Consumer Uncertainty and Purchase Decision Reversals: Theory and Evidence

Jeffrey D. Shulman,Marcus Cunha,Julian K. Saint Clair

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2015.0906

2015-07-01

Marketing Science

Abstract:This research examines how prepurchase information that reduces consumer uncertainty about a product or service can affect consumer decisions to reverse an initial product purchase or service enrollment decision. One belief commonly held by retailers is that provision of greater amounts of information before the purchase reduces decision reversals. We provide theory and evidence showing conditions under which uncertainty-reducing information provided before the purchase decision can actually increase the number of decision reversals. Predictions generated from an analytical model of consumer behavior incorporating behavioral theory of reference-dependence are complemented by empirical evidence from both a controlled behavioral experiment and econometric analysis of archival data. Combined, the theory and evidence suggest that managers should be aware that their information provision decisions taken to reduce decision reversals may actually increase them. Data, as supplemental material, are available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2015.0906 .

business

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how providing information to reduce uncertainty affects the likelihood that consumers will ultimately reverse their initial purchase or service registration decisions during the consumer purchase decision - making process. Specifically, the paper explores whether providing more information before purchase can reduce consumers' return and service cancellation behaviors, or, in some cases, increase these behaviors instead. Through a combination of theoretical models and empirical analysis, the paper reveals that under certain conditions, information that reduces uncertainty may lead to more decision - reversal phenomena.

### Main research questions:
1. **The relationship between consumer uncertainty and purchase decision reversal**: The paper studies how information provided before purchase to reduce uncertainty affects the likelihood that consumers will reverse their initial purchase or service registration decisions.
2. **The effectiveness of information - providing strategies**: The paper explores whether the information - providing strategies adopted by enterprises to reduce consumer uncertainty can achieve the expected results, that is, reducing returns and service cancellations, or may be counterproductive and increase these behaviors.

### Research background:
- **The cost of consumer decision reversal**: Consumer returns and service cancellations can bring significant costs to enterprises, such as inventory management costs, reselling costs, etc.
- **Limitations of existing research**: Previous studies mostly believe that reducing consumer uncertainty can reduce decision reversal, but this paper presents a different view, that is, in some cases, reducing uncertainty may increase decision reversal.

### Research methods:
- **Theoretical model**: The paper constructs an analytical model, combined with reference - dependence in behavioral theory, to predict the impact of enterprises providing information to reduce uncertainty on consumer decision reversal.
- **Empirical analysis**: The paper verifies the predictions of the theoretical model through controlled experiments and archival data analysis.

### Main findings:
- **Non - monotonic relationship**: The paper finds that the impact of information that reduces uncertainty on decision reversal is non - monotonic. Under certain conditions, reducing uncertainty may increase the probability of decision reversal, especially when the known utility components of consumers are within a specific interval.
- **The role of reference - dependence**: The paper emphasizes the importance of reference - dependence in this process, that is, consumers will be affected by their expected utility when evaluating products or services, which leads to decision reversal.

### Practical significance:
- **Enterprise information - providing strategies**: The paper suggests that enterprises should evaluate their information - providing strategies more carefully, because some information that reduces uncertainty may be counterproductive and increase return and service cancellation behaviors.
- **Marketing strategy adjustment**: When designing marketing strategies, enterprises should consider consumers' psychological factors, especially when providing information to reduce uncertainty, they need to weigh the completeness and partiality of information.

Through these studies, the paper provides enterprises with a new perspective to help them better understand and deal with the problem of consumer decision reversal.