Three-Dimensional Experimental Study of Compressibility Effects on Turbulent Free Shear Layers

Kevin U. Kim,Gregory S. Elliott,J. Craig Dutton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2514/1.J058556

IF: 2.624

2019-11-25

AIAA Journal

Abstract:Turbulent planar mixing layers of varying compressibility levels have been studied experimentally via flow visualization techniques, pressure measurements, and stereoscopic particle image velocimet...

engineering, aerospace

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Compressibility Effect in Compressible Turbulent Channel Flows

Zhang Peng,Song Yubin,Xia ZhenHua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1360/sspma-2022-0491

2023-01-01

Abstract:In this study, direct numerical simulations are carried out in compressible turbulent channel flows at Mach numbers 3 and 4.3. Combining the previous numerical cases with Mach numbers 0.3, 0.5 and 1.5, a compressible turbulent channel flow database covering the Mach number range from 0.3 to 4.3 at bulk Reynolds number approximately 6000 is obtained. Using this database, we studied the statistical behavior of the flow fields, the velocity and temperature streak structures, and the balance equation of temperature variance. The results show that the statistics related to the velocity field, the temperature field, and the velocity-temperature coupling quantities show better collapse behaviors in the semi-local coordinates, which demonstrates that the turbulent statistics depend mainly on the mean density and viscosity, indicating that the Morkovin hypothesis is applicable in the current Mach number range (0.3-4.3). Furthermore, the findings demonstrate that at high Mach numbers, compressibility is significantly enhanced, which makes the near-wall streak structures more stable. However, the proportion of the dilatation dissipation (due to the compressibility) in the total turbulent dissipation is still small and can be ignored.
Velocity Transformation for Compressible Wall-Bounded Turbulence—an Approach Through the Mixing Length Hypothesis

Xuke Zhu,Yubin Song,Xiaoshuo Yang,Zhenhua Xia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11433-024-2420-5

2024-01-01

Abstract:In an endeavor to establish a connection between the mean velocity profile in compressible wall-bounded turbulence and its incompressible analogue, a refined version of the Trettel and Larsson’s (TL) transformation is systematically derived and rigorously assessed across diverse flow scenarios. Incorporating the recently proposed intrinsic compressibility effects and modeling the multi-layer structure of mixing lengths, the proposed transformation demonstrates exceptional performance in collapsing 57 canonical flow cases, including cooled channel and pipe flows, channel flows with pseudo heat sources, as well as adiabatic and diabatic boundary layer flows. Furthermore, the transformation seamlessly extends to low Reynolds number cooled channel and pipe flows, achieving a level of accuracy unparalleled by other transformations in the current state-of-the-art.
Recent Progress in Compressible Turbulence

Shiyi Chen,Zhenhua Xia,Jianchun Wang,Yantao Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10409-015-0459-9

2015-01-01

Abstract:In this paper, we review some recent studies on compressible turbulence conducted by the authors’ group,which include fundamental studies on compressible isotropic turbulence（CIT） and applied studies on developing a constrained large eddy simulation（CLES） for wall-bounded turbulence. In the first part, we begin with a newly proposed hybrid compact–weighted essentially nonoscillatory（WENO） scheme for a CIT simulation that has been used to construct a systematic database of CIT. Using this database various fundamental properties of compressible turbulence have been examined, including the statistics and scaling of compressible modes, the shocklet–turbulence interaction, the effect of local compressibility on small scales, the kinetic energy cascade, and some preliminary results from a Lagrangian point of view. In the second part, the idea and formulas of the CLES are reviewed, followed by the validations of CLES and some applications in compressible engineering problems.
Visualization of compressibility effects on large-scale structures in compressible mixing layers

Xiaotian Shi,Jun Chen,Zhensu She

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12650-010-0046-x

IF: 1.7

2010-01-01

Journal of Visualization

Abstract:Graphical Abstract
Investigations of Multi-Stage Turbomachinery Flow Based on Mixing Plane Models and Unsteady Simulations

