Abstract:This paper examines the economic consequences associated with an audit failure in the field of statutory auditing services, by analyzing changes in the audit firm’s market share around the time of the investigation process undertaken by the Spanish Public Oversight Board. We explore the variations in audit market share by applying the difference in differences method to a treatment group of 70 sanctioned audit firms and a matched control group of 70 non-sanctioned audit firms. The period of analysis covers the years from 1999 to 2015. Our results show that the sanctioned audit firms suffered a significant decrease in their relative number of clients. Moreover, this measure of market share decreased not only after the publication of the sanction disclosure (which may be attributed to reputational losses) but also after the initiation of the investigation (which may be attributed to the firm’s reluctance to audit risky clients). Findings are similar for both small and large firms when the market share is measured in terms of clients, whereas the evidence is weak concerning variations in their turnover-based market share. Our conclusions could be of interest for audit firms and also for audit regulators when designing disciplinary systems. Este trabajo examina las consecuencias económicas asociadas a un fallo de auditoría en el ámbito de los servicios de auditoría legal, analizando los cambios en la cuota de mercado de la firma de auditoría en torno al momento del proceso de investigación emprendido por el Consejo de Supervisión Pública español. Exploramos las variaciones en la cuota de mercado de la auditoría aplicando el método de diferencia en diferencias a un grupo de tratamiento de 70 firmas de auditoría sancionadas y a un grupo de control emparejado de 70 firmas de auditoría no sancionadas. El periodo de análisis abarca los años comprendidos entre 1999 y 2015. Nuestros resultados muestran que las firmas de auditoría sancionadas sufrieron un descenso significativo en su número relativo de clientes. Además, esta medida de la cuota de mercado disminuyó no sólo después de la publicación de la comunicación de la sanción (lo que puede atribuirse a las pérdidas de reputación), sino también después del inicio de la investigación (lo que puede atribuirse a la reticencia de la empresa a auditar clientes de riesgo). Los resultados son similares tanto para las pequeñas como para las grandes empresas cuando la cuota de mercado se mide en términos de clientes, mientras que la evidencia es débil en lo que respecta a las variaciones de su cuota de mercado basada en el volumen de negocio. Nuestras conclusiones podrían ser de interés para las firmas de auditoría y también para los reguladores de la auditoría a la hora de diseñar sistemas disciplinarios.

The audit expectation gap and strengthened independence standards in the European Union: measuring the effects of the new EU Directive

Effectiveness of new safeguards and prohibitions to protect audit independence: an empirical research with auditors

Board Gender Diversity,Managerial Power and Demand for External Audit

The Effect of Auditing on Promoting Exports: Evidence from Private Firms in Emerging Markets

Predicting audit failure: evidence from auditing enforcement releases

Addressing the Auditor Independence Puzzle: Regulatory Models and Proposal for Reform

Auditor Independence and Value Relevance in the European Banking Sector: Do Investor Protection Environment and Corporate Governance Matter?

THE CURRENT STATUS OF AUDITORS’ AND INVESTORS’ PERCEPTIONS OF THE AUDIT EXPECTATION GAP

Independence factors influencing audit expectation gap in listed deposit money Banks in Nigeria

A Partial Least-Squares Structural Equation Modeling Approach to Investigate the Audit Expectation Gap and Its Impact on Investor Confidence: Perspectives from a Developing Country

New development: The shift of public sector auditing under the influence of institutional logics—the case of European Court of Auditors

Existence of the Audit Expectation Gap and Its Impact on Stakeholders’ Confidence: The Moderating Role of the Financial Reporting Council

Audit education role in decreasing the expectation gap

Did the International Financial Reporting Standards Increase the Audit Expectation Gap? An Exploratory Study

An analysis of the audit expectation gap in the Maltese central government

The effect of the financial crisis on audit quality: European evidence

The audit expectation gap: A review of the academic literature

Audit digitalization and its consequences on the audit expectation gap: A critical perspective

The Effect Of Auditor Competence And Auditor Independence On Audit Quality With Auditor Ethics As A Moderating Variable

Audit expectation gap: an empirical analysis

The economic impact of audit failures