Abstract:Modifying patients' expectations by exposing them to expectation violation situations (thus maximizing the difference between the expected and the actual situational outcome) is proposed to be a crucial mechanism for therapeutic success for a variety of different mental disorders. However, clinical observations suggest that patients often maintain their expectations regardless of experiences contradicting their expectations. It remains unclear which information processing mechanisms lead to modification or persistence of patients' expectations. Insight in the processing could be provided by Neuroimaging studies investigating prediction error (PE, i.e., neuronal reactions to non-expected stimuli). Two methods are often used to investigate the PE: (1) paradigms, in which participants passively observe PEs ("passive" paradigms) and (2) paradigms, which encourage a behavioral adaptation following a PE ("active" paradigms). These paradigms are similar to the methods used to induce expectation violations in clinical settings: (1) the confrontation with an expectation violation situation and (2) an enhanced confrontation in which the patient actively challenges his expectation. We used this similarity to gain insight in the different neuronal processing of the two PE paradigms. We performed a meta-analysis contrasting neuronal activity of PE paradigms encouraging a behavioral adaptation following a PE and paradigms enforcing passiveness following a PE. We found more neuronal activity in the striatum, the insula and the fusiform gyrus in studies encouraging behavioral adaptation following a PE. Due to the involvement of reward assessment and avoidance learning associated with the striatum and the insula we propose that the deliberate execution of action alternatives following a PE is associated with the integration of new information into previously existing expectations, therefore leading to an expectation change. While further research is needed to directly assess expectations of participants, this study provides new insights into the information processing mechanisms following an expectation violation.

Great expectations: The construct validity of the violation‐of‐expectation method for studying infant cognition

Expecting the Unexpected: Infants Use Others' Surprise to Revise Their Own Expectations

Integrating expectations and outcomes: Preschoolers' developing ability to reason about others' emotions

Perceptual and conceptual novelty independently guide infant looking behaviour: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Violation of Expectation via Metacognitive Prompting Reduces Theory of Mind Prediction Error in Large Language Models

Simplicity and validity in infant research

Predictors of Coping With Expectation Violation: An Integrative Review

Expectation Violations as an Effective Alternative to Complex Mentalizing in Novel Communication

Learning about Expectation Violation from Prediction Error Paradigms – A Meta-Analysis on Brain Processes Following a Prediction Error

Observing Emotion in Infants: Facial Expression, Body Behavior, and Rater Judgments of Responses to an Expectancy-Violating Event

The Modulation of Expectation Violation on Attention: Evidence from the Spatial Cueing Effects

Expectation Violation Enhances the Development of New Abstract Syntactic Representations: Evidence from an Artificial Language Learning Study

AVoE: A Synthetic 3D Dataset on Understanding Violation of Expectation for Artificial Cognition

An asynchronous, hands-off workflow for looking time experiments with infants.

Impact of expectation violation on relationship satisfaction across the transition to parenthood.

Computational modelling of hippocampal sensitivity to expectation violation

Nonverbal expectancy violations: Model elaboration and application to immediacy behaviors

Harmonic expectancy violations: Testing the effects of familiarity, lead-in time, and ecological validity

Do infants discriminate non-linguistic vocal expressions of positive emotions?

Infants evaluate informativeness of evidence and predict causal events as revealed in theta oscillations and predictive looking

Expecting the Unexpected: Violation of Expectation Shifts Strategies Toward Information Exploration