Ya-Lu ZHU,Jia-Qi LUO,Feng LIU

2017-01-01

Journal of Engineering Thermophysics

Abstract:At present,the steady methods based on mixing plane models are widely applied to numerical investigations of multi-stage turbomachinery flow.And meanwhile,the unsteady numerical methods have gained more attentions because the flow details can be obtained.In the study,four typical mixing plane models and unsteady simulations are employed to resolve the flow of a singlestage transonic compressor and a 1.5-stage subsonic turbine.Firstly,the effects of different mixing plane models on the interface flow conservations and the outlet radial distributions of aerodynamic parameters are presented.Furthermore,the results from the mixing plane models are compared with the time-averaged ones from unsteady simulations.Through the comparisons,one strives to find a mixing plane model with strong interface flow conservation and acceptable robustness.
Direct Numerical Simulation of a Three-Dimensional Spatially Evolving Compressible Mixing Layer Laden with Particles. I. Turbulent Structures and Asymmetric Properties

Qi Dai,Tai Jin,Kun Luo,Jianren Fan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5099469

IF: 4.6

2019-01-01

Physics of Fluids

Abstract:With the Eulerian-Lagrangian point-source method, the effects of dispersed particles on turbulent structures and asymmetric properties are systematically investigated in a three-dimensional spatially evolving compressible mixing layer with the convective Mach number up to 1.2. Particles interact with the mixing layer through two-way coupling, and three simulations with different particle diameters are conducted and compared with the particle-free flow. The underlying mechanisms responsible for the mixing layer asymmetry are also revealed through analyzing the self-similar equations of the particle-laden spatially evolving compressible mixing layer. The compressible mixing layer is significantly asymmetric on the high- and low-speed sides. The low-speed layer possesses more vortices and less shocklets compared with the high-speed layer in the fully developed region, and the shear layer center tends to skew toward the low-speed stream, which is due to the streamwise momentum gradient. Small particles augment the mixing layer asymmetry with more vortices and shocklets in the low-speed stream, which is attributed to the small inertia and the larger streamwise velocity of particles than fluid across the mixing layer. However, large particles attenuate the asymmetry of the mixing layer where the vortical structures on the low-speed side are further reduced and the shocklets are barely existent in both the layers, which is ascribed to the large inertia and the stronger effect of particle back-reaction on the low-speed fluid than that on the high-speed fluid.
Direct Numerical Simulation of a Three-Dimensional Spatially Evolving Compressible Mixing Layer Laden with Particles. II. Turbulence Anisotropy and Growth Rate

Qi Dai,Tai Jin,Kun Luo,Wei Xiao,Jianren Fan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5110990

IF: 4.6

2019-01-01

Physics of Fluids

Abstract:With the Eulerian–Lagrangian point-source method, turbulence modulation by dispersed particles is systematically investigated in a three-dimensional spatially evolving compressible mixing layer with the convective Mach number up to 1.2. Particles interact with the mixing layer through two-way coupling, and three simulations with different particle diameters are conducted and compared with the particle-free simulation. The underlying mechanisms responsible for turbulence modulation are revealed by analyzing the transport equations of the Reynolds stresses and turbulent kinetic energy, especially the two-way coupling terms. The compressible mixing layer turbulence is significantly anisotropic with strong three-dimensionality. The addition of particles augments turbulence anisotropy of the shear layer, and the augmentation becomes greater as the particle inertia increases, which is attributed to the different particle responsive features to the fluid fluctuations in the streamwise, normal, and spanwise directions. Particles respond fast to the fluid streamwise fluctuation but slowly to the normal and spanwise fluctuations because the streamwise turbulent intensity is larger compared with the normal and spanwise turbulent intensities. Consequently, the streamwise fluctuating velocity and the Reynolds shear stress are augmented and the normal and spanwise velocity fluctuations are attenuated. Besides, small particles slightly enhance the growth rate of the mixing layer, while large particles reduce the shear layer growth rate in the fully developed turbulence, which is due to the quick response of small particles and the slow response of large particles to the total fluid fluctuation.
The three-dimensional vortical structure in time-developing mixing layer with cross shear

