entities they mentioned in their problem statement. Due to the non-mathematical knowledge attached to these entities, some problems were believed to lead to a specific (cardinal) encoding compatible with one solving strategy, whereas other problems were thought to foster a different (ordinal) encoding compatible with the other solving strategy. We asked 59 children and 52 adults to solve 12 of those arithmetic word problems and to make a diagram of each problem. We hypothesized that the diagrams of both groups would display prototypical features indicating either a cardinal representation or an ordinal representation, depending on the entities mentioned in the problem statement. Joint analysis of the drawing task and the problem-solving task showed that the cardinal and ordinal features of the diagrams are linked with the hypothesized semantic properties of the problems and, crucially, with the choice of one solving strategy over another. We showed that regardless of their experience, participants' strategy use depends on their problem representation, which is influenced by the non-mathematical information in the problem statement, as revealed in their diagrams. We discuss the relevance of drawing tasks for investigating mental representations and fostering mathematical development in school.

Model Drawing Strategy for Fraction Word Problem Solving of Fourth-Grade Students With Learning Disabilities

The Use of a Bar Model Drawing to Teach Word Problem Solving to Students With Mathematics Difficulties

Improving the Mathematical Problem-Solving Skills of Students with Learning Disabilities

Uncovering the interplay between drawings, mental representations, and arithmetic problem-solving strategies in children and adults

Self-Regulated Strategy Development Instruction for Teaching Multi-Step Equations to Middle School Students Struggling in Math

The Effect of Model-Based Problem Solving on the Performance of Students Who are Struggling in Mathematics

Using Schema-Based Diagrams to Represent and Solve Word Problems: Relationship between Elementary Preservice Teachers’ Knowledge and Demonstration

The Effects of Concrete-Representational-Abstract Sequence Instruction on Fractions for Chinese Elementary Students with Mathematics Learning Disabilities

Technology-assisted instruction with teacher prompts on fraction multiplication word problems: A single-case design with visual analysis and Bayesian multilevel modeling

Word-Problem-Solving Interventions for Elementary Students With Learning Disabilities: A Selective Meta-Analysis of the Literature

Using SRSD to Improve the Fraction Computations of Students With and At-Risk for EBD

Priming Mathematics Word Problem Structures in a Rural Elementary Classroom

Teaching the partial products multiplication algorithm to students who struggle using CRA‐I

Students with mild intellectual disability engaging in proportions word problems

The mathematical word problem-solving performance gap between children with and without math difficulties: does working memory mediate and/or moderate treatment effects?

Learner-generated drawings by students with mathematical learning difficulties in finishing open number sentences

The Role of Teacher Training in Cognitive Strategy Instruction to Improve Math Problem Solving

A model for scaffolding mathematical problem-solving: From theory to practice

Self-Regulated Strategy Development for Algebra Problem Solving

A Modeling Perspective on the Teaching and Learning of Mathematical Problem Solving