Abstract:This paper presents the results of a reconsideration of earlier work that finds an association between daily hospital admissions for respiratory distress and daily concentrations of sulphate (lag 1) as well as daily maximum concentrations of ozone (lags 1 and 3). These associations are found even after clustering the data by hospital of admission and accounting for the effects of temperature. We use an adaptation of their generalized estimating equation technique for clustered data, that daily data being for southern Ontario summers from 1983 to 1988. Like them, we adjust for daily maximum temperatures. However, unlike the earlier work returned to ours includes daily average humidity as a potential explanatory variable in our model. Our analysis also differs from theirs in that we cluster the data by census subdivision to reduce the risk of confounding pollutant levels with population size within regions. Moreover, we log-transform the explanatory variables and then high-pass filter the resulting data. We also deviate from the earlier analysis by taking account of measurement error incurred in using surrogate measures of the explanatory variables. To do so we use new methodology designed for our study but of potential value in other applications. That methodology requires a spatial predictive distribution for the unmeasured explanatory variables. Each day about 700 missing measurements for each of these variables can then be imputed over the geographical domain of the study. With these imputations we get a measure of imputation error through the covariance of the predictive distribution. Along with the predictive distribution we require an impact model to link-up with the predictive distribution. We describe that model and show how it uses the imputed measurements of the missing values of the explanatory variables. We also show how through that model, uncertainty about these values is reflected in our analysis and in commensurate uncertainties in the inferences made. Apart from its substantive objectives, our analysis serves to test the new methods with the earlier results serving as a foil. The reassuring qualitative agreement between our findings and the earlier results seems encouraging.

Causal Inference in Environmental Epidemiology: Old and New Approaches

Transporting established insights from classical experimental design, implemented using methods that rely on modern computing to address causal questions in environmental epidemiology

Environmental epidemiology: basics and proof of cause-effect

Measurement Error and Environmental Epidemiology: a Policy Perspective

Unbiased temperature-related mortality estimates using weekly and monthly health data: a new method for environmental epidemiology and climate impact studies

A causal inference framework for cancer cluster investigations using publicly available data

Addressing Spatially Structured Interference in Causal Analysis Using Propensity Scores

Causation and prevention in epidemiology: assumptions, derivations, and measures old and new

Potential types of bias when estimating causal effects in environmental research and how to interpret them

A flexible hierarchical framework for improving inference in area-referenced environmental health studies

A Review of Spatial Causal Inference Methods for Environmental and Epidemiological Applications

Bridging the Divide: Tackling Tensions Between Life-Course Epidemiology and Causal Inference

Widespread environment-specific causal effects detected in the UK Biobank

A new approach to hierarchical data analysis: Targeted maximum likelihood estimation for the causal effect of a cluster-level exposure

How causal inference concepts can guide research into the effects of climate on infectious diseases

Imputing Unmeasured Explanatory Variables in Environmental Epidemiology With Application to Health Impact Analysis of Air Pollution

Estimating the impact of bias in causal epidemiological studies: the case of health outcomes following assisted reproduction

Modernizing the Bradford Hill criteria for assessing causal relationships in observational data

Causal Inference in the Social Sciences

Current trends in the application of causal inference methods to pooled longitudinal non-randomised data: a protocol for a methodological systematic review

A Review of Causal Inference Methods for Estimating the Effects of Exposure Change when Incident Exposure Is Unobservable