Shen Liping,Lin Jianzhong,Fu Bin

1996-01-01

Abstract:A new method used to describe three-dimensional mixing layers with discrete vortex filaments is studied. Based on this method, the three-dimensional mixing layers are computed numerically. The vortical structure, distribution of mean velocity and momentum loss thickness in different time are given. The effects of shear rate and intensity of disturbance on flows are analysed. Some computed results are compared with experimental ones, they show a good agreement. The results given in the paper are helpful to understand such flows.
3d Numerical Simulation Of A Planar Compressible Free Mixing Layer

song fu,qibing li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-59334-5_31

2003-01-01

Abstract:In this paper Xu's gas-kinetic BGK scheme is simplified based on the conservative constraint and then applied in the simulation of 3-D planar compressible mixing layer with M-c = 0.4, 0.8 and 1.2. The numerical results here provide the flow-field structure, the characteristic of velocity fluctuation. The velocity fluctuation intensity and shear stresses are in good agreement with experimental and existing numerical results. The normalized growth rate agrees well with experimental results.
Direct Numerical Simulation of A Spatially Developing Compressible Plane Mixing Layer: Flow Structures and Mean Flow Properties

Qiang Zhou,Feng He,M. Y. Shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2012.400

IF: 3.7

2012-01-01

Journal of Fluid Mechanics

Abstract:The spatially developing compressible plane mixing layer with a convective Mach number of 0.7 is investigated by direct numerical simulation. A pair of equal and opposite oblique instability waves is introduced to perturb the mixing layer at the inlet. The full evolution process of instability, including formation of Lambda-vortices and hairpin vortices, breakdown of large structures and establishment of self-similar turbulence, is presented clearly in the simulation. In the transition process, the flow fields are populated sequentially by Lambda-vortices, hairpin vortices and 'flower' structures. This is the first direct evidence showing the dominance of these structures in the spatially developing mixing layer. Hairpin vortices are found to play an important role in the breakdown of the flow. The legs of hairpin vortices first evolve into sheaths with intense vorticity then break up into small slender vortices. The later flower structures are produced by the instability of the heads of the hairpin vortices. They prevail for a long distance in the mixing layer until the flow starts to settle down into its self-similar state. The preponderance of slender inclined streamwise vortices is observed in the transversal middle zone of the transition region after the breakup of the hairpin legs. This predominance of streamwise vortices also persists in the self-similar turbulent region, though the vortices there are found to be relatively very weak. The evolution of both the mean streamwise velocity profile and the Reynolds stresses is found to have close connection to the behaviour of the large vortex structures. High growth rates of the momentum and vorticity thicknesses are observed in the transition region of the flow. The growth rates in the self-similar turbulence region decay to a value that agrees well with previous experimental and numerical studies. Shocklets occur in the simulation, and their formation mechanisms are elaborated and categorized. This is the first three-dimensional simulation that captures shocklets at this low convective Mach number.
Numerical Simulation of Compressible Mixing Layers

Song Fu,Qibing Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijheatfluidflow.2006.03.028

IF: 2.643

2006-01-01

International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow

Abstract:Three-dimensional spatially developing compressible planar mixing layers are studied numerically for convective Mach number Mc=0.4, 0.8 and 1.2. The present results for the flow-field structures, the mean velocity profiles, the mixing-layer growth rate and Reynolds stresses agree well with those of experiments and other numerical studies. The normalized growth rate decreases with increasing Mc. Shocklets are found to exist in the mixing layer at Mc=1.2 and their formation mechanism shows good agreement with the scenario of flow around a bluff body. The effect of compressibility on the large-scale structures is stronger than that on the small-scale ones. The budget of the Reynolds-stress transport equations agree well with that from the temporal developing results. The magnitudes of most of the contributing terms in the budget reduce with increased compressibility effect except for the pressure-dilatation term which is very small.
Numerical flow visualization of a mixing layer

