Abstract:Introduction: The ability to reason about equations in a robust and fluent way requires both instrumental knowledge of symbolic forms, syntax, and operations, as well as relational knowledge of how such formalisms map to meaningful relationships captured within mental models. A recent systematic review of studies contrasting the Cuisenaire-Gattegno (Cui) curriculum approach vs. traditional rote schooling on equational reasoning has demonstrated the positive efficacy of pedagogies that focus on integrating these two forms of knowledge. Methods: Here we seek to replicate and extend the most efficacious of these studies (Brownell) by implementing the curriculum to a high degree of fidelity, as well as capturing longitudinal changes within learners via a novel tablet-based assessment of accuracy and fluency with equational reasoning. We examined arithmetic fluency as a function of relational reasoning to equate initial performance across diverse groups and to track changes over four growth assessment points. Results: Results showed that the intervention condition that stressed relational reasoning leads to advances in fluency for addition and subtraction with small numbers. We also showed that this intervention leads to changes in problem solving dispositions toward complex challenges, wherein students in the CUI intervention were more inclined to solve challenging problems relative to those in the control who gave up significantly earlier on multi-step problems. This shift in disposition was associated with higher accuracy on complex equational reasoning problems. A treatment by aptitude interaction emerged for both arithmetic equation reasoning and complex multi-step equational reasoning problems, both of which showed that the intervention had greatest impact for children with lower initial mathematical aptitude. Two years of intervention contrast revealed a large effect (d = 1) for improvements in equational reasoning for the experimental (CUI) group relative to control. Discussion: The strong replication and extension findings substantiate the importance of embedding these teaching aides within the theory grounded curricula that gave rise to them.

Teaching the partial products multiplication algorithm to students who struggle using CRA‐I

Teaching Rational Number Concepts to Fifth-Grade Students Who Struggle With Mathematics

The Effects of a CRA-I Intervention on Students’ Number Sense and Understanding of Addition

The intervention of Brain Gym in the mathematical abilities of high-school students: A pilot study

Improving the Mathematical Problem-Solving Skills of Students with Learning Disabilities

Technology-assisted instruction with teacher prompts on fraction multiplication word problems: A single-case design with visual analysis and Bayesian multilevel modeling

Does fostering reasoning strategies for relatively difficult basic combinations promote transfer by K-3 students?

Interventions to improve equational reasoning: replication and extension of the Cuisenaire-Gattegno curriculum effect

Teaching Mathematics based on Integrating Reading Strategies and Working Memory in Elementary School

Self-Regulated Strategy Development Instruction for Teaching Multi-Step Equations to Middle School Students Struggling in Math

Connecting symbolic fractions to their underlying proportions using iterative partitioning.

Virtual Instruction in Teaching Mathematics to Autistic Students: Effects of Video Modeling, Virtual Manipulatives, and Mathematical Games

'MusiMath' and 'Academic Music' - Two music-based intervention programs for fractions learning in fourth grade students

Teaching Fifth-Grade Students With Specific Learning Disabilities to Explain Their Mathematical Reasoning Through Written Expression

From Non-symbolic to Symbolic Proportions and Back: A Cuisenaire Rod Proportional Reasoning Intervention Enhances Continuous Proportional Reasoning Skills

Does Multi-Component Strategy Training Improve Calculation Fluency Among Poor Performing Elementary School Children?

An arithmetical word problem-solving intervention for disadvantaged French kindergarten children

Evaluating and comparing three variations of cover, copy, and compare on multiplication fact fluency.

Priming Mathematics Word Problem Structures in a Rural Elementary Classroom

Integrated number sense tutoring remediates aberrant neural representations in children with mathematical disabilities

Performance of Fourth-Grade Students with Learning Disabilities on Multiplication Facts Comparing Teacher-Mediated and Technology-Mediated Interventions: A Preliminary Investigation