Factors affecting wear in tumbling mills: Influence of composition and microstructure
J.J. Moore,R. Perez,A. Gangopadhyay,J.F. Eggert
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0301-7516(88)90071-3
1988-04-01
International Journal of Mineral Processing
Abstract:A large range of iron-carbon alloys were investigated under milling conditions. The alloy systems used included AISI 1020 mild steel, high-carbon low-alloy forged steel, forged martensitic stainless steel, forged austenitic stainless steel and NiHard, 20% chromium, 27% chromium, 30% chromium white cast irons. A range of mineral slurries was also used which included a corrosive copper-nickel sulfide ore, abrasive quartzite, taconite, molybdenite, and abrasive and corrosive quartzite-pyrrhotite combinations. These ranges of alloy systems and minerals provided suitable comparisons with respect to corrosive and/or abrasive conditions of the mineral slurry together with a suitable variation in microstructural constituents of the ball.Marked-ball wear tests were conducted under laboratory conditions in the main, but a small investigation aimed at identifying the importance of impact was also conducted using large industrial tumbling mills. Seven wear mechanisms were identified from examination of ball surfaces, using scanning electron microscopy. It was determined that wear rate was dependent upon a complex interaction of parameters involving microstructure, hardness ratio of the ball to the mineral, mineral slurry chemistry and pH and oxygen potential, ball mix and size. Adiabatic shear bands were also found in balls which were used in the large industrial mill. A galvanic series of the minerals and grinding media materials was determined from electrochemical tests, indicating the tendency of each grinding material to corrosive wear. The effect of media composition and microstructure was also determined using a strain index method developed in this investigation. In all the tests conducted the harder grinding media produced the most efficient grinding.Wet grinding efficiency was found to be dependent on media hardness, while wear under wet grinding was much higher, in general, than that under dry grinding. With respect to mill size it was found that the smaller laboratory mills tended to overemphasise corrosive wear compared with the larger laboratory mills.