Jianzhong Lin,Zhaosheng Yu,Xueming Shao

1998-01-01

Journal of Hydrodynamics

Abstract:Kelvin-Helmhotz roll up of the 3-D time-developing mixing was simulated numerically. The dye lines or fluid interfaces were presented by computing a passive scalar at high Peclet number. The hydric bubbles were also simulated numerically. To help understanding the visualization results, the behaviour of coherent structures were analyzed. A comparison between vortical structure and passive scalar contours indicates that the wrapping by the vortices largely dominates the evolution of passive scalar.
Modelling the Compressibility Effect with Second-Moment Closure

S. Fu,S. Y. Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-75999-7_41

IF: 4.391

2007-01-01

Computational Mechanics

Abstract:Compressibility is well known to suppress turbulence, the cause of the compressibility effects remains, however, unclear. Previous studies carried out in the early 1990s conjectured that the main compressible effects were associated with the dilatations of velocity fluctuation. Later, it was shown that the main compressibility effect came from the reduced pressure-strain term due to reduced pressure fluctuations. Although better understanding of the compressible turbulence had generally been achieved with the increased DNS and experimental efforts, there are still some discrepancies among these recent findings. In the present work the effect of compressibility on shear flows are characterized in three categories corresponding to three regions of turbulent Mach numbers M t : the low-M t , the transition-M t ; and the high-M t ; regions. It is observed in these three regions that the effect of compressibility on the growth rate of the turbulent mixing layer is rather different. A simplified approach to model the reduced pressure-strain effect may not necessarily reduce the mixing-layer growth rate, rather, an increase in the growth rate may occur. The present work develops a new second-moment model for the compressible turbulence through the introduction of some blending functions of M t to account for the compressibility effects on the flow. The model has successfully applied to the compressible mixing layers.
Direct Numerical Simulation of Particle Dispersion in a Three-Dimensional Spatially Developing Compressible Mixing Layer

Qi Dai,Tai Jin,Kun Luo,Jianren Fan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5054744

IF: 4.6

2018-01-01

Physics of Fluids

Abstract:By direct numerical simulations, the particle dispersion is systematically investigated in a three-dimensional spatially developing compressible mixing layer. The convective Mach number is 1.2 and particles interact with fluid through both the one-and two-way coupling. Six simulations are conducted with different particle diameters (Stokes numbers) or particle back-reaction. The compressible mixing layer is characterized by various vortical structures and unsteady shocklets, which both have significant effects on the dispersion of particles. The particles tend to accumulate in the peripheries of the vortical structures with high density, low vorticity, and high strain rate inside the mixing layer, as well as the high-density regions behind the shocklets outside the mixing layer. Due to the sweep and ejection effects, the particles from the high-speed side cluster in the high-speed streaks while those from the low-speed side collect in the low-speed steaks. Also, the particle mixing between the two streams skews towards the low-speed side. Compared with the other cases, medium particles show the strongest preferential concentration in the peripheries of vortices while small particles exhibit the most significant tendency to accumulate behind the shocklets. As the Stokes number decreases, the particle mixing is enhanced with more significant deviation towards the low-speed side. Besides, the particle back-reaction on fluid attenuates the preferential concentration. Outside the mixing layer, the number of the compression regions of the particle dispersion decreases, but the particles have stronger concentration behind the residual shocklets. The particle mixing as well as the skewness towards the low-speed side is also attenuated under the two-way coupling, which is attributed to the reduction of the vortex number and the centrifugal effects on particles. Published by AIP Publishing.
MULTI-SCALE STRUCTURES IN COMPRESSIBLE TURBULENT MIXING LAYERS

