Abstract:This article seeks to bring evidence on public value co-creation between public auditors and auditees, with a focus on the environment, as a matter of pressing interest for the citizens. We analyse data from performance audit reports issued by the European Court of Auditors: the tonality of audit conclusions and the corresponding auditees’ replies and the degree of acceptance and implementation of audit recommendations by the auditees. The analysis is performed using the theoretical perspectives of institutional logics and public value co-creation. We use qualitative and quantitative methods, including sentiment analysis and bivariate analysis. We find evidence that the EU public auditors increased their focus on environmental issues, following an increasingly trending institutional logic of focusing on non-financial topics of public interest. However, the tonality of environment-related audit conclusions and the auditees’ replies does not differ from the non-environment-related ones. We also demonstrate that public auditors co-created public value together with the auditees through a significantly higher acceptance of their recommendations in environmental than in non-environmental audits. The article contributes to the existing literature by using data from a supranational supreme audit institution and by applying an innovative research methodology in the audit field (sentiment analysis). It also offers practitioners valuable insights on performance audit’s evolution and impact. Although the data is limited to one supreme audit institution, this research can open future research avenues to perform comparative analysis with other supreme audit institutions or extend the research scope to content analysis of the substance of audit findings. Este artículo busca aportar evidencias sobre la co-creación de valor público entre los auditores públicos y los entes auditados, poniendo el foco en el medio ambiente como un asunto de interés apremiante para la ciudadanía. Analizamos los datos de los informes de auditoría de gestión emitidos por el Tribunal de Cuentas Europeo: el tono de las conclusiones de auditoría y las correspondientes respuestas de los auditados y el grado de aceptación e implementación de las recomendaciones de auditoría por parte de los auditados. El análisis se realiza desde las perspectivas teóricas de las lógicas institucionales y la co-creación de valor público. Utilizamos métodos cualitativos y cuantitativos, incluido el análisis de sentimiento y el análisis bivariado. Encontramos evidencia de que los auditores públicos de la UE incrementaron su enfoque en temas medioambientales, emitiendo un número cada vez mayor de informes relacionados con el medioambiente, siguiendo una lógica institucional actual de la nueva gobernanza pública de enfocarse en temas no financieros de interés público. No obstante, la tonalidad de los informes de auditoría, las conclusiones y las respuestas de los auditados en auditorias medioambientales no difieren del resto. También demostramos que los auditores públicos cocrearon valor público junto con los auditados a través de una aceptación significativamente mayor de sus recomendaciones en las auditorías ambientales si la comparamos con la aceptación en las no ambientales. El artículo contribuye a la literatura existente utilizando datos de una institución de auditoria supranacional y aplicando una metodología de investigación innovadora en el campo de la auditoría (análisis de sentimiento). También ofrece a los profesionales información valiosa sobre la evolución y el impacto de la auditoría de gestión en el sector público. Aunque los datos se limitan a una única institución auditora, este artículo puede abrir vías de investigación futuras para realizar análisis comparativos con otros tribunales de cuentas o ampliar el alcance de la investigación al análisis de contenido de las conclusiones de auditoría y de las respuestas de los auditados.

Effectiveness of new safeguards and prohibitions to protect audit independence: an empirical research with auditors

The audit expectation gap and strengthened independence standards in the European Union: measuring the effects of the new EU Directive

The Effect of Auditing on Promoting Exports: Evidence from Private Firms in Emerging Markets

Predicting audit failure: evidence from auditing enforcement releases

Addressing the Auditor Independence Puzzle: Regulatory Models and Proposal for Reform

Auditor Independence and Value Relevance in the European Banking Sector: Do Investor Protection Environment and Corporate Governance Matter?

Incentives for Auditor Independence: An Analysis of the Effectiveness of Formal Sanctions in China

The Effect Of Auditor Competence And Auditor Independence On Audit Quality With Auditor Ethics As A Moderating Variable

Effect of Computer Assisted Audit Tools on Corporate Sustainability

The economic impact of audit failures

Audit firm tenure and audit quality: A cross‐European study

New development: The shift of public sector auditing under the influence of institutional logics—the case of European Court of Auditors

The effect of the financial crisis on audit quality: European evidence

Sustainable corporate governance and new auditing issues: a preliminary empirical evidence on key audit matters

Audit partner industry specialization and audit quality: Evidence from Spain

An empirical comparison of non‐Big 4 and Big 4 auditors' perceptions of auditor independence

effect of independence, professionalism, and experience of internal auditors on fraud prevention with organizational culture as moderating variable

The Effect of Auditor Independence and Ethics on Audit Quality with Audit Fee as a Moderating Variable in Public Accounting Firms in Medan

The impact of managerial ownership on audit fees: Evidence from Portugal and Spain

Does increasing auditors' independence lead to more forceful public auditing? A study of a Canadian internal audit reform

New Public Governance and Public Value Co-creation: The Case of the European Court of Auditors Environmental Audits