TIE-JIN WANG,XIAO-TIAN SHI,JUN CHEN,ZHEN-SU SHE

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217984910023797

2011-01-01

Modern Physics Letters B

Abstract:A size-dependent gradient method is used to study the Mie scattering visualization of the compressible turbulent mixing layers at two convective Mach numbers M-c = 0.107 and 0.474 in order to reveal multi-scale structures. Coherent vortices and inclined wavy structures are clearly visualized by applying the method. Similarity between the grey-level and the velocity fluctuations is discovered with the spectral analysis. These results suggest away to capture turbulent structures from scalar fields.
Direct Numerical Simulation of Compressible Binary Species Mixing Layer

SUN Xiao-bo,FAN Xue-jun,LU Xi-yun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0253-2778.2007.10.020

2007-01-01

Journal of University of Science and Technology of China

Abstract:Compressible binary species mixing layer was investigated using direct numerical simulation to solve the three-dimensional compressible Navier-Stokes and species equations.The effects of the density ratio of binary species and compressible effect were mainly discussed.Results show that,as the density ratio increases,the growth rate of the disturbances in the mixing layer decreases.In the early stage of the the mixing layer evolution,the compressible effect,especially the baroclinic effect,dominates the dynamics of the vortex;in the later stage,the compressibility becomes weak and the stretching effect plays a dominant role.The transition and evolution of the coherent structures were also analyzed.
Direct Numerical Simulation of a Three-Dimensional Particle Laden Plane Mixing Layer Considering Inter-Particle Collisions

Xinwei Chen,Debo Li,Kun Luo,Jianren Fan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ces.2011.08.052

IF: 4.7

2011-01-01

Chemical Engineering Science

Abstract:To investigate the behavior of inter-particle collision and its effects on multiphase flow, the direct numerical simulation of a three-dimensional gas–solid two-phase plane mixing layer is conducted. The flow is assumed to be temporally evolving and incompressible. The particle trajectories are traced by the one-way or two-way coupled Lagrangian method separately. The deterministic hard-sphere model is used to describe the inter-particle collision. Calculations are performed for a particle Stokes numbers of 3. The results show that the preferential concentration phenomenon of particles is found after the beginning of the rolling up of the large-scale vortex structures due to the influence of the vortex. It is also found that the inter-particle collision occurs frequently in the local regions with higher particle concentration of the flow field. The evolution of inter-particle collision can be divided into 3 stages under the influence of the growth of the vortex and the particle dispersion. The results under the two-way coupling show that the particle distribution is more uniform. The modifications of the mixed fluid thickness, the Reynolds stresses, and the mean stream-wise velocity of two phases due to inter-particle collision are quantitatively investigated.
Direct Numerical Simulation of Rapidly Distorting Compressible Homogeneous Turbulent Flow

Shuang Tan,Qibing Li,Song Fu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1615/tsfp9.570

2015-01-01

Abstract:The gas-kinetic scheme is applied into the direct numerical simulation of rapidly distorting turbulence, to investigate the effects of mean flow compressibility on turbulence fluctuations. Different distortion Mach numbers are considered and the results show that as 'implicit effect' (Simone et al., 1997), the redistribution relaxation process in the initial stage has great influences on flow field evolution. Compared with shear flows, mean flow compressibility has distinct 'explicit effect' on turbulence energy in strain flows. The priori estimate of three typical turbulence models for redistribution term shows that high order turbulence model is required for pressure-deviatoric term, and the compressibility corrections of pressure-dilatation part should also be carried out upon high order models.
Experimental Study of Structure and Dynamics of Turbulent Stratified Jet

Jun Chen,Duo Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1115/FEDSM-ICNMM2010-30740

Abstract:Stratified flows are frequently observed in environmental and oceanic applications, which often involve interaction of momentum and scalar flux. In this study, Particle Image Velocimetry and Planar Laser Induced Fluorescence are applied to simultaneously measure the velocity and density fields of a turbulent jet discharged horizontally into an environment with density difference, for studying the mixing and entrainment process in stratified flows. The data are analyzed to gain understanding of the physical mechanism of vertical mixing (mixing along gravity direction) and horizontal mixing (mixing along horizontal direction) introduced by the turbulent jet flows. The dataset also provides a test platform for mixing models used in stratified flow simulations.© 2010 ASME

Environmental Science,Physics
Vortex Structures and Mixing of Compressible Mixing Layer

Zhou Qian

2014-01-01

Abstract:Using the seventh-order upwind compact scheme for spatial discretization of the convective flux,the explicit central eighth-order scheme for viscous flux terms,the unsteady three-dimensional compressible Navier-Stokes equations are solved for the compressible spatially evolving plane mixing layer.The direct numerical simulation(DNS)is performed without resorting to any sub-grid models.The convective Mach number of the mixing layer is chosen to be 0.7for characterizing the moderate compressibility.The finite difference grid size is 4160×351×256.The spatial developing structures are shown in detail from the initial instability flow until the full development of turbulent flow.The results show that the large-scale vortex structures,such asΛvortices,hairpin vortices and flower structures,make the momentum thickness grow rapidly along the streamwise flow.The discussions are focused on the capacity of the moderate compressible shear layer to mix the fluids from the two different sides.It is found that the large-scale vortex structures significantly affect the thickness of the visual layer thickness shown by the mass fraction of the passive scalar.Particularly,strong pumping flows between the two counter-rotating vortices ofΛvortices as well as hairpin vortices injects large amounts of fluid from one side to the other side.The small vortices contained in the flower structures also help mix the fluids through their energetic twisting motion,only at a relatively small scale.Generally speaking,the dynamic evolution of these large-scale vortex structures produces very curvy interfaces between the upper side and the lower side,and the large contact area of the curvy interfaces appreciably enhances the mixing between the fluids from the two sides.The fine scale structures in the fully developed turbulence play an important role in making the mixing of the shear layer more uniform.However the contribution of the fully developed turbulence to the visual mixing layer growth is very limited.

Three-Dimensional Experimental Study of Compressibility Effects on Turbulent Free Shear Layers

Compressibility Effect in Compressible Turbulent Channel Flows

Velocity Transformation for Compressible Wall-Bounded Turbulence—an Approach Through the Mixing Length Hypothesis

Recent Progress in Compressible Turbulence

Visualization of compressibility effects on large-scale structures in compressible mixing layers

Investigations of Multi-Stage Turbomachinery Flow Based on Mixing Plane Models and Unsteady Simulations

Direct Numerical Simulation of a Three-Dimensional Spatially Evolving Compressible Mixing Layer Laden with Particles. I. Turbulent Structures and Asymmetric Properties

Direct Numerical Simulation of a Three-Dimensional Spatially Evolving Compressible Mixing Layer Laden with Particles. II. Turbulence Anisotropy and Growth Rate

The three-dimensional vortical structure in time-developing mixing layer with cross shear

3d Numerical Simulation Of A Planar Compressible Free Mixing Layer

Direct Numerical Simulation of A Spatially Developing Compressible Plane Mixing Layer: Flow Structures and Mean Flow Properties

Numerical Simulation of Compressible Mixing Layers

Numerical flow visualization of a mixing layer

Modelling the Compressibility Effect with Second-Moment Closure

Direct Numerical Simulation of Particle Dispersion in a Three-Dimensional Spatially Developing Compressible Mixing Layer

MULTI-SCALE STRUCTURES IN COMPRESSIBLE TURBULENT MIXING LAYERS

Direct Numerical Simulation of Compressible Binary Species Mixing Layer

Direct Numerical Simulation of a Three-Dimensional Particle Laden Plane Mixing Layer Considering Inter-Particle Collisions

Direct Numerical Simulation of Rapidly Distorting Compressible Homogeneous Turbulent Flow

Experimental Study of Structure and Dynamics of Turbulent Stratified Jet

Vortex Structures and Mixing of Compressible Mixing Layer